We just launched a new feature: My Charts.
See your charts >
10 years after Riesling tasting - 2012
Restaurant Holz und Feuer, Kirchheim, Germany
Tasted May 7, 2022 by NoTrollingerPlease with 697 views
Flight 1 (2 notes)
White
2012 Weingut Keller Hipping Riesling Großes Gewächs
93 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Pale golden color. Clean nose, ripe, sweet fruit, floral notes, lots of crushed stones. On the palate not fully dry, beautiful sweet yellow fruit. Very mineral, nice tension and density. Good balance. Very long and fine. Potential for 5+ years. 93+
Pale golden color. Clean nose, ripe, sweet fruit, floral notes, lots of crushed stones. On the palate not fully dry, beautiful sweet yellow fruit. Very mineral, nice tension and density. Good balance. Very long and fine. Potential for 5+ years. 93+
White
2012 Van Volxem Scharzhofberger Riesling Pergentsknopp
flawed
Unfortunately not a perfect bottle. No TCA bot probably UTA.
Flight 2 (2 notes)
White
2012 Schäfer-Fröhlich Bockenauer Felseneck Riesling Großes Gewächs
94 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, pale golden color. Typical SF nose, that vanishes with air. Otherwise quite smoky and mineral. On the palate dry, very mineral, dense and deep. Great pressure and tension and very long. Liquid stones at its best. Still young, potential for at least 5+ years. 94+
Clear, pale golden color. Typical SF nose, that vanishes with air. Otherwise quite smoky and mineral. On the palate dry, very mineral, dense and deep. Great pressure and tension and very long. Liquid stones at its best. Still young, potential for at least 5+ years. 94+
3 people found this helpful
Comment
White
2012 Dönnhoff Hermannshöhle Riesling Großes Gewächs
93 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, pale golden color. Very floral and fruity nose, very harmonious and deep. On the palate not the immense pressure of the Felseneck, but a very beautiful balance and harmony. Equally mineral. Juicy and very young. 93+
Clear, pale golden color. Very floral and fruity nose, very harmonious and deep. On the palate not the immense pressure of the Felseneck, but a very beautiful balance and harmony. Equally mineral. Juicy and very young. 93+
3 people found this helpful
Comment
Flight 3 (2 notes)
White
2012 Trimbach Riesling Clos Ste. Hune
93 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Bottle was double decanted about 7h before the tasting. Pale yellow color. Muted nose, dense, dark and with some petrol. This wine is completely closed and shows only a glimpse of its future glory. Bone dry, salty mineral notes, wonderful extract and depth. Lean and elegant. Long, very fine and almost shy finish. Re-tasted after about 2h’s and it opened up a bit more and gained complexity. Will be an awesome wine in a decade. Now 92+++
Bottle was double decanted about 7h before the tasting. Pale yellow color. Muted nose, dense, dark and with some petrol. This wine is completely closed and shows only a glimpse of its future glory. Bone dry, salty mineral notes, wonderful extract and depth. Lean and elegant. Long, very fine and almost shy finish. Re-tasted after about 2h’s and it opened up a bit more and gained complexity. Will be an awesome wine in a decade. Now 92+++
2 people found this helpful
Comment
White
2012 Trimbach Riesling Cuvée Frédéric Emile
92 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Pale golden color. Nose way more open than the CSH, lots of ripe fruit and herbs.
On the palate ready for the show: Lovely pure ripe fruit, salty mineral core, good balance and length. Drink now, but absolutely no need to hurry, will last another decade, but I doubt it will improve. 92-93
Pale golden color. Nose way more open than the CSH, lots of ripe fruit and herbs.
On the palate ready for the show: Lovely pure ripe fruit, salty mineral core, good balance and length. Drink now, but absolutely no need to hurry, will last another decade, but I doubt it will improve. 92-93
2 people found this helpful
Comment
Flight 4 (2 notes)
White
2012 Emrich-Schönleber Halenberg Riesling Großes Gewächs
92 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Pale golden color. Nose with some herbs and some weird medicinal notes, but no flaw of the wine itself. On the palate the classic “dark” and smoky Halenberg notes, fruity, again some medicinal notes. Harmonious and long. 91-92
Pale golden color. Nose with some herbs and some weird medicinal notes, but no flaw of the wine itself. On the palate the classic “dark” and smoky Halenberg notes, fruity, again some medicinal notes. Harmonious and long. 91-92
2 people found this helpful
Comment
White
2012 Schäfer-Fröhlich Monzinger Halenberg Riesling Großes Gewächs
92 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
From Magnum. Pale golden color. SF Sponti nose, not that appealing. But on the palate it really rocked. Classic dark Halenberg mineral core, salty, beautiful tension and pressure, very long finish. Still upside potential. 94 Palate - 2 Pt Nose = 92+
From Magnum. Pale golden color. SF Sponti nose, not that appealing. But on the palate it really rocked. Classic dark Halenberg mineral core, salty, beautiful tension and pressure, very long finish. Still upside potential. 94 Palate - 2 Pt Nose = 92+
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Flight 5 (2 notes)
White
2012 Wittmann Westhofener Brunnenhauschen Riesling Großes Gewächs
93 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, medium golden color. Medium+ intense nose with some sweet fruit and some lactic notes. On the palate dry, good mineral core. A bit unbalanced acidity, making this wine a bit sweet/sour. Still very young. Good length and potential. 92-93+
Clear, medium golden color. Medium+ intense nose with some sweet fruit and some lactic notes. On the palate dry, good mineral core. A bit unbalanced acidity, making this wine a bit sweet/sour. Still very young. Good length and potential. 92-93+
White
2012 Weingut Keller Abts E® Riesling Großes Gewächs
93 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, pale golden color. Beautiful airy, herbaceous and stony nose. On the palate quite elegant and very well balanced. Beautiful tension and pressure, lots of ripe sweet fruit and a wonderful mineral core. Juicy and very long. Re-tasted after 2h and it got even more complex. Still a bit too young. Give it 2-3+ years. 93-94+
Clear, pale golden color. Beautiful airy, herbaceous and stony nose. On the palate quite elegant and very well balanced. Beautiful tension and pressure, lots of ripe sweet fruit and a wonderful mineral core. Juicy and very long. Re-tasted after 2h and it got even more complex. Still a bit too young. Give it 2-3+ years. 93-94+
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Flight 6 (1 note)
White
2012 Georg Breuer Rüdesheimer Berg Schloßberg Riesling
96 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, medium golden color. Fantastic nose! Smoky, reductive, very deep, dense and complex. Wow!
Another proof, that power and complexity does not need much alcohol. Only 11,5% abv! This is all about perfect balance and harmony! Power without weight. Beautiful elegant, juicy, salty mineral, smoky and with a beautiful pressure. Very long and complex finish. Probably not at its full peak. 96+
Clear, medium golden color. Fantastic nose! Smoky, reductive, very deep, dense and complex. Wow!
Another proof, that power and complexity does not need much alcohol. Only 11,5% abv! This is all about perfect balance and harmony! Power without weight. Beautiful elegant, juicy, salty mineral, smoky and with a beautiful pressure. Very long and complex finish. Probably not at its full peak. 96+
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Flight 7 (2 notes)
White
2012 Georg Breuer Rauenthaler Nonnenberg Riesling
92 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, medium golden color. Very mineral nose. On the palate lots of sweet fruit, salty, herbaceous. Rather lean, very good balance and good length. Drinks well now, but no need to hurry. 92-93
Clear, medium golden color. Very mineral nose. On the palate lots of sweet fruit, salty, herbaceous. Rather lean, very good balance and good length. Drinks well now, but no need to hurry. 92-93
1 person found this helpful
Comment
White
2012 Weingut Ökonomierat Rebholz Birkweiler Kastanienbusch Riesling Großes Gewächs
94 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, medium golden color. Beautiful complex fruity/herbaceous nose. Not as deep and complex as the Schlossberg, but almost as beautiful.
On the palate wonderful combination of fruit, herbs and floral components. Very mineral, deep and complex. Certainly with power, but never fat or broad. Great tension and pressure! Very long and lingering finish. Still some upscale potential. 94+
Clear, medium golden color. Beautiful complex fruity/herbaceous nose. Not as deep and complex as the Schlossberg, but almost as beautiful.
On the palate wonderful combination of fruit, herbs and floral components. Very mineral, deep and complex. Certainly with power, but never fat or broad. Great tension and pressure! Very long and lingering finish. Still some upscale potential. 94+
Flight 8 (2 notes)
White
2012 A. Christmann Königsbacher Ölberg Riesling Kapelle Trocken Vesteigerungswein/Auction
93 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, medium golden color. Very fine and elegant nose with some cotton candy and herbs. On the palate lots of ripe stone fruit, dense and mineral, some bitter notes. Fine, elegant and with a good balance. Long. 92-93
Clear, medium golden color. Very fine and elegant nose with some cotton candy and herbs. On the palate lots of ripe stone fruit, dense and mineral, some bitter notes. Fine, elegant and with a good balance. Long. 92-93
White
2012 A. Christmann Konigsbacher Idig Riesling Großes Gewächs
93 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
From Magnum. Clear, medium golden color. Dense and deep nose, some smoky notes, some rock flour. On the palate with more power and more of everything than the Ölberg. Also very mineral. Not as elegant and fine, bit with more pressure and tension. Long. Potential for another decade. 93-94
From Magnum. Clear, medium golden color. Dense and deep nose, some smoky notes, some rock flour. On the palate with more power and more of everything than the Ölberg. Also very mineral. Not as elegant and fine, bit with more pressure and tension. Long. Potential for another decade. 93-94
Flight 9 (2 notes)
White
2012 Peter Jakob Kühn Riesling Schlehdorn
87 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, deep golden color. A bit oxidized nose, a bit old and tired.
On the palate apple must, jodine, very mineral. Like an old Champagne without bubbles. Bottle was not flawed, but just past peak. 87-88
Clear, deep golden color. A bit oxidized nose, a bit old and tired.
On the palate apple must, jodine, very mineral. Like an old Champagne without bubbles. Bottle was not flawed, but just past peak. 87-88
1 person found this helpful
Comments (2)
White
2012 Koehler-Ruprecht Kallstadter Saumagen Riesling Auslese trocken "R"
90 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, medium golden color. Very lean and meagre notes. On the palate very juicy and mineral, but also lean and meagre. Good balance, salty finish. Knowing this wine for years I would say it just way too young and needs another decade to fully shine. I will not touch my remaining bottles for 5+ years. 90-91++
Clear, medium golden color. Very lean and meagre notes. On the palate very juicy and mineral, but also lean and meagre. Good balance, salty finish. Knowing this wine for years I would say it just way too young and needs another decade to fully shine. I will not touch my remaining bottles for 5+ years. 90-91++
Flight 10 (2 notes)
White
2012 Wittmann Westhofener Kirchspiel Riesling Großes Gewächs
93 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, pale golden color. Stony, mineral nose. On the palate a surprisingly beautiful Kirchspiel that is mainly focused on its structure and mineral core. Deep, nice tension and very long. Drink now – 5 years. 92-93
Clear, pale golden color. Stony, mineral nose. On the palate a surprisingly beautiful Kirchspiel that is mainly focused on its structure and mineral core. Deep, nice tension and very long. Drink now – 5 years. 92-93
1 person found this helpful
Comment
White
2012 Weingut Knoll Riesling Smaragd Ried Schütt
91 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, pale golden color. Very floral, expressive nose. On the palate ripe fruit, tiny bit of botrytis. Beautiful elegance and balance. Long finish. 91-92
Clear, pale golden color. Very floral, expressive nose. On the palate ripe fruit, tiny bit of botrytis. Beautiful elegance and balance. Long finish. 91-92
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Flight 11 - Pirate flight (2 notes)
White
2012 Wittmann Westhofener Morstein Riesling Großes Gewächs
94 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Popped and poured. Clear, pale golden color. Beautiful complex, smoky nose, dense and deep.
On the palate Morstein at its best. Smoky, dark mineral core, deep and dense. Great pressure and tension. Wonderful power, but very elegantly wrapped. Long finish. Bright and shiny future ahead. 94+
Popped and poured. Clear, pale golden color. Beautiful complex, smoky nose, dense and deep.
On the palate Morstein at its best. Smoky, dark mineral core, deep and dense. Great pressure and tension. Wonderful power, but very elegantly wrapped. Long finish. Bright and shiny future ahead. 94+
1 person found this helpful
Comment
White
2012 Weingut Keller Morstein Riesling Großes Gewächs
92 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Perfect bottle, bought at release. Double decanted about 8h before. Clear, pale golden color. Very muted nose, not showing much.
On the palate a beautiful wine, but compared to the Wittmann he completely lost in every way. Lacks the tension and energy I usually admire in this wine. Probably this wine needs a decade to develop. It certainly has all the components. But today it was simply a disappointment on a very high level. 92 (++)
Perfect bottle, bought at release. Double decanted about 8h before. Clear, pale golden color. Very muted nose, not showing much.
On the palate a beautiful wine, but compared to the Wittmann he completely lost in every way. Lacks the tension and energy I usually admire in this wine. Probably this wine needs a decade to develop. It certainly has all the components. But today it was simply a disappointment on a very high level. 92 (++)
Flight 12 (2 notes)
White
2012 Dr. Bürklin-Wolf Forster Kirchenstück Riesling
93 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, pale golden color. Interesting green notes and stems, fresh and lean.
On the palate it is all about extract and structure, not about fruit. Very mineral, deep and dense. Lean body. Very good balance and tension. Way too young. Give it another decade. 93-94+
Clear, pale golden color. Interesting green notes and stems, fresh and lean.
On the palate it is all about extract and structure, not about fruit. Very mineral, deep and dense. Lean body. Very good balance and tension. Way too young. Give it another decade. 93-94+
White
2012 von Winning Forster Kirchenstück Riesling Großes Gewächs
92 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, pale golden color. Herbaceous nose, some fresh Curry herbs. On the palate quite nice, but lacks the extract, definition and precision of the Bürklin-Wolf. Warm ripe fruit, again some Curry herbs, good length. Will certainly last for a few more years, but will most probably not improve. 91-92
Clear, pale golden color. Herbaceous nose, some fresh Curry herbs. On the palate quite nice, but lacks the extract, definition and precision of the Bürklin-Wolf. Warm ripe fruit, again some Curry herbs, good length. Will certainly last for a few more years, but will most probably not improve. 91-92
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Flight 13 (3 notes)
White
2012 Franz Hirtzberger Riesling Smaragd Singerriedel
95 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, pale golden color. Classic Wachau nose, lots of acacia, crushed stones and ripe stone fruit.
This wine clearly polarizes. You either love the style or you hate it. I love it. Full bodied, but the power is beautifully wrapped and the wine is elegant and in a very good balance. Clear fruit, clear botrytis. Acacia and honey. Wonderful pressure and tension. Long and lingering finish. No need to hurry, will stay on this level for a decade and will probably improve. 94-95+
Clear, pale golden color. Classic Wachau nose, lots of acacia, crushed stones and ripe stone fruit.
This wine clearly polarizes. You either love the style or you hate it. I love it. Full bodied, but the power is beautifully wrapped and the wine is elegant and in a very good balance. Clear fruit, clear botrytis. Acacia and honey. Wonderful pressure and tension. Long and lingering finish. No need to hurry, will stay on this level for a decade and will probably improve. 94-95+
1 person found this helpful
Comment
White
2012 F.X. Pichler Riesling Unendlich
93 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, pale golden color. Classic Wachau nose, lots of acacia, crushed stones, fresh.
Yes it is fat and bold. But also with great pressure, depth and density. Lots of acacia and honey notes, wonderful mineral core. Wonderful extract. Good balance and length, but not “endless”.
92-93
Clear, pale golden color. Classic Wachau nose, lots of acacia, crushed stones, fresh.
Yes it is fat and bold. But also with great pressure, depth and density. Lots of acacia and honey notes, wonderful mineral core. Wonderful extract. Good balance and length, but not “endless”.
92-93
White
2012 F.X. Pichler Riesling Smaragd Ried Kellerberg
91 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Clear, medium golden color. There is a huge discussion if FX Pichler had some wine making problems in 2011/2012. This Kellerberg had clear notes of band aid on nose and palate. Other than that it is a very good mineral Wachau Riesling with a beautiful tension and very good balance. Is it flawed? Depends on the view point. I will rate it 91-92
Clear, medium golden color. There is a huge discussion if FX Pichler had some wine making problems in 2011/2012. This Kellerberg had clear notes of band aid on nose and palate. Other than that it is a very good mineral Wachau Riesling with a beautiful tension and very good balance. Is it flawed? Depends on the view point. I will rate it 91-92
Flight 14 - Some after tasting reds (3 notes)
Red
2001 Château Montrose
93 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Tasted double blind. Clear, deep ruby color. Beautiful left bank BDX nose, cool, spicy and herbaceous. On the palate a beautiful tension, fine, high tannin, lots of fine red fruit, silky texture. Dense and long. Very nice. 92-93
Tasted double blind. Clear, deep ruby color. Beautiful left bank BDX nose, cool, spicy and herbaceous. On the palate a beautiful tension, fine, high tannin, lots of fine red fruit, silky texture. Dense and long. Very nice. 92-93
Red
2015 Bernhard Huber Malterdinger Bienenberg Spätburgunder Großes Gewächs
91 points
No notes taken. Beautiful German Spätburgunder, still in its teenage years. Drinks beautiful right now but has upscale potential 91++
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Red
2009 Domaine Armand Rousseau Père et Fils Clos de la Roche
94 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Popped and poured. Fine herbaceous, spicy nose with lots of fine red fruit. Dense.
On the palate rather cool, very elegant and fine. Rather dark fruit. Salty mineral notes. Beautiful balance and harmony. Great pressure and very good length. Close to greatness. 94+
Popped and poured. Fine herbaceous, spicy nose with lots of fine red fruit. Dense.
On the palate rather cool, very elegant and fine. Rather dark fruit. Salty mineral notes. Beautiful balance and harmony. Great pressure and very good length. Close to greatness. 94+
Flight 15 - Sweet end (1 note)
White - Off-dry
1988 Joh. Jos. Prüm Wehlener Sonnenuhr Riesling Auslese Goldkapsel
94 points
Glass: Sophienwald Universal
Popped and poured. Wow. What a beauty! So fresh and balanced. Beautiful acidity, wonderful fruit. So young. Very long and complex finish. Great! 94-95
Popped and poured. Wow. What a beauty! So fresh and balanced. Beautiful acidity, wonderful fruit. So young. Very long and complex finish. Great! 94-95