Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(128 comments on 111 notes)

1 - 50 of 111 Sort order
Red
2019 Les Celliers de Meknes 1er Cru Château Roslane Les Coteaux de L'Atlas Red Blend
11/29/2022 - Livonietisr Likes this wine:
92 points
Best marocan red tasted till now. Deep garnet color. Aromas of black currant, cherry, pepper, mint, leather, smoke. Dry, balanced, fruity, velvety, very easy drinking. Medium finish.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    5/11/23, 12:38 PM - So I just got a bottle of the 2020 vintage. Do you have any ideas about the drinking window of this wine, approximately?

  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    5/19/23, 7:37 AM - thanks!

Red
2018 Domaine François de Nicolay Ladoix Les Briquottes Pinot Noir
7/25/2021 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
90 points
Very interesting what a year can do to a wine. Now really shock-full of pinosity - my wife took one sniff and one sip and then she said: oh, my, you really opened up something fancy tonight, didn't you? Still has freshness and structure and should be even better down the line. Excellent.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    9/11/22, 10:18 PM - Tack för kommentar! Agreed, wish I had a case of this stuff in my cellar. Why don’t you add your own tasting note and rating as well?

White - Sparkling
2008 Henriot Champagne Brut Millésimé Champagne Blend
1/28/2022 - Elvis1969 wrote:
89 points
Alldeles för ung ännu. Var rätt bra dag 3 men vänta helst i tio år med att korka upp.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    7/2/22, 1:24 PM - intressant - jag tycker att Henriots 2006:or har börjat öppna sig ganska mycket senaste två åren eller så. Prövade den första 2008:an i förrgår och har några flaskor i källaren. Väntar nog ett tag men skulle nog inte spara di tio-tjugo år?

  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    7/6/22, 7:05 AM - Tack!

Red
2013 Ridge Merlot Estate Santa Cruz Mountains
7/2/2022 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
94 points
Really shining with some grilled Iberico Secreto. Has so much fruit and chocolatey loveliness on the nose that you almost miss the sandpaper fine tannins and the very well balanced finish on this beauty. Lovely. I said hedonistic but my friends argued for melancholic. It probably is both.

Edit: upped the score - it was so good and everyone else had this as the WOTN (I had a Stony Hill 2010 Cabernet and a Arnot Robert’s Trout Gulch 2015 Chardonnay as my WOTN.)
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    7/3/22, 6:46 AM - Thx for the question! It was ready to go right after pulling the cork and then it kept steady for 3-4 hours (no decant). Maybe even grew some during that time but lovely throughout the meal.

Red
2016 Raul Pérez Bierzo Ultreia Valtuille Mencía
2/20/2021 - Stanrocks Likes this wine:
89 points
Blind

Nose of southern style white wine, dried wild anise, fennel, very mediterranean herbs

palate is med acid, with spice, white pepper, quite southernly as well, dried citrus and lemon peel, quite powerful, med+ length I thought of Clairette or Bouboulenc ... :) godello
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    6/23/22, 2:10 PM - hi there and thank you for your very fine tasting note, just to say that I think you may have entered it for the wrong wine? The Valtuille is a red wine made with Mencia.

Red
2014 Domaine de L'Aurage Castillon Côtes de Bordeaux Red Bordeaux Blend
5/5/2019 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
94 points
Ooh,lala! A new favorite. Long time since I felt so excited by a merlot. This has the same crazy opulent fruit as a Shafer but with the balance of a Le Macchiole. Ripe plums, black cherries, milk chocolate of the finest persuasion and a long fresh finish. Has grip but its sandpaper like and hidden amongst all the sweet fruit and velvety texture. Great now (better pop'n'pour than day 2), but will certainly be good for a long time, but I think there's no knowing if the balance will be as perfect ten years from now. Mitjavile Jr. strikes a home run in a not-so-heralded-year with a Cotes de Castillon.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    1/24/22, 1:49 PM - thx for reading and posting a comment!

    No, cab franc and merlot. Not sure about the split. But the cab franc had no green pyrazines and felt integral and thus equally ripe. A little bit like a Le Macchiole Cab Franc come to think of it. Or something from Napa.

    I loved it but please see the other notes as well. I bought a couple of bottles of this from two different sources and there was real difference between the two sources. For the record, the not as great but still very good bottles were bought from the Swedish government retail monopoly store. Guessing someone had a batch that was less than optimally stored and off-loaded on us poor Swedes...

Red - Fortified
2011 Duorum Porto Vintage Port Blend
12/25/2018 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
95 points
christmas dinner (at our home): On the bottle it says that this was bottled in 2013, I am not really sure about the various entries for the wines of Duorum here, but would just for the record state that this was probably the best port I've had. Dense, yet light on its feet with good acidity and harmonious seamless fruit and wonderful texture that never gets cloyingly sweet nor harsh and bitter from tannic structure. This drinks so well now but has the makings for a century worth of storing it feels like.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    11/12/21, 11:28 PM - jag tyckte det var topp notch! Tror dock att priset när jag köpte den var runt 600 kr för en 75 cl-flaska så litet dyrare nu men verkligen ett bra köp skulle jag säga!

Red
2010 Tenuta delle Terre Nere Etna Rosso Calderara Sottana Etna DOC Nerello Blend, Nerello Mascalese
4/22/2021 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
97 points
The ugly duckling has turned into a swan! The tannins have mellowed but their imprint is noticeable as a sort of background structure. The red berries feel youthful and complex. The attack is, well, not soft, but very very fine. The freshness is all there.

And the minerality is laced around the fruit in a way that makes me think of Clos Rougeard or Thierry Germain cab franc (Domaine des Roche Neuve).

Extremely delish and at the same time contemplative and structured, but in a way that feels so much more light in style than when I tried the first bottle in 2013. Well worth the wait!
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    4/24/21, 1:23 AM - Tack för kommentaren! jag hade faktiskt gett upp hoppet om denna producent och detta vin. Otroligt vacker flaska.

  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    10/6/21, 9:05 AM - thx for commenting!

Red
2002 Château Léoville Barton St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
7/3/2021 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
93 points
Blind tasting with the three amigos (chez moi): The most backward bottle of the four we opened, on the other hand it was not as sullen after the cork was pulled as the La Mission Haut-Brion 2002 but it actually stayed very much in character over ten hours so obviously has much more to give. We all liked this very much but no one had it as the best wine in the line up. Very very classic Medoc and St Julien whereas the other 2002 wines maybe were not as easy to pick out blind in terms of geography within Bordeaux. Lean, black fruit, elegant, savory, a little peppery and dry but with a velvety palate and a rather long, grippy finish.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    7/4/21, 7:55 AM - Mark and Harley - thx for commenting. A great night indeed and I was surprised at how much I liked all these 2002s. Feels like one should take advantage of the still much lower prices this vintage fetches at auctions relative to other vintages from the same decade.

Red
2019 Familia Zuccardi Malbec Concreto Altamira
6/12/2021 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
92 points
This is how I like my Malbecs! Raised in concrete egg but still fruity and structured, there is more of an emphasis on licorice root tea, violets, black cherries, fresh blueberries from the north and maybe a touch of raw meat as well. Lovely grip and freshness, this was poured from a Magnum (two magnums in fact) and I think it's a real keeper.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    6/12/21, 11:20 AM - Hittade bara på Magnum men kändes väldigt fräsch och fin redan nu men som om den också skulle klara flera år (särskit på magnum) i källaren. Jag har i praktiken slutat köpa Malbec från Argentina för jag tycker de ofta är för sönderekade och tungt extraherade. Detta var dock mycket bra! Och absolut inget lätt vin för den skull.

Red
2006 Kapcsándy Family Winery Estate Cuvée State Lane Vineyard Yountville Red Bordeaux Blend
5/21/2021 - Sundbyberg wrote:
92 points
Tasting: Very good but I liked it better laste time, a few weeks ago. I think the 2-3 hour decant last time made a difference.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    5/21/21, 12:54 PM - I had a similar experience with my second bottle tonight, very good, but not as good as last time when I aired it a lot longer.

White
2018 Grosset Riesling Polish Hill Clare Valley
9/2/2020 - streethawk Likes this wine:
93 points
Very good right now, with potential to develop into something great with another 5-10 years of bottle age. Notes of petrol, white flowers, slate on the nose. The palate has the bright acidity and laser-sharp focus found in the best Riesling expressions from across the world, like a solitary ray of sunshine. Slight bitterness on the back palate. Overall, a very enjoyable wine that I expect will only gain in complexity with some more time.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    5/6/21, 1:26 PM - Yes! very apt comment on this wine. Drinking the 2017 now and went back to check on my notes from the '18 vintage, agree very much with your note. Very interesting combination of that sunripe body with a dash of petrol and yet an extremely lean and grassy (almost soapy) finish with a really acidic bite that rolls on the tongue for a long long time.

White
2019 Cà dei Frati Lugana I Frati Turbiana, Verdicchio
3/13/2021 - Omar Khayyam wrote:
88 points
Early days for this one. very aromatic on the nose with verbena soap, mandarins, fresh lime peel. On the palate sweet mandarin fruit attack followed by a little bitter grapefruit kernel and peel finish. Perfect texture! good freshness. Not all together yet. Save for 3-5 years and drink with food, perhaps grilled swordfish or tuna with some fresh salsa. Like many of these verdicchios the qtr is great compared to many other famous white wines of the world. 88 now but potential for 90 points later on for sure.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    4/13/21, 11:04 AM - Thx for commenting! yes, super confusing. Turbiana and Trebbiano di Lugana are other alias for Verdicchio. NB Ca Dei Frati makes a slightly more expensive wine, the Pratto, which is not as much Verdicchio and I actually prefer the cheaper I Frati Lugana (i.e. this wine). I never have the patience for storing these wines for as long as my Italian brother-in-law and more knowledgeable wine friends tell me is needed to bring out the real inherent complexity in these Italian Verdicchios be they from Lugana or Castelli di Jesi or Matelica. Simply too delish and inexpensive and food friendly to keep around for too long.

Red
2015 By Farr Pinot Noir "Farrside" Geelong
4/6/2021 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
93 points
I really liked the intensity on this one: at first there is the telltale By Farr cooked beet but luckily it goes away, leaving a very complete nose with a lot of the kind of pinosity that I have come to appreciate from reasonably oaked Oregon pinot noirs, which this resembles: vanilla, mature strawberries, black cherries, wet soil, undergrowth, licorice root tea, and some slightly stemmy tulips (that also blows off with decanting) and a little truffle. Finish is long and powerful and ends on a hoisin sauce note. It manages to be elegant and deftly oaked with a lot of freshness but also with fruit and power - a Pinot for the Syrah lovers.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    4/7/21, 12:09 AM - Hi and thx for commenting! I've had mixed results with By Farr wines, but all seem built to handle cellaring for up to 10 years from the vintage, without a doubt. For this one, my feeling was that it is drinking really well right now with a decant so why bother saving if you only have one bottle, but if you have more, I'd say that it would be interesting to see how this evolves over the next 5 or so years.

    Beyond that I have no experience of what to expect so it's hard to have a firm opinion, but I would not be surprised if it would be perfectly fine, but perhaps not necessarily better, ten years from now.

White
2016 Hubert Lamy Saint-Aubin La Princée Blanc Chardonnay
3/25/2021 - Mark van Delft wrote:
89 points
Average St Aubin: lychee, minerals, white peach, soft toast, grapefruit, some rough acidic edges, especially in the finish, there are better options out there in St Aubin.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    3/26/21, 12:01 AM - thx for the note, I agree with your overall conclusion. Have one bottle left which I will leave a bit further just to see what happens, but I don't have very high expectations. Clear difference between this and the more high end En Remilly from the same producer.

Red
2006 Kapcsándy Family Winery Estate Cuvée State Lane Vineyard Yountville Red Bordeaux Blend
3/6/2021 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
92 points
When a big batch of this wine landed in Stockholm, released on the state monopoly, most wine friends I know felt instinctively that something must be wrong for a wine of this pedigree from Napa, with age, at a reasonable price (well, 100 USD is 100 USD and not cheap by any means), to drop on us ill fortunate Swedes in the middle of winter. I took a bet on a different theory: that maybe this was a vintage with less ripe fruit and less grippy tannins and less concentration, which usually does not appeal to the well to do crowd that still buys Napa reds in expensive steak restaurants around the country. Maybe some retailer was feeling the pressure from the Covid-recession? Maybe the high percentage of merlot in the early vintages of the estate cuvée from Kapcsandy (later on brought down to about a fifth as I understand it) meant that at this stage in the wine's cellar journey, the grip and fruit was softened to understated velvet textured elegance?

Well, I think we both were right. This is an utterly delicious Napa wine with lovely budding mature notes on the nose, an easy to drink velvet texture, with a slightly hollow mid palate, creating a feeling of lightness. Which, for my part, I adore as it marries the best of two types of wines I really enjoy - classic Bordeaux and lighter fresher reds.

Excellent wine, but maybe the sirloin and rather acidic sauce bearnaise and grilled veggies was a bit too much, with a gruyere it shone. Recommended but not if you are into big Napa wines. And I have no idea of the drinking window on this one, but there's no hurry, and at the same time, probably would not save my second bottle for another ten years for sure.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    3/7/21, 11:08 PM - thx for commenting and very interesting to hear your view on the 2006 vintage in Napa!

Red
2014 Domaine Coursodon St. Joseph L'Olivaie Syrah
2/14/2020 - tymon Does not like this wine:
85 points
Nice fruit overshadowed by oak. Light tannins, medium plus acidity. Pleasant enough if you enjoy oaky wines. Good potential, but any Rhône characteristics are difficult to spot because of the new oak.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    2/6/21, 5:35 AM - Agree completely and I think this sums up Coursodon quite well - in really good vintages the fruit can match their new oak regime, but most often what you describe is the result. I am guessing that they are trying to implement a more serious northern rhone style on what is essentially vineyard material that should be better of in a light and fresh cross-hermitage style.

Red
2016 Frank Cornelissen MunJebel CS Terre Siciliane Nerello Mascalese
4/12/2020 - tymon wrote:
93 points
Starts of with some funky horse stable and leather (so saddle in sum, I guess), and a VA aroma that is a bit over the top (even though I enjoy VA aromas in general). The aroma balances out very nicely after a couple of hours in the decanter, bringing out juicy, tart, dark stone fruits, with the touch of VA adding a crisp juicyness on top. Further back there is smokiness, spice and some nice and round earthy aromas reminiscent of rooibos tea and slightly sulphuric edge. A complex and striking aroma.

Very juicy and clean on the palate, with an impressive structure. Both tannins and acidity is high, but well balanced with the impressive body of the wine. It lingers on with taste of plums and cherries, and the gripping tannins. The concentration is astounding, and the after taste is very long with both tannins and acidity staying on for a long time, together with some of the smokiness. On day two it it’s still just as lovely, even though the aromas are a bit less in your face, but the VA aroma is now completely integrated.

The wine still has a lot of potential, and I’ll wait for a couple of years with the next bottle, as the fruit is still super fresh and can match more tertiary aromas.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    2/6/21, 5:33 AM - very good review! Thx for posting!

Red
2006 Château Léoville Barton St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
2/15/2020 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
94 points
Time to check in with the '06 Leoville Barton. Nose is full on developed with classic cabernet dominated St Julien markers, but also more opulent dark chocolate and some spice box. Quite generous in fact. On the palate there is much structure left to be resolved, and it is more strict. Drinking really well with grilled meat right now but there is a long term race going on between the fruit and the structure. If they find a harmonious truce it will be truly great. Meanwhile quite ok to approach already now.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    2/16/20, 1:08 AM - Thx for commenting!

  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    1/25/21, 1:25 PM - @Magnum PI - thx for commenting and if you open a bottle, let us know how it is doing and what your thoughts are!

White
2018 Patrick Piuze Chablis Terroir de la Chapelle Chardonnay
Winebar [3 Whites, 8 Reds, & 6 *shared* bottles] from 06/26/20 (Vintage Wines Ltd., San Diego, CA): Cf. the CellarTracker Article link [lower lft] to get specific info for this vintage, including acclaim.

N: Closed; Minerals, flint, poss smoke, with hints of caramel

P: MF body; RNDISH entry with very NICE, ALMOST swtish frt beautifully counterbalanced by an acidity which flows into a LONG, BALANCED, TANGY/swt (60:40) finish that is already showing impending elegance. DESERVES through '21, then drinking through '24 without difficulty. Impressively done! My EXC, poss even higher down the line? [This vendor's $30.95 would put it in the middle of wine-searcher's 3 postings.]
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    11/9/20, 11:26 PM - Thanks for commenting above and thanks for pointing me to the CT article (have somehow missed this feature before). Excellent. Keep up the good work!

Red
2017 Badenhorst Family Wines Cinsault Ramnasgras Swartland
1/18/2020 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
92 points
Really very good. Nose has red berries, some clove perhaps but only so much as to give it a dash of really enticing complexity akin to sniffing on a good Pinot noir or Grenache. On the palate silky texture, great freshness, linear, roses and raspberries. Very fine and highly recommended.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    10/23/20, 9:19 AM - @Genghis - thx for commenting and let us know what you think

White
2018 Domaine Cauhapé Jurançon Sec Geyser Manseng Blend
9/18/2020 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
90 points
Very good bang for the buck! The varietal mix include all five white grapes of the appellation: 30% gros manseng, 30% petit manseng, 30% camaralet, 5% lauzet and 5% courbu.

The name is aptly chosen as it offers a veritable explosion of flavor and aromas, lots of tropical fruit, lots of spice, all against the backbone of a fat texture, stringent acidity and rather elegant finish. They suggest to pair it with grilled fish and you wouldn't go wrong for doing so, but we tried also with a flavorful risotto with wild mushrooms and salsiccia and the wine was by no means overpowered in that context either. Really nice, but even better on day two when it had calmed down somewhat aromatically, imho.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    10/18/20, 11:38 AM - @PAOK Wines Brussels - Thx for commenting! I agree it's very aromatic. I found it better day two when some of the most wild and tropical aromas had calmed down. Translations of fish names can be tricky as the categories hide the many (sometimes hundreds) of different varieties that exist around the globe. In Sweden, Bream is a white fish with many small bones but delicious white flesh that has some fat to it so that it can take some spices when you grill it - if you do that then maybe this wine would be a good pairing, but I agree, with the classic white fish grilled and served with salt and fresh lemon - nothing beats a good (unoaked!) assyrtiko.

Red
2008 Domaine du Vieux Télégraphe Châteauneuf-du-Pape La Crau Red Rhone Blend
10/10/2020 - markcic Likes this wine:
91 points
We went to visit one of my wife's sisters who live upstate NY 125 miles away. Even though I supplied the dinner wines I did not partake as driving home at night on dark country roads after a few glasses of wine is just not my thing. So when we got home I opened a 375 and decanted it and let it sit while I had a glass of Sancerre. Found some chicken in the fridge and had my midnight snack. The nose on the wine was cherry and red plum. The palate was dark cherry, red plum, cigar and hints of spice. The finish was moderate to long. I would really like to be able to try this wine in a larger format with a longer decant as I believe it would develop further. Overall very enjoyable.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    10/12/20, 1:25 PM - Thanks for the note! I am saving my 2008 a bit longer. Your moment feels very much like something out of Philippe Delerms book https://www.amazon.com/Small-Pleasures-Life-Philippe-Delerm/dp/1861591160
    - the well deserved reward after an evening at the in-laws, with a long drive and no drink (of course!).

Red
2014 Sami-Odi Shiraz XIV Barossa
3/24/2018 - Omar Khayyam wrote:
90 points
DBYOB (stockholm): So sweet, full of oven roasted root veggies similar to Melville. The bottle shape had me thinking this was a piedrasassi with some sunshine in it. Still, in spite of the over the top nose, the body was quite balanced. I liked it, but still it paled in the presence of the other two syrahs in the flight.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    10/11/20, 11:01 PM - Thx for commenting! If you click on the tasting story link "DBYOB (stockholm)" you get to the tasting notes for Reynvaan and Guigals Ch d'Ampuis.

Red
2017 Domaine des Roches Neuves Saumur-Champigny Les Mémoires Cabernet Franc
9/6/2020 - The Guzz wrote:
91 points
Dark in color. Purple fruit. Very lifted, packed with stones and minerality. All stone, chalk, and cranberry on the nose. Takes a few hours to smooth out. A touch austere with some green elements. Great tension. Should be very good with time.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    9/7/20, 9:08 AM - Thx for the review! I have one bottle, sounds like I should save it for another 2-3 years at least?

White
2017 Anne et Jean-Francois Ganevat Victor de la Combe Vin de France Chardonnay
5/9/2020 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
90 points
Stony, chalky and made in an oxidative style but more green apples than yellow apples in the bin. 100 % chardonnay from Macon. Much more restrained than for example the 2015 Les Gryphées from Ganevat and the Domaine Valette Mâcon-Chaintré 2014 vieilles vignes tasted earlier this year. Could probably do with another year or two in the cellar. But drinking really well already. slightly spritzy day one and better day two.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    8/25/20, 12:03 PM - Thx for commenting!

    And yes, absolutely sound and very delish at that. For me 90 points is a high score.

    And no, this is not sous voile, but absolutely is there an oxidative style for some of these wines that comes from the winemaking (or the yeast culture in the cave or any other contextual influence) compared to for example a steel tanked chablis that is more pure green apple and lemon. There are some producers in the Jura and Burgundy who do things even more borderline, probably through wine making where one does not worry to much about oxidative risks, or even seek these out without going near sherry/vin jaune. I actually think many Jura producers do a bit of a balancing act where they push the ouillé style a bit in this direction. It's like their biggest fear is reduction and the crisp monotonous steel tank style of chardonnay. This is what I mean in this context by oxidative style.

    Cheers and keep enjoying your Ganevat whites, they're generally awesome!

Red
2017 Domaine Sylvain Pataille Marsannay Clos du Roy Pinot Noir
1/31/2020 - Collector1855 wrote:
92 points
Expressive nose of blackberries, sweet spices, licorice, sandal wood. Well measured palate, elegant with good structure. Nice showing of this appellation, glad to see that the less famous places in Burg are doing better and better, making good QPR Pinots available. 92+
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    8/13/20, 1:33 PM - yes, agree very much! Best Clos du Roy (or Marsannay for that matter) that I've tasted. Very often the wines of the appellation - in the past - that I've tried, have shown mostly dark fruit and grippy structure, in a generally well done and decent style but just slightly monotonous; here you have some real pinot complexity in terms of sweet fruit, spice, wet soil as well as very great freshness.

Red
2012 Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon Estate Santa Cruz Mountains
8/6/2020 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
94 points
Great cabernet fruit with cassis, some fresh blueberries, some pipe tobacco, coarsely ground black pepper and brilliant acidity and long finish with a medium body creating a feeling of an easy-drinking claret that is still not bashful about its Californian fruit. There is a grip and substance but it is sand paper elegant and ready to journey for another decade in your cellar if you so wish but also great with some grilled Black Onyx Entrecôte in the warm summer evening.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    8/8/20, 2:32 AM - Thx for commenting! Enjoy the wines! I had bought four and have one left...

Red
2005 Thomas Pinot Noir Dundee Hills
7/27/2020 - arthrovine wrote:
flawed
Damn. Have been sitting on these awhile. This was an imbalanced wine marred by VA.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    7/31/20, 12:45 PM - I feel you. They are indeed hit-and-miss in that sense. but the good ones are truly among the absolute greatest wines I have ever tasted.

Red
2006 Montevetrano Montevetrano Colli di Salerno IGT Red Blend
7/26/2020 - Kris G Likes this wine:
92 points
Full bodied and rich showing with mainly black fruits, minerals and toasted impressions. It gives a good reflection of its volcanic surface. Powerful wine but it keeps its tension so it doesn't become boring after 1 glass. Well done!
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    7/27/20, 5:24 AM - Thx for the note. What do you think of the cellar window for this wine?

  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    7/28/20, 3:23 AM - Thx!

White
2016 Arnot-Roberts Chardonnay Watson Ranch Napa Valley
7/26/2020 - acidqueen wrote:
90 points
I always love the Watson Ranch, and this was good, but it wasn’t in the same league as other years. I agree with a few others who mentioned that this was getting “weighty”. It was rounder and fuller than I have had in other vintages, and there was a hint of butter/caramel on the finish. I am going to drink the rest of mine up in the next 12 months and then proceed to the 2017.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    7/27/20, 5:23 AM - thx for the note. Sounds like this should be chilled a bit more than normal to bring out the freshness?

  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    7/27/20, 9:33 AM - Thx for replying and absolutely, this is good wine. I have popped one of my two 2016 Watsons and it just felt like it was really good grape material, but something went wrong with the malolactic or such chemical reaction. So saved my remaining bottle for now. I really enjoyed the 2014 AR Watson (and trout Gulch), especially on release. They do age well, but there is a springy energy to these chardonnays early on that I really like.

Red
2015 RdV Vineyards Lost Mountain Fauquier County Red Bordeaux Blend
6/21/2020 - EricKnick Likes this wine:
94 points
Deep ruby color. Blackberry, black cherry, and earth on the nose. Tastes of blackberry, black currant, fig, dark chocolate, leather, and mocha. Balanced acid, subtle tannins, and a beautiful long finish. Good now with a decant but time in the cellar will pay dividends. I’ll dispense with the cliche comparisons to Napa and Bordeaux benchmarks and instead note this wine is a great reflection of its terroir in the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains. Undoubtably, this is Virginia’s red wine standard bearer.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    6/28/20, 5:07 AM - ErickNick - couldn't agree more with you. Thanks for the note. I have a bottle stored away and will wait at least another five years I think.

Red
2014 Ojai Syrah White Hawk Vineyard Santa Barbara County
6/27/2020 - Puteljen! wrote:
90 points
This bottle came across as overly sweet and packed with lots of vanilla and almost cooked fruit. Rich, heady but still fair balance thanks to the fair amount of acids present. Still drinking nicely and Very nice with grilled tenderloin, gremolata and potato sallad but not up to previous bottles.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    6/28/20, 5:04 AM - Thanks for the note.

    I had a similar experience between two bottles of this wine, sampled 2017 and 2018 -just a year later it felt a little bit more out of balance in terms of sweetness, beet and soy notes. Still really good, but not as much all in one place and linear as I remembered it.

    I chalked it up to poor storage on my part but perhaps it is a more general development. I will save my remaining bottle a while to see if it recovers some previous splendor.

Red
2018 Savage Wines Thief in the Night Piekenierskloof Red Blend
3/1/2020 - ludwigbpm wrote:
91 points
Une peu de kitsch au nez, des épices, des fines herbes perceptibles en finale, un vin assez aromatique et séducteur. L’alcool ressort un peu malgré le simple 13% affiché. Delicieux.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    5/30/20, 6:56 AM - long time fan Ludwig. Have you tried other Duncan Savage wines? What are you're thoughts there?

    ps Kirsch au lieu de Kitsch n'est ce pas? ;)

Red
2018 Savage Wines Syrah The Girl Next Door Coastal Region
3/16/2020 - sidaga Likes this wine:
91 points
Robe pourpre sombre;
Nez très parfumé & le devient de plus en plus avec le temps, la trame florale est omniprésente du début à la fin. Fruité foncé (cassis, cerise), il y a un petit qqchose d'animale (fourrure). Beau nez élégant & intense.
Bouche tout aussi élégante que le nez, en premier temps sur des notes de fruits foncés denses bien supporté par une acidité vive & des notes rocailleuses. Les tannins sont fins & assèchent la finale. Belle bouche quasi aérienne & intense à la fois. Excellent.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    5/30/20, 6:50 AM - je suis tout a fait d'accord avec vous deux sur la qualité des vins de Duncan Savage. Merci pour les notes.

Red
2016 Domaine Trapet Gevrey-Chambertin Pinot Noir
4/29/2020 - Mazy Likes this wine:
90 points
Gevrey-Chambertin 2016: confrontation: S'ouvre rapidement dans le verre. Le nez est discret, délicat. En bouche, il se révèle soyeux, sur les arômes de cassis, et démontre beaucoup de finesse. Les tannins sont légers et très digestes. On ne décèle pas d'élevage apparent. Un Gevrey de grâce qui se boit dangereusement bien.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    5/2/20, 6:56 AM - merci pour le tasting note, Mazy. Si tu avais une autre bouteille, tu l'aurais bu maintenant ou sera-t-il meilleur de la garder encore qq ans?

  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    5/2/20, 8:31 AM - :)

Red
2015 Ruggabellus Archaeus Barossa Valley Red Rhone Blend
4/30/2020 - Trydebull wrote:
Tappade flaskhelvetet!!! Fan! Var verkligen sugen på att testa den hör! Har du två flaskor och vill sälja en - skicka PM!
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    5/1/20, 6:43 AM - kan bara beklaga...

Red
2013 Wynns Coonawarra Estate Cabernet Sauvignon Black Label
3/27/2020 - Omar Khayyam wrote:
88 points
Still quite primary, fruit driven modern cabernet with some oak. Mostly black currants on the palate. With air, the excellent balance stands out. Right now, not so much complexity, but should cellar well for at least a decade. Good value for money also. Was really nice to some grilled, slightly spicy, strip loin steak.

Edit: Day 2 it has filled out nicely. Someone has dropped a chocolate liquor praline in the glass. The sweet&sour is more pronounced, as well as a bouquet of violets and some sweet licorice. Early days. Wait ten years. Expect it to perform slightly higher at peak maturity.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    4/16/20, 10:28 AM - Svårt att säga faktiskt - jag har inte druckit så många cabbar från Coonawarra och från Södra Australien generellt sett har jag mest druckit vin på rhone-druvor från områdena runt Adelaide och sen en del burgundiskt från Yarra valley. Men känslan var att just den här fruktiga och ändå balanserade stilen är rätt typisk.

Red
2010 Château Sociando-Mallet Haut-Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend
1/11/2020 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
91 points
Very good and classic Bordeaux with 55 % Cabernet Sauvignon, 40 % Merlot and 5 % Cabernet Franc; excellent nose with some cassis, plum, tobacco, licorice. On the palate seamless, lean body with a fresh core, with a nice grip and decent finish and most of all purity of fruit. Drinking really well right now to food (we served it with grilled lamb chops), but for really mature complexity I am guessing you have to wait five-ten years. For me this is what I look for in Bordeaux (as opposed to overly woody, spicy and sweet&tannic monster cabs).
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    3/25/20, 12:11 PM - Mark, thx for commenting and much pleasure further down the lane.

White
2016 de Lancellotti Chardonnay Anderson Vineyard Dundee Hills
10/21/2018 - Omar Khayyam wrote:
86 points
There's quality fruit here, for sure. But it is cloaked in oak, heat and spice. Alcohol reads 14.2% on the label but could be more.

Oak is not overwhelming but clearly marks the wine with a buttery imprint.

The fruit is intense; like the peel of old yellow apples, yellow plum and pineapple preserves that has been left for too long in the tin can.

Texture is rich but balanced, with fine acidity. But the finish is overly spicy. I am thinking more in terms of dry Jurançon or South African Chenin Blanc. Has a lot of personality and should perhaps be stored for at least five-seven years.

It's a little much currently. But everything is there ,so for the right palate, this could be great.

Personally though, I look for other qualities in chardonnay.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    2/8/20, 10:54 AM - I think it was not just oak but perhaps more so slightly over ripe fruit. But this is also on the backdrop of some fantastic wines I have had from this producer and from the de Lancelotti vineyard proper. So I had other expectations. Maybe serve it slightly chilled, in a carafe, with some butter milk fried chicken or panko fried cod filet to take the edge of? For USD 25 it's worth a try. Looking forward to hearing from your impressions of the wine.

Red
2016 Buccella Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley
3/24/2019 - Omar Khayyam wrote:
Dream Big - Discover California Wine Tasting (Stockholm, Gamla Riksarkivet (old government archives building) March 2019): AAAARRGHH. The one table I had my mind set on and by the time I got there, all the wine was finished, except for the 2016 Cab, which was so nice. Really lovely and a perfect example of when the Napa fruit shows it's really world class. Complex, for sure this is a big wine, but beautifully balanced and drinkable already now. I think this could go for twenty years and be even better. Highly Recommended.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    2/6/20, 12:02 PM - Hard to say, only had a pour. Say 92-94?

White
2017 Domaine de Chassorney Saint-Romain Combe Bazin Blanc Chardonnay
8/31/2019 - Finare Vinare wrote:
91 points
Aromatically upfront, ripe and fairly powerful, with faint vanilla oak and rich fruit aromas boosted by ethyl acetate. This, together with the 13,5% abv, also contributes to the perceived sweetness on the palate. This is an expressive and rewarding natural-style white Burgundy, although for some palates the level of acetate may be close to comfortable limits. (Disclaimer: ITB with Swedish importer Vin & Natur)
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    9/1/19, 3:55 AM - Tack för bra beskrivning!

    I had a similar experience with Cossards (les) Bigotes, a bourgogne blanc from the same vintage. Excellent wine. It felt like an open question if it would improve much more with cellaring or if the freshness and fruit is best enjoyed during the next year. What's your take on the Combe Bazin (I have only one bottle) in this respect?

Red
2017 Enderle & Moll Pinot Noir Basis Baden
8/2/2019 - Omar Khayyam wrote:
88 points
Sweet raspberries, pale red color, freshness dominant feature. A little short but harmonious. Easy to like and easy to drink. Don’t think this will benefit from cellaring much.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    8/5/19, 12:04 AM - thx for commenting and I am sure you will like these light but fresh German Pinots once they arrive. We had the 2017 Liaison they day after the 2017 Basis and the Basis was actually more open for business at this point, although there is more stuffing in the Liaison which has higher potential for storing I think.

Red
2012 Ojai Syrah White Hawk Vineyard Santa Barbara County
10/26/2018 - Christoffer78 Likes this wine:
95 points
A lovely and absolutely adorable wine with brilliant balance, integration and overall proportions. This wine is drinking superbly right now but will most likely continue to evolve for another decade or more. The 2012 White Hawk exhibits an elegant combination of power, elegance and fruit. The fruit is totally on par with all the other components, yet it speaks up a bit more loudly thanks to the youthfullness of this effort. Power is expressed by a marvelous 50+ second length on the finish! Despite almost ten years rest there is plenty of both texture and a stunning structure. A lovely wine!
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    5/25/19, 6:46 AM - fina tasting notes som alltid Christoffer! Men förstod inte "despite more than ten years rest"?

White
2017 Early Mountain Vineyards Petit Manseng Madison County
4/19/2019 - Omar Khayyam wrote:
92 points
Early Mountain Winery (at the winery with Ben Jordan): Petit Manseng, who'd guessed this was the grape for Virginia? While maybe not so surprising that all the vintners seemed to be doing the same Bordeaux varietals, as well as chardonnay, but the fact that so many were also using this semi-obscure Jurancon white varietal was intriguing.

And in a little sample from yet unbottled wine at Early Mountain, I finally understood why. This was by far the best petit manseng I tried in Virginia, and a real showstopper. On the nose there is resin, lemons, grilled lemons, grape fruit. Fleshed out body with a zesty grape fruit like tangy feel to it. great wine and the future of this winery if you ask me.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    4/22/19, 1:01 AM - Thx for commenting! I agree that the development in Virginia vineyards is really interesting. Probably need a couple of decades to weed out the vanity projects from more suitable vineyard land. Drainage seem to be important so I would look for vineyard that is higher up on the slopes.

White
2014 Maison Valette MesdemoiZelles Vin de France Chardonnay
3/8/2019 - Puteljen! Likes this wine:
92 points
Had a very strange experience with this wine. On day one it was flat and muted, mostly winter apples. Felt clumsy and overly oxidised. On day two it was fresh as a daisy. The apples where there but toned down, the acidity was up a couple of pinholes and it was drinking beautifully. Nex time I'll give it a proper decant. Score is for day two (on day one about 86-87 pts)
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    3/15/19, 1:18 PM - very similar to my experience!

Red
2007 Thomas Pinot Noir Dundee Hills
1/11/2019 - pjhr Likes this wine:
92 points
Tasty red berry aromas with a silky smooth palate of red berry, earthy notes with a moderate finish and a bit of Brett.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    1/12/19, 10:13 AM - where would you place it in terms of maturity?

  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    1/13/19, 2:10 AM - thx! I have one left... will see what I do with it. cheers!

Red
2008 Castello dei Rampolla Sammarco Toscana IGT SuperTuscan Blend
DBYOB 3.0 The Rise of the Eternal Return (@swedish home): no notes but was very fruity cabernet nose on this with a lot of structure. Very good.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    1/8/19, 8:20 AM - Thx for commenting! We did the tasting in November and was not strictly on a scientific footing at this stage in the evening, so hard to be precise... but I do remember thinking that this was not unenjoyable at this stage, but also that there were many years left to go before peak.

Red
2015 Clos Saron Kind of Blue Sierra Foothills Syrah Blend, Syrah
1/6/2019 - Omar Khayyam Likes this wine:
92 points
Very odd but lovely combination of pure racy cinsault [edit: no cinsault, although that's how the restaurant listed it, it's a mix of Syrah, carignan and cabernet, see note from winemaker as comment to this tasting note] fruit that does not bear much trace of oak or anything but a streak of sweaty horse saddle and some VA. Some similarities to a young Musar. we liked it just fine!
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    1/7/19, 9:09 AM - You are the winemaker I presume?! Many thanks for commenting, and further more, for your lovely wines! I had this wine at the excellent restaurant La Colline in Stockholm, Sweden. They had it listed as Cinsault.

    I guess the fact that it has some carignane and Cabernet Sauvignon explains why I felt the association to Chateau Musar. The only other of your wines that I have tried was the 2010 Out of the Blue which we drank 3-4 years ago and I have been looking for Clos Saron wines ever since. Not easy to find in Stockholm! This one was a little lighter in color compared to the Out of the Blue 2010 as I think I remember it and also different in expression. I really liked that one too.

Red
2005 Château Haut-Bailly Pessac-Léognan Red Bordeaux Blend
DBYOB 3.0 The Rise of the Eternal Return (@swedish home): Really lovely, did not take notes so will refrain from scoring other than saying it was excellent and drinking really well. Clearly, has potential to develop and will drink well for many more years.
  • Omar Khayyam commented:

    1/2/19, 1:34 PM - thx! will definitely keep my eyes open.

1 - 50 of 111
More results
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close