11/3/22, 5:30 PM - Thanks for that Vinophilo, but just because lots of people do a thing, doesn't mean that thing is correct. Your logically fallacious argument is referred to as "argumentum ad populum" - claiming a truth or affirming something is good because the majority thinks so.The reality is that your position is that "you just have to believe" and I can understand why you would say that, because there is absolutely no evidence that there is any scientific basis that biodynamics could work. The scientific method is the best tool we have for understanding the world we live in and biodynamics fails these tests.Also, the straw man argument you put forward about making wines with "mega-purple or other yuck" doesn't make any sense. You're making out like it's a false dichotomy of that stuff or biodynamics, and winemaking is so much more that those two extremes, as I'm sure you well know, and I feel you know how intellectually dishonest your argument is.Please feel free to show me how biodynamics could plausibly work, but until then, my position stands and your points make me even more sure that biodynamics is all - as I said - "mumbo-jumbo".As I said in my tasting notes, it it highly plausible that people practising biodynamics are showing some sort of attention-to-detail in caring for the vineyard, but to ascribe that to angels to fairies or biodynamics is unjustified.
3/22/18, 12:11 PM - Just in case you don’t know, you can put info about who you drank with wine with and where in the private consumption note
9/15/13, 3:27 AM - What did they charge you, if you don't mind me asking?
7/21/13, 2:35 AM - I'm so hungry now. That looks fantastic.
11/10/10, 6:37 AM - Must pick up some bottles of this.
11/10/10, 6:34 AM - I couldn't agree more. This is exactly why I love this wine.
11/10/10, 6:32 AM - It's funny isn't it - how this wine works so well with food. I really think it's great value.
11/10/10, 6:30 AM - That's interesting, because it was the stinkyness that attracted me to this wine at the initial tasting and I reckoned that it would bring some interesting developments over time. It sounds like it's still a bit too dominant though. I might wait another 6 months before I look at the first.
11/10/10, 6:27 AM - Wow. I just picked three of these up on Saturday and sent them to the cellar purely on spec. It sounds like these really do deliver for their price. Looking forward to cracking them. Glad you enjoyed it.
6/5/10, 1:59 AM - I think you meant to post this tasting note against the red wine. This is the white!
3/6/10, 1:40 AM - Nice work. I looked at the Pinot Noir and loved it, so I might grab 6 of these for the cellar based on your comments.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search