Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Tasting Notes for KeithSurg

(883 notes on 797 wines)

1 - 50 of 883 Sort order
Red
1/7/2024 - KeithSurg wrote:
95 points
Decanted an hour, drank over 2. This is my last bottle of the last vintage I bought - wish I had more. Drinking perfectly: rich, smooth, long finish. Not as complex as my favorites, but the velvety texture, body, and balance is amazing.
Red
10/30/2023 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
Recently received from the winery. Still drinking great.
Red
10/27/2023 - KeithSurg wrote:
92 points
Fantastic, but not what it used to be. Took to a restaurant, which was a mistake - tremendous amount of sediment that was not properly handled. Don't hold any longer.
1 person found this helpful Comments (1)
Red
8/15/2023 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
Decanted at Nonna for 110. Big wine, integrated and drinking well now.
Red
2019 Cliff Lede High Fidelity Napa Valley Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
6/14/2023 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
More approachable early than some of their other vintages, but consistent with other 2019s. Big, rich, complex.
1 person found this helpful Comments (1)
White
6/5/2023 - KeithSurg wrote:
95 points
Incredibly rich, pure Chardonnay fruit. Amazing.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
1/12/2023 - KeithSurg wrote:
94 points
Intense, fruit-forward, yet balanced. Tasting mature already.
5 people found this helpful Comment
White
1/4/2023 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
More approachable young than their others. More fruit, less acidity. Still very intetesting, integrated and delicious.
Red
1/1/2023 - KeithSurg wrote:
95 points
Decanted from magnum 3 hrs before dinner. Wow. Classic Napa cab made in an old world style. Mature and integrated, yet still fresh. Drink now, but no rush - may not get better, but still has plenty of life.
White - Sparkling
1/1/2023 - KeithSurg wrote:
Drank along side '06 Dom and Dom Rose. This was the crowd favorite
1 person found this helpful Comment
White
2/10/2022 - KeithSurg wrote:
96 points
Beautiful, easy to drink, delicious. I've been on the list for years, and still just get 2 Laurens. Love all their wines, but this is what brings me back.
2 people found this helpful Comment
Red
1/24/2022 - KeithSurg wrote:
90 points
Dark fruit, licorice, burned leaves, and gamy notes. Medium body. Interestng.
Red
12/14/2021 - KeithSurg wrote:
92 points
Opened my 9L for dinner with my best friends. Surprised that this large format was already showing some age - glad I didn't wait longer. Fruit and tannins have mellowed. Smooth, integrated, nice finish.
Red
9/13/2021 - KeithSurg wrote:
96 points
Classic Napa. Velvety and delicious.
Red
9/13/2021 - KeithSurg wrote:
91 points
Nice structure, but the fruit just didn't come out before the bottle was gone.
Red
8/11/2021 - KeithSurg wrote:
92 points
Decanted a couple of hours. The fruit was just coming through at the end. Nice balance, drinking well. Recommend a long decant.
Red
8/11/2021 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
Drank after the UV-SL. This is more mineral-driven and tight, but fantastic.
White
6/13/2021 - KeithSurg wrote:
92 points
A much richer style than I expected. Concentrated, with lemon and floral notes, smooth finish.
1 person found this helpful Comment
White
5/3/2021 - KeithSurg wrote:
94 points
Drank after the UV-SL. This had more acidity, minerality and structure reminiscent of a Burgundy. Very nice.
3 people found this helpful Comment
Red
4/28/2021 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
Smooth and polished. Drinking beautifully now. Fruit fading without the complex nuances I was hoping for. Drink soon.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
3/1/2021 - KeithSurg wrote:
84 points
This was extremely tannic on release, so I put in the cellar and forgot about it. Saw it tonight and opened with excitement, as I'm a huge Maybach and TRB fan. Strange magenta color. Thin, somewhat tart. Minimal red fruit. Short, dry finish.
Red
3/1/2021 - KeithSurg wrote:
84 points
Closed, thin, tannic
Red
1/27/2021 - KeithSurg wrote:
94 points
Decanted at Ruth's. Rich, smooth, deep flavors with velvety tannins and smooth finish. Beautifully mature Napa cab.
Red
12/19/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
87 points
Was looking forward to a nice cab at the end of a flight of very good pinots. This was disappointing, thin and dry for this price.
Red
11/15/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
95 points
Enjoyed over 2 hrs without decant. Great structure and balance that should hold up to longer cellaring, but beautiful now. Elegant wine that would impress Napa and Bordeaux lovers equally.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
11/15/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
92 points
Tart on opening, with more balanced flavors over the next 2 hrs. More Bordeaux than Napa in style. Good structure, smooth short finish.
2 people found this helpful Comment
White
10/18/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
92 points
A little astringent on opening, much better later, especially on day 2. Great balance of fruit, minerality and acidity. Citrus flavors, esp meyer lemon, clean finish.
Red
10/2/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
Some time has done wonders for this wine. Not one of the best vintages, but drinking well now.
White
9/29/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
94 points
Decanted, but not necessary for this one. Rich citrus and lemon flavors, long smooth finish. Not as complex as some other Auberts, but still fantastic. Paired great with chicken piccata.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
8/14/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
Nice mature Napa cab. Great balance, nice structure. Drinking beautifully now.
Red
2012 Antinori Solaia Toscana IGT SuperTuscan Blend (view label images)
8/12/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
91 points
Very good, but did not open up enough over a couple of hours to overcome the dominant oak and smoke flavors.
Red
6/6/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
92 points
Loads of fresh red fruit with herbs, licorice, and smoke. Firm, but nicely balanced and drinking well already.
2 people found this helpful Comment
Red
5/22/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
95 points
Very ripe and sweet, yet balanced, smooth and fresh. Velvet mouthfeel.
White
4/22/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
95 points
Wow, as usual. Decanted and enjoyed at cellar temp. Lemon zest, spice, minerals. Intense. Acidity balanced the buttery fat of a rich chicken piccata.
2 people found this helpful Comment
Red
4/21/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
92 points
PnP. Dark fruit integrated with leather, earth and minerals for a young, old-world style.
Red
3/15/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
96 points
Impressive bottle, better than previous. Rich, smooth, sweet and polished. No sign of fading, drinking beautifully.
Red
1/24/2020 - KeithSurg wrote:
90 points
Smooth, polished, easy-drinking without food, ripe but not overly sweet.
Red
12/26/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
89 points
Even on day 2, this never really opened up much. Dry and tannic, medium body
Red
12/1/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
I've had a bottle of this with my Thanksgiving turkey for years. This is a richer, smokier vintage that went great with the food.
1 person found this helpful Comment
White
11/26/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
94 points
Decanted and consumed at cellar temp. Drinking beautifully now. Rich, silky mouthfeel, smooth finish.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
11/4/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
Rich, earthy, complex. Drink now.
3 people found this helpful Comment
White
10/29/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
91 points
Great pairing with the butter and garlic in shrimp scampi
Red
8/26/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
92 points
Pretty nose of violet, mint, sweet oak. Light to medium body with soft tannins. Red fruit driven, dry mineral finish. Great balance.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
8/11/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
94 points
Decanted and enjoyed over 2 hrs. Drinking beautifully. Deep nose of dark fruit, leather and mint. Rich palate with soft tannins and nice minerality, great balance.
Red
6/22/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
91 points
Mature, integrated and delicate with nice balance of red fruit and earthiness. Heavy on the wood and smoke flavors for a wine with such finesse. Maybe waited too long to drink? Paired well with smoked pork roast.
Red
6/15/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
95 points
Drinking beautifully. Big and rich with soft, velvety tannins.
Red
2015 Relic Wines The Prior Napa Valley Cabernet Franc (view label images)
6/2/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
Beautifully balanced dark and red fruit flavors, minerals and hints of herbs. Clean aromatics, medum body, silky mouthfeel with tannins already integrated. Drinking well now.
Red
3/12/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
94 points
Rarely does a new wine taste as good at home as I remember it from a recent Napa trip. This was better. Smooth, rich, soft, balanced, delicious. No need to hold this.
2 people found this helpful Comment
Red
3/2/2019 - KeithSurg wrote:
93 points
Similar notes from 6 yrs ago, but better. So smooth. Still on the sweet side, best after dinner.
1 - 50 of 883
More results
  • Tasting Notes: 883 notes on 797 wines
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close