Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(69 comments on 63 notes)

1 - 50 of 63 Sort order
Red
2015 Domaine de l'Ecu Ange Vin de France Pinot Noir
9/21/2018 - cfrances33 wrote:
85 points
Served in a Riedel Burgundy glass. Root; 1021 hPa.

Upon intial opening, this is very reductive and stinky with a manure quality. Fortunately, after stepping away for 20 minutes, this blows off. Color here is a deep magenta, moving to a bricking, watery rim. Some sediment, but rather fine. The nose here is really quite pleasant, with fresh bramble, red currant, lavender, and fresh violet. A bit of menthol. There’s a distinct wet red clay quality, along with decaying compost. Rather attractive, though the clay can be a bit distracting. Taste follows suit with more tart red fruits - red currant, red raspberries, rose water, sage. Some of the same decaying leaves funk by not as noticeable as the palate. Tannic structure here is moderately firm, and lingering. The red clay character from the nose provides no real flavor, but completely drives the palate, drying out the ripeness of the fruit, emphasizing the tart acidity, and sharpening what would likely be a rather pleasant tannic grip. The finish is short with no real flavor other than some of the tart red currant, a slight graininess, and incredibly dry.

Overall this wine is confounding. The fruit quality is undeniable, but I can’t say that the terra-cotta aging benefits this wine. Perhaps I focus on the clay qualities that come through on the nose and palate by power of suggestion, but I don’t think they provide any complexity to the wine; quite the opposite. I’m not sure aging will help this wine either as it was short and uninteresting a year ago and doesn’t seem much different now. I’d love to try this same wine coming from old oak elevage.
  • mazik commented:

    1/28/24, 8:39 AM - Strangest wine I've every drunk.

Red
2010 Red Mare Wines Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley
Drank past the suggested drink date, but still tasted good. A little lighter than my favorite Cabernets, though smooth and paired well with steak, potatoes and wedge salad.
  • mazik commented:

    10/5/23, 11:21 AM - Whoever put a two year drink-by date four to six years after vintage of a Napa cab wasn't thinking very clearly.

Rosé
2020 Heidi Schröck Heidi Schröck & Söhne 'Tour de Rosé' Neusiedlersee Rosé Blend
4/6/2022 - Elycohn Likes this wine:
87 points
Suicide soda fountain blend of Nothern Italian, French, and German varietals. Fun to see Lagrein and Teraldego in the mix. Comes together in a soft pink cotton candy glow and raspberry lemonade finish. Thirst quenching.
  • mazik commented:

    10/5/23, 10:24 AM - Second that motion!!!

Red
2005 Hospices de Beaune Beaune 1er Cru Cuvée Brunet Pierre André Pinot Noir
8/24/2016 - ChristP Likes this wine:
95 points
What a magnificent Burgundy. Alas, no formal notes. The 2005 Cuvee Brunet is still rather youthful and tannic. It took around 3 hours in the decanter to start to open up, and it continued to evolve with every glass - no, almost with every sip. It's amazing wine with great depth of red and dark fruits, tannins to pack the cheeks and youthful acidity. There's great complexity and a lovely finish. Foolishly, I only bought a 6-pack, so I'm now down to 5 bottles. This should not be opened for another couple of years, and I'm sure it could cellar well for a further ten years. If ever this comes round again, don't hesitate to buy this outstanding Burgundy from a top producer in what was a golden vintage (the price was also very reasonable at GBP180 for the half case).
  • mazik commented:

    9/18/23, 8:43 AM - My experience of this wine was very different....

Red
2017 Peacock Family Vineyard Pinot Noir Doña Margarita Vineyard Sonoma Coast
10/15/2021 - OldHick95 Likes this wine:
91 points
Light in style. Nose of well worn letter. Core of red plum, licorice. Tingling acidity on the long finish.
  • mazik commented:

    8/7/23, 9:56 AM - leather?

Red
2018 Maison L'Envoyé Pinot Noir Two Messengers Willamette Valley
Skany. Do not open
  • mazik commented:

    4/19/23, 7:52 AM - skany?

Red
2020 Monthélie-Douhairet-Porcheret Bourgogne Pinot Noir
Väldigt syrligt och tenens till vinäger i smaken
Troligast skadat
  • mazik commented:

    4/18/23, 7:18 AM - Usually I would rate a wine that tasted this way as "flawed."

Red
2020 Château des Tours (Beaujolais) Brouilly Gamay
10/23/2022 - mazik Likes this wine:
89 points
Dark ruby in the glass with fragrant raspberry and cherry fruit along with clove and lilac, good length, goes down nicely and definitely cuts the grease! Golde was contemptuous of it.
  • mazik commented:

    10/23/22, 1:21 PM - Half bottle was 23 euros at Corza.

White
2015 Selbach-Oster Zeltinger Sonnenuhr Riesling Spätlese trocken Mosel Saar Ruwer
5/3/2020 - jwolf99 Likes this wine:
87 points
My third bottle before I could really get a good read on this; much more trocken than spatlese; acidity is almost too much and is a real distraction from the rest of wine; once you get past the acid, there are nice apple and pear flavors which persist on moderately long finish
  • mazik commented:

    5/2/22, 3:46 PM - Your comment suggests why spaetlese trocken is just not a terrific idea, you really need the sugar to balance the acid.

White
2017 Molino Real Sierras de Málaga Mountain Blanco Moscatel, Muscat
3/20/2022 - logos Likes this wine:
70 points
pungent herbaceous-floral nose; fleshy, matte textured, slightly harsh, ripe melony taste; brisk acidity;soft, clean, lingering finish. very attractive and moreish. may improve
  • mazik commented:

    3/21/22, 8:50 AM - Apparently you have your own 100-point scale, entirely different from everyone else's. If you want to give numbers in the 60s and 70s to wine that is very good to excellent, that's fine, but it would be helpful to everyone else if you put your numbers in your comment rather than among the ratings that CellarTracker averages together.

Red
2017 Stephen Ross Pinot Noir Edna Valley
3/16/2022 - logos Likes this wine:
63 points
simple in the best way: easy drinking, pronounced cherry and a touch earthy on the nose and palate. decent length and harmonious aftertaste. quite enjoyable; might improve with age.
  • mazik commented:

    3/18/22, 2:29 PM - You might want to take a look at
    https://www.inc.com/jim-schleckser/making-sense-of-the-100-point-wine-scale.html
    Giving a wine you *like* a 63 doesn't make any sense. I never give a score below 70, anything below is for wine that is flawed. You can do as you wish but since CellarTracker averages the numerical scores, your 63 drags the average down and might make someone think twice about buying it.

White
2018 Peter Lauer Ayler Riesling Faß 2 Trocken Mosel Saar Ruwer
1/12/2020 - Alexander Smith Likes this wine:
89 points
This maceration Fab 2 is described by Florian as an Orange wine, I must admit I don't like Orange Wines. I just don't get them. However, this is certainly interesting. Golden colour with aromas of overripe peaches, yellow apple, pears and tea the palate was more layered than what I was expecting with a rich mouthfeel of bruised orchard fruits, tropical notes, crushed stones and an easy straight finish. Not a favorite of his lineup but understand why some like it.
  • mazik commented:

    12/27/21, 2:08 PM - Faß = Fass = barrel

White - Sweet/Dessert
2005 Château Guiraud Sauternes Sémillon-Sauvignon Blanc Blend
Luis back on the Saddle @ The Kenwood: PnP from .375 - small taste - like most 2005's a little on the sweet side with not enough acidity to quite balance it out, but still very pleasant to sip! Honeyed golden fruit with peach, creamed orange and apricot dominating, hints of Meyers Lemon and caramel. A very nice, well made Sauternes. Like most Sauternes, can be drunk now for its rich fruit and acidity, or can be held for more caramel and creaminess....has the fruit, and enough acidity to last quite some time. 92+ points.
  • mazik commented:

    12/19/21, 1:36 PM - What first turned me on to wine was a bottle of Ch. Yquem and a bottle of Chambertin. I had had non-Mogen David before but they were Italian generics (soave, valpolicella). These were the wines that made me feel that wine could be ecstasy!

Red
2008 Kidnapper Cliffs Ariki Hawke's Bay Red Bordeaux Blend
6/30/2021 - rgawlowski wrote:
90 points
Nice, although syrupy… on the nose, palate etc. feels almost black currant/kirsch sweet.
  • mazik commented:

    6/30/21, 10:31 PM - Did you get this at the Acker auction too? I like "almost syrupy"!

  • mazik commented:

    7/1/21, 4:15 PM - Our reviews may help Acker sell the other seven or eight cases that were on offer. The Swede who wanted to drink this with lamb burgers in 2017 encouraged me to hope it was not hopelessly over the hill.

White - Sweet/Dessert
1991 István Szepsy Tokaji Aszú 6 Puttonyos Furmint Blend, Furmint
3/29/2021 - vinko84 wrote:
95 points
Great Find. Perfect and matured Tokaji
  • mazik commented:

    5/9/21, 1:56 PM - Just bought one of these at auction. Did I overpay?

  • mazik commented:

    5/27/21, 9:45 AM - $190

  • mazik commented:

    6/8/21, 6:25 PM - It was offered at $60 plus the auction house's 24% markup, I bid on it, I was outbid to $70 a day later, then in the last five minutes the bidding went nuts, there were four or five bidders, and I wound up with it at more than three times the original price. So I was experiencing a bit of buyer's remorse.
    It's a collector's bottle, the first year Isztvan Szepsi was able to make the wine his own way rather than having to sell his grapes to the co-op.

White - Sweet/Dessert
2002 Zind-Humbrecht Pinot Gris Clos Jebsal Sélection de Grains Nobles Trié Spéciale Alsace
1/23/2018 - moziedk Likes this wine:
100 points
This is the second bottle we drink of the 2002 Close Jebsal Trie Speciale, the first one we drank at a young age around 10 years ago, it was already fantastic then. This one we drank today January 23rd on our 12 1/2 anniversary, now 15 years old and thus still a young wine. This is an absolute monster now, wow what a wine, so complex and full-bodied. 10 years ago it was dark yellow in color, now it is deep red-brown. If I ever see one again, I'll buy it.
  • mazik commented:

    5/3/21, 2:44 PM - Three half bottles are on offer at Acker Auctions
    https://www.ackerwines.com/auctions/?auctionId=1356

Red
2010 Arietta Quartet Napa Valley Red Bordeaux Blend
11/18/2020 - mazik Likes this wine:
92 points
Popped & poured. My first impression was leather and dust, fruit on the nose was muted at first, later came in stronger with black raspberry and plum. Not a fruit bomb at all, more like a St. Emilion in a good year. Opens out with lots of charm eventually. The best gulp was what was left in my glass, tasted with a mouthful of barnyardish sheep's milk cheese.
The rest of the bottle was vacuvined, and was a 94 wine the next day (with leftover meatloaf). The primary fruit and secondary leather, oak, and earth had all come together. It's highly extracted, juicy, with abv 14.8% covered, and a long finish. If you've got a bunch of these, as I have, they need a bit of air to show all their stuff. Decant or vinturi if you have one, and watch out for the sediment at the bottom.
Bought from Acker Merrall auction at $280 for a dozen.
  • mazik commented:

    4/16/21, 9:25 PM - At Acker sometimes you get a real bargain but sometimes the bottles haven't been stored perfectly. I brought a half bottle of 2003 Rüdesheimer TBA from Acker to a dinner and the cork positively disintegrated. Wine was delicious but getting at it was work!

Red
2016 Etude Pinot Noir Fiddlestix Vineyard Sta. Rita Hills
6/20/2018 - jrhonda160 Likes this wine:
91 points
Soft but definite Napa aroma. Uneventful light flavor at first, finishing with a bit of a dry tart cherry.
  • mazik commented:

    12/22/20, 10:46 PM - Santa Rita Hills AVA is about 400 miles south of Napa.

Red
2016 Acacia Pinot Noir Carneros
7/12/2020 - Eric G wrote:
80 points
We like West Coast Pinot Noir and bought multiple bottles of this one based on ratings + recommendations. Sadly, although nothing wrong with the wine it didn’t registered with us.
  • mazik commented:

    12/19/20, 12:38 PM - Anything wrong with it?

  • mazik commented:

    12/20/20, 6:56 AM - We just cracked open a Dehlinger pinot that we bought at auction and "it didn't register with us" would have been a good addition to my note. Wondering whether we have a case of covid palate or whether the wine was poorly stored.... Nobody else rated the wine below 91.

Red
2015 Compania de Vinos del Atlantico Yecla Gordo Mourvèdre Blend, Mourvèdre
3/9/2020 - regatore Does not like this wine:
80 points
코어가 너무 진해서 영빈인줄 알았는데, 향과 팔렛에서 오는
부케가 제법 있었다. 그럼에도 2015 빈티지 일줄은 몰랐다.
높은 알코올이 조금 튀는 느낌이고, 밸런스가 그리 좋지 못하다는 인상 .
푸르티 향이 지배적인데 블랙베리, 자두가 지배적이며 카시스 향이 난다. 달콤하면서도 매콤한 스파이시 오크 향이 뚜렷하다. 바닐라 터치도 가볍게 느껴진다. 채소류 향도 듬성 듬성 나며 약간의 피래진 뉘앙스도 지니고 있다. earthy한 쿰쿰한 캐릭터도 느껴진다.
와인이 대체적으로 먹을 수록 느끼한 느낌이고, 약간 화학적 요소들이 느껴지는 듯했다. 그래서 나에겐 맞지 않는 듯 해 아쉽다.

미디엄 플러스 산도, 미디엄에서 미디엄 플러스 탄닌, 미디엄에서 미디엄 플러스에 좀 못미치는 바디감의 드라이한 와인이다.
14%의 알콜이라 식도가 뜨겁게 타오르고 그 위로 여운이 제법 길다. 하지만 질감이 묽어서 아쉽다.
  • mazik commented:

    11/17/20, 2:31 PM - Google Translate yields the following:
    I thought it was beautiful/refined because the core was so thick,
    There was quite a bouquet. Nevertheless, I didn't know it was a 2015 vintage.
    The impression that the high alcohol splashes a little and the balance is not very good.
    The scent of fruity is dominant, but blackberry and plum dominate, and it has a cassis scent. It has a distinct sweet and spicy spicy oak scent. The vanilla touch also feels light. It has a light vegetable scent and has a slight bloody nuance. You can also feel the earthy character.
    The more I drank the wine, the more I felt it, and the chemical elements seemed to be felt. That's why it doesn't seem to suit me, so I'm sorry.

    It is a dry wine with a body feeling a little less than medium plus acidity, medium to medium plus tannin, and medium to medium plus.
    Since it is 14% alcohol, the esophagus burns hot and the lingering lingering sound above it is quite long. However, it is unfortunate that the texture is thin.

Red
2018 Velenosi Lacrima di Morro d'Alba Superiore Querci’Antica
11/6/2020 - mjwilliams2 wrote:
Based on the reviews, I was excited. But I was underwhelmed.
  • mazik commented:

    11/11/20, 11:36 AM - The bloom may be off the rose!!

Red
2018 Meiomi Pinot Noir California
9/8/2020 - swade wrote:
86 points
Sweet dark fruit. Closer to Syrah than Pinot. Lots of residual sugar. Ten years ago there was some vintage to vintage interest and flavor profile change. This has fans (my wife), but there is no vinosity here anymore, rather industrial recipe. The price should keep going down. You know what you are getting here, but so too at McDonalds. The difference between this and say Seghesio zin, is it doesn’t have distinctiveness. No flaws. This will have its fans. Rich and fruit forward. This it delivers. It can’t be outstanding for me. It can’t be better than the 2017 when it is the same. 86
  • mazik commented:

    10/5/20, 1:52 PM - 2011 was the last good year for Meiomi, as I look back in my tasting notes.

White
2018 Cambria Chardonnay Katherine's Vineyard Santa Maria Valley
1/17/2020 - LakeGirl69 Likes this wine:
77 points
Nice balance of oak and enjoyed the complexity.
  • mazik commented:

    7/5/20, 6:12 AM - Numerical rating and review seem to have been by different people.

Red
2015 Anderson's Conn Valley Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley
11/13/2018 - SMHalps wrote:
flawed
My first bottle of 6 that I ordered, and it was flawed. Stored perfectly, it was probably corked. Very disappointing. Undrinkable.
  • mazik commented:

    12/29/19, 7:28 AM - Did you ever try another bottle? Were they all flawed?

Red
2009 Domaine Pierre Gelin Chambertin-Clos de Bèze Chambertin-Clos de Bèze Grand Cru Pinot Noir
6/17/2018 - SommStags wrote:
Nice fruit and somewhat in balance for such a young wine. While I recommend waiting another 5-10 years, it wasn’t a terrible sin opening. Think this wine will be around 92-93 points when it hits the plateau.
  • mazik commented:

    1/14/19, 5:11 PM - Just bought half a case of this. When would you drink it?

Red
2014 Cambria Pinot Noir Clone 4 Santa Maria Valley
2/9/2017 - UpfromtheCellar wrote:
88 points
Medium bodied, with notes of spice and fruit. Easy to pour down. At under $15 a buy in California chardonnay that can too easily be either shrill or soft/flabby at this price point. Nicely balanced.
  • mazik commented:

    12/4/18, 6:01 PM - WTF? Chardonnay?

Red
2015 Les Domaines Paul Mas Coteaux du Languedoc Château Paul Mas Clos des Mûres Syrah Blend, Syrah
10/26/2017 - pdev wrote:
88 points
Sweet red currant/pommegranite, violet. palate tastes like grenache...but supposedly none present, very fresh, red fruits, garrigue. Juicy modern winemaking.
  • mazik commented:

    2/3/18, 7:19 PM - It's 12% grenache.

Red
2012 Williams Selyem Pinot Noir Russian River Valley
10/23/2017 Pulled a glass via Coravin after trying the 2013 which I didn't care for. Wasn't crazy about this one either. Need to try again after letting it sit longer perhaps. Maybe just not my style.
  • mazik commented:

    10/26/17, 3:16 PM - I've been finding Williams Selyem the dog that didn't bark, decent wine but not worth the tariff.

Red
2014 Montinore Estate Pinot Noir Willamette Valley
5/12/2017 - Chataignier Likes this wine:
88 points
Cerise et fruits rouges au nez, légère touche de bois et de douceur aussi. Plutôt sur le fruit rouge légèrement acide en bouche, frais (légèrement asséchant) et bon. Pas boisé ni vanillé comme le sont souvent les pinots noir des usa. Intéressant, frais et agréable, finale moyenne + sur un feeling gamay. On sent que ce vin est fait avec soin mais je m'attendais à mieux pour 30$.
S'accorde bien avec un saumon et légumes grillés. Domaine en bio et biodynamie.
  • mazik commented:

    9/30/17, 8:34 PM - This a $20 wine (in the USA at least).

White - Sweet/Dessert
2009 Château Rabaud-Promis Sauternes Sémillon-Sauvignon Blanc Blend
8/30/2016 - Eclipse1 Does not like this wine:
50 points
Great if you hanker after a reminder of how good lucozade was when you were a kid. Clumsy, cloying, far too much acidity. Boiled sweets, spritzy and frankly, sickly. All the fruit seems to collide like a bad car crash and leaves the worst after taste i can ever recall. Has an almost tannic finish. At best it is like getting bored with sucking a sherbert lemon, but when you finally crunch it to relieve the boredom you get a squirt of sour, bitterness. Off to the fridge to get some PX .
  • mazik commented:

    10/3/16, 7:09 PM - Sounds like a flawed bottle.

Red
2014 Meiomi Pinot Noir California
3/23/2016 - yeti575rider wrote:
84 points
Wouldn't normally bother to read about and score something this mass produced but was curious to see what others thought of the 2014. I normally appreciate this wine for what it is and like it but this one just went over the top for me. I think this is the first wine where I got vanilla as the dominant flavor. It tasted like a cross between a super sweet grape cream soda and a Dr. Pepper. In case you were wondering that is not a good thing. Of course one of the other people drinking this really liked it. There is a reason that they sell a zillion of these every year.
  • mazik commented:

    3/26/16, 1:41 PM - I totally agree, including your numerical rating, but this wine *used* to be much better. The 2010 was like an entry level Santa Lucia Highlands pinot.

Red
2012 Château Mauvesin Barton Moulis en Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend
12/22/2015 - mathwonk wrote:
delicious. more like california wine, fresh berry taste, simple and lovely, but smooth and rich with some depth. none of the earthy complexity i recall from bordeaux. maybe i have been away from bordeaux wine so long it has changed. i mean no criticism here, as this is a real pleasure to find open on the counter at my son's house. probably opened last night, but at my house it would not still be there. i will try to save him a glass until he gets home, but that is not a given. why have i never heard of this wine? is it a young vine version of leoville barton?
  • mazik commented:

    2/21/16, 3:07 PM - No, it isn't, it's just owned by the Bartons. Léoville is in Saint-Julien, this is from Moulis-en-Medoc, a different commune altogether and not one that was included in the 1855 rankings. It's in the south of the left bank, down near Margaux. The top wine from Moulis is generally considered to be Ch. Chasse-Spleen. There are other very good and underpriced Bordeaux from these unranked communes, I used to enjoy Ch. Lanessan a good deal, it was from Cussac, which is very close to Saint-Julien.

Red
2012 La Follette Pinot Noir Van der Kamp Sonoma Mountain
12/1/2015 - ageverett Does not like this wine:
86 points
Disappointing. Pop and pour and drank over 2.5 hours. Never developed into anything redeeming for me. Muted nose, thin palate and relatively short, unenthusiastic finish. Maybe it needs to breathe? Will try something different next time.
  • mazik commented:

    12/10/15, 8:05 AM - This got some terrific reviews from, e.g., Wine Advocate; were they drinking a different wine?

Red
2011 Sterling Vineyards Limited Release Anniversary Blend Napa Valley Red Blend
5/22/2015 - dsan0123 wrote:
flawed
Believe it was shipped corked. Very vinegar taste and not good
  • mazik commented:

    5/22/15, 4:27 PM - Cork taint (TCA aka trichloroanisole) has the smell of wet moldy cardboard, some say "sweaty socks" or "wet dog." Vinegar (acetic acid) is a natural component of wine fermentation, though if it's dominant the wine can be undrinkable.

Red
2011 Biggio Hamina Cellars Pinot Noir Willamette Valley
8/23/2014 - mazik Does not like this wine:
75 points
Sour and unpleasant still: who wants to drink rhubarb wine? Anyone want my last four bottles?
  • mazik commented:

    4/23/15, 11:20 PM - Gave those away many months ago.

Red
2011 Coho Pinot Noir Stanly Ranch Carneros
3/22/2015 - Armando B wrote:
87 points
Bigger, darker fruited style pinot. Not for the AFWE drinker. Spritzy on opening. Dissapaited after Day 1. Thereafter a good, if unremarkable, representation of this style. OK if you are in the mood for it. OK QPR for the $25 bottle discount price. Not worth the regular retail price.
  • mazik commented:

    3/28/15, 5:31 AM - AFWE = anti-flavor wine elite??

Red
2009 Jemrose Syrah Cardiac Hill Bennett Valley
11/29/2014 - RPerro Likes this wine:
93 points
Decanted 1 hour. Super dark, almost black in color, with big aromas of black fruit, cracked peppercorn and violets. Blackberry, pepper and earth on the palate, finishing with a bitter dark chocolate flavor. This is some really good stuff!
  • mazik commented:

    2/25/15, 3:11 PM - That's it -- exactly!

Red
2006 Macrae Family Winery Pinot Noir Bacigalupi Vineyard Russian River Valley
1/15/2015 - Rmjchen Likes this wine:
89 points
The cork broke but was able to salvage it. Elegant wine with pinot traits. Not overtly acidic as some reviewers noted. Good balance of elements though not a life changing experience. Considering what I paid through last bottle it was a good value.
  • mazik commented:

    1/15/15, 11:44 PM - The issue for me and a number of other tasters was not acidity--high levels of naturally occurring malic acid--but the wine fault termed "volatile acidity"--generally caused by ethyl acetate (smells like nail polish remover) and acetic acid (vinegar). A small amount is not a big deal and because it's volatile it tends to evaporate, so your second glass may taste better. It happens, or doesn't, in the barrel during fermentation. You got lucky.

Red
2006 Macrae Family Winery Pinot Noir Bacigalupi Vineyard Russian River Valley
1/4/2015 - mazik wrote:
flawed
Amazingly unpleasant. Cork broke but butt was retrievable. Cloudy dark red with brownish tinge. The bouquet has flowers and fruit but is marred by volatile acidity, which did not blow off. Red fruit and vinegar on the palate. This goes down the drain, I can't even cook with it. Shame on Last Bottle!
  • mazik commented:

    1/7/15, 7:07 PM - Changed it to "flawed." Ethyl acetate and acetic acid out of control.

Red
2006 Macrae Family Winery Pinot Noir Bacigalupi Vineyard Russian River Valley
1/4/2015 - jpferna wrote:
85 points
As previously mentioned, cork shredded when opening. Not a good sign. A very drinkable pinot, but fairly thin over the palate. I too am surprised Last Bottle hyped this one.
  • mazik commented:

    1/5/15, 4:01 PM - I seem to have gotten the same shipment you did, with a lot of ethyl acetate in the "bouquet"(smells something like nail polish remover) and acetic acid (vinegar) on the palate. Somewhere in there was an elegant wine destroyed by volatile acidity.

Red
2010 Sea Smoke Pinot Noir Southing Sta. Rita Hills
12/27/2014 - Tom Warden Likes this wine:
93 points
This wine is mellowing out quite nicely...especially with 30 minutes of decanting ahead of drinking. Drank three bottles with some special friends with salmon and asparagus...perfect.
  • mazik commented:

    12/31/14, 9:00 AM - I don't get why you "don't like the wine," given what you say about it.

Red
2011 Ravenswood Zinfandel Teldeschi Dry Creek Valley
3/26/2014 - FrugalGlug wrote:
88 points
Taking a whiff, it all but confirmed that this wine had some head. Alcohol and plum on the nose. The rest of what could have been detectable was drowned out.
Juicy, tannic and overbearing. There's a lot of bombast present here, which sadly hides what the Zinfandel grape can offer. It's a great glass, but anything beyond that sends your senses reeling. Upon tasting the next day, the alcohol became more timid and the berries seemed to express themselves more. Decant for a day, and you'll find some pleasing nuances. But, I'd have to say, skip this one.
  • mazik commented:

    10/21/14, 6:24 AM - What does it mean "this wine had some head"?

  • mazik commented:

    10/21/14, 8:42 AM - Thanks, usually I use "hot" as shorthand for "too much alcohol not integrated as yet.

Red
2010 Château Tour St-Vincent Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend
7/15/2014 - wineaficionado Likes this wine:
89 points
Nose: Red currents, raspberries, licorice. Very perfumy. Mouth: Consistent with the nose. Very good wine. Finish a bit too diluted. Wine just a tad too bitter. Ready to drink now.
  • mazik commented:

    9/29/14, 11:52 AM - Ready to drink now?

White
2010 Brewer-Clifton Chardonnay Mount Carmel Sta. Rita Hills
8/23/2014 - mazik Likes this wine:
91 points
Lovely wine, my tasting note from March stands. But will somebody explain how to get that effing capsule off?
  • mazik commented:

    8/23/14, 11:56 AM - Thanks very much, Jonahfactor!!!

Red
2011 Château Graves de Rabion St. Émilion Red Bordeaux Blend
11/23/2013 - Jeffyboy wrote:
85 points
Rather dark with some billbery hue, not clear with rather long legs. Light rim. Nose: very powdery but with some tart aromas at the begining, later becoming more swedt. Taste: light, lacks body a bit; quite high acidity - resembling red currants. Strange "dishcloth" finish - rather long. Would call it disapointment.
  • mazik commented:

    8/19/14, 10:33 AM - "Dishcloth" may mean TCA cork taint?

Red
2012 Meiomi Pinot Noir California
7/1/2014 - mazik wrote:
82 points
As in April: exaggerates to the point of parody the lushness of the 2011 Meiomi. Too hot, too fruity, too chewy. Where is the winemaker who made the 2009 and 2010 Meiomi that I fell in love with?
  • mazik commented:

    7/2/14, 12:12 PM - Thanks TALLMIKEWINE. You called my attention and I realize (for the first time) that pretty nearly *all* my TNs this year on 2012 pinot noir are in the 82-85 range. So it may be that, though I'm in love with pinot, I'm just not wild about this vintage, perfect as it seemed to the winemakers. Or (so I hope, because I'm cellaring some 2012 Williams Selyems and some Loring single vineyard SLHs) that it's a wonderful vintage that just needs more bottle age to taste right to me.

White
2010 Brewer-Clifton Chardonnay Mount Carmel Sta. Rita Hills
6/1/2014 - JOJ wrote:
90 points
The notes on this wine below are fascinating -- no consistency at all. This was my first bottle, and I liked it quite a bit, although I certainly would never have guessed it to be a California Chardonnay. On the nose, lemon, pineapple, and melon, with an interesting and not unpleasing touch of horse blanket. Really zippy on the palate, with lemon, green apple, and nutmeg, framed by a tangy spine of mineral and citrus. A touch thin, but rounded out with air.
  • mazik commented:

    6/1/14, 12:03 PM - To me it looks as though there are some bad (flawed) bottles out there, but otherwise the tasting notes, like mine in March, seem to tally with yours.

White - Sparkling
N.V. Scharffenberger Brut Excellence Mendocino County Champagne Blend
1/1/2014 - Z1nnfull Likes this wine:
86 points
Really nothing special here for $20. They say its 2/3 Chard, 1/3 Pinot Noir, but hard to tell. Little creamy, but on the light side. Not a lot of depth and struggle to pull specific flavors out of it. Can't agree that this is good for the $$$ when you have Gruet and similar (try their Blanc de Noir) for well under $20. By the next day after properly securing it, it had lost all carbonation. Disappointing but good. Would have been happy if I paid $10-12 for it.
  • mazik commented:

    4/30/14, 9:22 PM - Scharffenberger website says the wine is 2/3 chardonnay, 1/3 pinot noir.

Red
2009 Dashe Cellars Zinfandel Old Vines Todd Brothers Ranch Alexander Valley
3/3/2014 - mazik Does not like this wine:
83 points
It's not flawed, it's not temporarily odd tasting from travel in a truck, and decanting doesn't do anything whatever for it. It tastes musty, dusty and drab. To me it seems utterly incredible that anyone ever said of this wine "Explosively perfumed scents of dark berry preserves, violet and spicecake, with a peppery topnote. Pliant and broad on the palate, offering intense blackberry and cherry compote flavors that show impressive depth and focus." The wine I received from LastBottle was not that wine.
  • mazik commented:

    3/7/14, 8:41 PM - Two bottles in a row, what are the odds? And I certainly didn't detect the wet-cardboard-sweatsocks stink of TCA. If it was damaged, I'd guess bad storage. Or that it was some plonk mislabeled at the winery.

White
2010 Brewer-Clifton Chardonnay Mount Carmel Sta. Rita Hills
3/2/2014 - prism wrote:
74 points
Popped and poured. The wax top is a chore to open. Dark, oxidized-looking stuff. Smoke flavors and broiled grapefruit. Was looking forward to this--my first of six. Disappointing. Sharp, woody, and acidic. Maybe it was just this bottle, but this sure ain't Chablis. Oak predominates; not much fun to drink. Window is closing, so I'll be trying another bottle soon, but so far it's not a wine I'd serve to anyone else. Possibly a flawed bottle -- I really hope so -- but this bottle merits no better than 74: drinkable but well below an average chardonnay.
  • mazik commented:

    3/5/14, 6:48 PM - I think you may have gotten a seriously flawed bottle because that wasn't my experience with what must have been one from the same batch. (Except with the sealing wax capsule, which is a pain.)

    Your TN had me worried that I'd just gotten skunked by LastBottle again--I unfortunately bought half a case of their deadly Dashe zinfandel.

1 - 50 of 63
More results
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close