1/28/24, 8:39 AM - Strangest wine I've every drunk.
10/5/23, 11:21 AM - Whoever put a two year drink-by date four to six years after vintage of a Napa cab wasn't thinking very clearly.
10/5/23, 10:24 AM - Second that motion!!!
9/18/23, 8:43 AM - My experience of this wine was very different....
8/7/23, 9:56 AM - leather?
4/19/23, 7:52 AM - skany?
4/18/23, 7:18 AM - Usually I would rate a wine that tasted this way as "flawed."
10/23/22, 1:21 PM - Half bottle was 23 euros at Corza.
5/2/22, 3:46 PM - Your comment suggests why spaetlese trocken is just not a terrific idea, you really need the sugar to balance the acid.
3/21/22, 8:50 AM - Apparently you have your own 100-point scale, entirely different from everyone else's. If you want to give numbers in the 60s and 70s to wine that is very good to excellent, that's fine, but it would be helpful to everyone else if you put your numbers in your comment rather than among the ratings that CellarTracker averages together.
3/18/22, 2:29 PM - You might want to take a look at https://www.inc.com/jim-schleckser/making-sense-of-the-100-point-wine-scale.htmlGiving a wine you *like* a 63 doesn't make any sense. I never give a score below 70, anything below is for wine that is flawed. You can do as you wish but since CellarTracker averages the numerical scores, your 63 drags the average down and might make someone think twice about buying it.
12/27/21, 2:08 PM - Faß = Fass = barrel
12/19/21, 1:36 PM - What first turned me on to wine was a bottle of Ch. Yquem and a bottle of Chambertin. I had had non-Mogen David before but they were Italian generics (soave, valpolicella). These were the wines that made me feel that wine could be ecstasy!
6/30/21, 10:31 PM - Did you get this at the Acker auction too? I like "almost syrupy"!
7/1/21, 4:15 PM - Our reviews may help Acker sell the other seven or eight cases that were on offer. The Swede who wanted to drink this with lamb burgers in 2017 encouraged me to hope it was not hopelessly over the hill.
5/9/21, 1:56 PM - Just bought one of these at auction. Did I overpay?
5/27/21, 9:45 AM - $190
6/8/21, 6:25 PM - It was offered at $60 plus the auction house's 24% markup, I bid on it, I was outbid to $70 a day later, then in the last five minutes the bidding went nuts, there were four or five bidders, and I wound up with it at more than three times the original price. So I was experiencing a bit of buyer's remorse. It's a collector's bottle, the first year Isztvan Szepsi was able to make the wine his own way rather than having to sell his grapes to the co-op.
5/3/21, 2:44 PM - Three half bottles are on offer at Acker Auctionshttps://www.ackerwines.com/auctions/?auctionId=1356
4/16/21, 9:25 PM - At Acker sometimes you get a real bargain but sometimes the bottles haven't been stored perfectly. I brought a half bottle of 2003 Rüdesheimer TBA from Acker to a dinner and the cork positively disintegrated. Wine was delicious but getting at it was work!
12/22/20, 10:46 PM - Santa Rita Hills AVA is about 400 miles south of Napa.
12/19/20, 12:38 PM - Anything wrong with it?
12/20/20, 6:56 AM - We just cracked open a Dehlinger pinot that we bought at auction and "it didn't register with us" would have been a good addition to my note. Wondering whether we have a case of covid palate or whether the wine was poorly stored.... Nobody else rated the wine below 91.
11/17/20, 2:31 PM - Google Translate yields the following:I thought it was beautiful/refined because the core was so thick,There was quite a bouquet. Nevertheless, I didn't know it was a 2015 vintage.The impression that the high alcohol splashes a little and the balance is not very good.The scent of fruity is dominant, but blackberry and plum dominate, and it has a cassis scent. It has a distinct sweet and spicy spicy oak scent. The vanilla touch also feels light. It has a light vegetable scent and has a slight bloody nuance. You can also feel the earthy character.The more I drank the wine, the more I felt it, and the chemical elements seemed to be felt. That's why it doesn't seem to suit me, so I'm sorry.It is a dry wine with a body feeling a little less than medium plus acidity, medium to medium plus tannin, and medium to medium plus.Since it is 14% alcohol, the esophagus burns hot and the lingering lingering sound above it is quite long. However, it is unfortunate that the texture is thin.
11/11/20, 11:36 AM - The bloom may be off the rose!!
10/5/20, 1:52 PM - 2011 was the last good year for Meiomi, as I look back in my tasting notes.
7/5/20, 6:12 AM - Numerical rating and review seem to have been by different people.
12/29/19, 7:28 AM - Did you ever try another bottle? Were they all flawed?
1/14/19, 5:11 PM - Just bought half a case of this. When would you drink it?
12/4/18, 6:01 PM - WTF? Chardonnay?
2/3/18, 7:19 PM - It's 12% grenache.
10/26/17, 3:16 PM - I've been finding Williams Selyem the dog that didn't bark, decent wine but not worth the tariff.
9/30/17, 8:34 PM - This a $20 wine (in the USA at least).
10/3/16, 7:09 PM - Sounds like a flawed bottle.
3/26/16, 1:41 PM - I totally agree, including your numerical rating, but this wine *used* to be much better. The 2010 was like an entry level Santa Lucia Highlands pinot.
2/21/16, 3:07 PM - No, it isn't, it's just owned by the Bartons. Léoville is in Saint-Julien, this is from Moulis-en-Medoc, a different commune altogether and not one that was included in the 1855 rankings. It's in the south of the left bank, down near Margaux. The top wine from Moulis is generally considered to be Ch. Chasse-Spleen. There are other very good and underpriced Bordeaux from these unranked communes, I used to enjoy Ch. Lanessan a good deal, it was from Cussac, which is very close to Saint-Julien.
12/10/15, 8:05 AM - This got some terrific reviews from, e.g., Wine Advocate; were they drinking a different wine?
5/22/15, 4:27 PM - Cork taint (TCA aka trichloroanisole) has the smell of wet moldy cardboard, some say "sweaty socks" or "wet dog." Vinegar (acetic acid) is a natural component of wine fermentation, though if it's dominant the wine can be undrinkable.
4/23/15, 11:20 PM - Gave those away many months ago.
3/28/15, 5:31 AM - AFWE = anti-flavor wine elite??
2/25/15, 3:11 PM - That's it -- exactly!
1/15/15, 11:44 PM - The issue for me and a number of other tasters was not acidity--high levels of naturally occurring malic acid--but the wine fault termed "volatile acidity"--generally caused by ethyl acetate (smells like nail polish remover) and acetic acid (vinegar). A small amount is not a big deal and because it's volatile it tends to evaporate, so your second glass may taste better. It happens, or doesn't, in the barrel during fermentation. You got lucky.
1/7/15, 7:07 PM - Changed it to "flawed." Ethyl acetate and acetic acid out of control.
1/5/15, 4:01 PM - I seem to have gotten the same shipment you did, with a lot of ethyl acetate in the "bouquet"(smells something like nail polish remover) and acetic acid (vinegar) on the palate. Somewhere in there was an elegant wine destroyed by volatile acidity.
12/31/14, 9:00 AM - I don't get why you "don't like the wine," given what you say about it.
10/21/14, 6:24 AM - What does it mean "this wine had some head"?
10/21/14, 8:42 AM - Thanks, usually I use "hot" as shorthand for "too much alcohol not integrated as yet.
9/29/14, 11:52 AM - Ready to drink now?
8/23/14, 11:56 AM - Thanks very much, Jonahfactor!!!
8/19/14, 10:33 AM - "Dishcloth" may mean TCA cork taint?
7/2/14, 12:12 PM - Thanks TALLMIKEWINE. You called my attention and I realize (for the first time) that pretty nearly *all* my TNs this year on 2012 pinot noir are in the 82-85 range. So it may be that, though I'm in love with pinot, I'm just not wild about this vintage, perfect as it seemed to the winemakers. Or (so I hope, because I'm cellaring some 2012 Williams Selyems and some Loring single vineyard SLHs) that it's a wonderful vintage that just needs more bottle age to taste right to me.
6/1/14, 12:03 PM - To me it looks as though there are some bad (flawed) bottles out there, but otherwise the tasting notes, like mine in March, seem to tally with yours.
4/30/14, 9:22 PM - Scharffenberger website says the wine is 2/3 chardonnay, 1/3 pinot noir.
3/7/14, 8:41 PM - Two bottles in a row, what are the odds? And I certainly didn't detect the wet-cardboard-sweatsocks stink of TCA. If it was damaged, I'd guess bad storage. Or that it was some plonk mislabeled at the winery.
3/5/14, 6:48 PM - I think you may have gotten a seriously flawed bottle because that wasn't my experience with what must have been one from the same batch. (Except with the sealing wax capsule, which is a pain.)Your TN had me worried that I'd just gotten skunked by LastBottle again--I unfortunately bought half a case of their deadly Dashe zinfandel.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search