7/15/18, 6:51 PM - You just saved me from opening this tonight. Thank you!
6/29/18, 4:20 PM - Curious if you'd decant this at all or just PnP?
5/5/18, 2:01 PM - Thanks! Considering opening one this weekend -- any guidance on how much air you gave it? Was it pop n pour, decanted awhile, or drank over several hours from the bottle?
2/13/18, 2:14 PM - This is very helpful as I am considering when to open mine. How much air/decant to people think this needs?
10/8/17, 5:32 PM - Sounds like it would be very food versatile too! Thanks for the great note Fred!
9/4/17, 8:05 PM - First of all, glad to see your notes! Very helpful -- especially since we dine at Felix frequently and can try this there! You should definitely continue to write notes! Sounds like this wine is in a perfect place to enjoy, still some apparent fruit, softened tannins, lively but open on the nose.
6/27/17, 11:18 PM - Urethral is my new fave wine descriptor.The way a great wine should be.
3/24/17, 11:19 AM - Just read the Harvey Ball wikipedia entry. SO glad you use him as a reference for smiley faces. Amazing story.Regarding the wine, I have to say thanks for the detailed notes!
3/21/17, 6:12 PM - Noticed use of (sic) which suggests this was copied from another source and the misspelling was left in. Are these the user's notes or are you quoting something/someone?
11/24/16, 11:19 PM - They understand. They do not like that style. So they are making sure the voice their disapproval in words and voting it down in the rating they feel it really deserves.
11/24/16, 11:13 PM - I just had a Thanksgiving dinner with a case of this (we drank 10 bottles of it between eight adults) and I can say it was candied, overly simplified for an American (mainstream) palate. It was fucking ODIOUS but well made if that makes any sense at all. I didn't bother bringing my To Kalon, Beckstoffer, Dr. Crane, or Palmaz stuff I considered bringing that would have fallen on unappreciative palates. The Caymus is simple, too sweet, and I dare say it tastes like adulterated (as in, YES, it tastes like additives are not integrated but added to the wine). This may appeal to some. And may sell more. Yes, the fruit is good and the winemaking is competent but they've marred what could have been a more REAL wine not a candy wine. Still, manages 91 on basis of pedigree, fruit, skill... but loses out on the sweet fruit tootsie roll NON-integrated bullshit. Come on Caymus, stop pandering to the masses. You're better than this.
11/24/16, 10:48 PM - Exactly. Came from dinner party where 10 bottles of Caymus were drank (plus one Pahlmeyer Jayson 2014 and one Merry Edwards 2014 Russian River Pinot Noir), because of this crowd-pleasing quality. But, to me, it's not as good as a 2014 Jayson Pahlmeyer red which is less plush, less sweet, less ostentatious, less simple, and far more balanced, complex and interesting.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search