Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(15 comments on 11 notes)

1 - 11 of 11 Sort order
Red
2019 Fattoria Petrolo Galatrona Val d'Arno di Sopra Merlot
9/24/2022 - RyanWu Likes this wine:
92 points
All the good things were there on day one. The other half was decanted in wine cellar for a day. However, it faded away so fast on day two. On the first day, the nose was full of dry herb, mineral, and some dark fruit underneath. The body was dusty but filled with chocolate. Just like midnight pumpkin coach, the magic was gone on day two. This is so wired for me that this tannic young wine faded away in this pace! I rated 93 on day one, but only 91 on day two. The aging potential for me is questionable that I might not be a fan after celllaring.
  • RyanWu commented:

    10/3/22, 2:45 PM - I kept the wine in wine cellar which is 55 F. I did the same thing on 2017 Chateau Clinet. Both are Merlot based wines, but Clinet was a no doubt winner on day 2

  • RyanWu commented:

    10/4/22, 3:01 AM - Not really positive on that.

Red
2006 Hall Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley
1/23/2022 - Vailman Likes this wine:
92 points
I’m pleased with the results of having cellared this wine for 13 years. Based on recent reviews I was worried it would be past its prime but quite to the contrary. Filled with cherries, cassis and a touch of leather showing its age. Medium finish that grew longer over the course of the evening. Benefited from a 2–3 hour decant. I agree, it’s time to drink up, but properly cellared this wine has stood the test of time.
  • RyanWu commented:

    2/7/22, 6:45 AM - I also opened one this year. The wine is still energetic IMO. Although it’s a bit one dimension, it deserves the 35 dollars price tag. I doubt not too many 35 dollars wines can hold up so well like this.

Red
2018 B Cellars Cabernet Franc Sugarloaf Vineyard Napa Valley
12/19/2021 - RyanWu Likes this wine:
92 points
Pure and opulent. I almost can not feel the high ABV (15.6%). Earthy and cedary nose. The body was quite juicy with long lasting. Not a masterpiece but a solid wine. Drink now to 2025.
  • RyanWu commented:

    12/19/21, 3:53 PM - I usually decant the wine in wine cellar and drink it in two days. This one really can hold up for even longer, because it was still at the strong side in day two. I guess there is still a room for it to evolve but not much. Since the nature of this one is lacking some other elements (acid, the maturity of tannin,complexity of nose……..), it will be a clean, pure, and relatively simple wine after 10+ years.

Red
2013 Bevan Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon McGah Vineyard Rutherford
8/13/2021 - RAD2626 Likes this wine:
92 points
Just wonderful. Great fruit, legs and balance. Lilac overtones with dark berries. Chocolate thick decadence. Will stand up against any food or competition.
  • RyanWu commented:

    8/18/21, 9:24 PM - Totally agree! Just tasted yesterday. No 80 pts wine.

Red
2017 Bevan Cellars Ontogeny Napa Valley Red Bordeaux Blend
6/5/2020 - GQG wrote:
91 points
Well, the 2017's from Napa... and from Bevan no less... the good, or the bad... good first... the attack is solid, hits you with dark fruit... blueberries, cassis, tobacco, and energy from the acidity... no goo... and then...

Then, well... there's no middle... only a finish, which stretches out on the top of the palate with acidity and some fruit. It lacks the depth of the 2016, and about complexity, let us not speak of such things. A definite notch down from 2016. Sediment noted, decanted for 3 hours.
  • RyanWu commented:

    1/24/21, 5:15 AM - Your note is so true. The hollow body is quite wiered. I still see the little trick from Russell by using residue sugar to increase depth, but it doesn’t help this time. Overall, it seems like 17’ is not worthy to buy more.

  • RyanWu commented:

    1/25/21, 3:52 PM - Totally! I’m a huge fan of Russell, but this didn’t meet the level of his lineups. I feel sorry to the vintage. Definitely, stocking up 16’ and 18’ will be the smarter way. It seems like 20’ will be bad as well.............

White
2004 Trimbach Riesling Cuvée Frédéric Emile Alsace
5/12/2020 - RyanWu wrote:
87 points
Pnp. Golden liquid showed floral nose and vanila hint. The palate was quite complex with high acidity. Botyris scent was there as well. Old but still solid. Anyways, it is going downhill.
  • RyanWu commented:

    5/12/20, 8:50 PM - That's what I doubt about it. I got it in Taiwan. I suspect the scenario is the retailer didn't store it well. Subtropical! The aging process seems like to be accelerated. It's really odd.

Red
2009 Ridge Monte Bello Santa Cruz Mountains Red Bordeaux Blend
6/25/2019 - msuwine wrote:
This earthy and lean Cabernet is hard for me to figure at this point - hence the lack of a score. I respect Ridge's place in wine history, along with its transparent and under-stated approach. I also know it has a loyal and avid fan base, who often evoke its reputation for ageability and Old World balance. So, I get it: smart people love these wines.

Still, I can't say I loved this wine, even at the 10-year mark. My main question is whether the flavor profile is a feature or a bug, so here come the descriptors: Brick red in color; light- to medium- in body; nose of plum, dill, and herbs. Understated but integrated tastes of black cherry, cranberry, anise, leather, vanillin, and (more) dill, with a wispy and dusty finish. Blend of 72% Cabernet Sauvignon, 22% Merlot, and 6% Petit Verdot. 13.5% alcohol. Followed over six hours with little change.

Based on this bottle, I found a thinness, woodsiness (lots of American Oak), and lack of intensity that I don't typically associate with greatness. I believe in - and enjoy - great old wines, but I'm just not sure this is one of them, at least not yet. Maybe this is just a matter of this particular bottle, vintage, or stage in the maturation process (or, yes, perhaps this particular palate). I'm planning to try a few other aged Monte Bellos, but this wasn't a promising start, at least for me.
  • RyanWu commented:

    7/13/19, 7:26 AM - Totally agreed! Whenever there is a whistleblower, people will give him a textbook answer, way too young. Then, if the wine is still bad after twenty years, people will say that you didn't keep it well or corckage. For me, good is good. There is no mistake for not having goosebumps after sipping a hallmark wine. Ridge Monte bello 09' is just not that good (Tried it last week!).

Red
2012 Riverain Cabernet Sauvignon Tench Vineyard Oakville
12/25/2015 - Mrp2008 wrote:
flawed
My first Riverain Cab, brought to Christmas dinner with the "in-laws". Sadly, corked. Thought it was just me at first, then everyone mentioned it tasted "weird". Bummer
  • RyanWu commented:

    12/30/15, 10:27 AM - How can you dislike Napa's wines? Having these responsible, humble, and passionate vintners around us makes me feel so blessed. This is why more and more great wines coming every year. Cheers!

  • RyanWu commented:

    12/30/15, 7:08 PM - OH! I am sorry Matt. I am just trying to give the credit to Steve. He is truly responsible and humble to his product, and I do appreciate the enthusiastic vintners like him in Napa Valley. This is the reason why we both love the wines from Napa.

Red
2012 Louis Latour Corton Domaine Latour Corton Grand Cru Pinot Noir
11/21/2015 - RyanWu wrote:
90 points
Pnp. Tasting is followed by seriously monitoring the changes for three hours. To sum up the experience, everything is so mild, and there is no X-factor found in this wine. Although this is from the second largest grand cru in Beaune, the quality is not really impressive at all. Comparing Pnp and three hours decanted, the wine only goes worse but not better. The acidity is too high, so it's not in a good balance. Back to the wine, nose is pretty muted unless you taking a deep breathe. It's not too fruity but earthy. On the palate, everything is subtle and almost non-detectable. To be honest, you can do better with 50 dollars in hand. if you go to Russian river, the producers dedecating in balance wines can deliver better choices at this price range. In any way, finding out the beauty of burgundy is a continuing fight for me. I hope one day I can see the amazing side of Burgundy described by the previous generation wine lovers, or it's just an enigma.
  • RyanWu commented:

    11/22/15, 2:12 PM - This is a good point for my future journey. This is the reason why I like here so much. I always can get great advice from all kinds of experts. I really appreciate a lot.

  • RyanWu commented:

    11/27/15, 6:14 PM - I know! However, I will sill try more and keep hanging on.

Red
2009 Fontodi Flaccianello della Pieve Colli della Toscana Centrale IGT Sangiovese
2/21/2015 - RyanWu wrote:
92 points
This wine is really in a sleep stage. It's way too closed in nose and taste. After 3 hours decanting, it is still closed showing only trace Asian spice and dark fruits. However, on the palate, the flavor is so complex with tannic backbone. I meet the same problem again. When I tasted 2003 Chateau Leoville Barton in 2014, the big wine character raised so many questions on my tongue. I barely can find any description to express the wine. Now, I had realized that the problem is just because of not yet at the drinking window. (The wine is still closed at second day.) I will definitely leave this wine for 10 more years. It should pay much more back to your patience.
  • RyanWu commented:

    2/21/15, 7:49 AM - Please at least wait 5 more years. I believe long decanting can help a little bit, but it is really at it's dormant stage just like the recent comment in wine spectator. It's much tougher than Oreno or Gaudo al Tasso.

Red
2006 Bacio Divino Cabernet Sauvignon Janzen Beckstoffer To Kalon Vineyard Oakville
3/10/2013 - efc wrote:
94 points
A complete wine in every respect. Deep purple in color with a heady nose of Blackberry, plum and chocolate. The tannins were fine and completely integrated. A wine of great length and full bodied. Overall, nothing was lacking. I wish I had more!
  • RyanWu commented:

    1/24/14, 8:31 AM - So true! I only have the chance to get two bottles. After tasting one of them, I really regreted that I didn't buy at least 6 pack...................It's a great wine, which shows the classic characters of Napa Cab.

1 - 11 of 11
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close