Comments on my notes

Red

2015 Domaine Florent Garaudet Monthélie 1er Cru Les Champs Fulliots Pinot Noir

12/18/2023 - MrOctoberfest Likes this wine:

Considerably lighter than my last bottle in 2019. Nice texture and delicate cranberry flavors. It feels like it might be in hibernation so I will wait until January 2026 to check in again. I think I’m the only one on CT drinking this wine anyway.

dgkula commented:

12/24/23, 5:29 AM - I have a few bottles as well but haven’t touched them yet! Appreciate your note!

Comment

Red

2014 Julien Cruchandeau Nuits St. Georges Aux St Jacques Pinot Noir

8/5/2022 - dgkula wrote:

86 points

Hasn’t improved. May have gotten worse. Real shame considering the cost.

dgkula commented:

8/6/22, 5:42 PM - Did taste better the next day after some air. Probably want to decant the next bottle

Comment

Red

2014 Ceritas Pinot Noir Hacienda Secoya Vineyard Anderson Valley

4/15/2022 - Beezc wrote:

94 points

Fantastic…even better with some air.

dgkula commented:

4/19/22, 2:27 PM - Agree - this is outstanding wine. I still have two left! Saving them for a special occasion .

Comment

White

2012 Gilbert Picq & ses Fils Chablis Dessus La Carriere Chardonnay

12/31/2014 - dgkula Likes this wine:

86 points

IMHO dusts the 2011. Consistent with the vintage this is bordering on take the enamel off your teeth. Very nice Chablis but with a funny funk on the nose on this bottle which blows off. A bit over-priced compared to the Fevre Domaine bottling. Pissed that I bought a case and the shop composed a case with half 2011 which I find watery and thin in comparison. 1/24: had a bottle of 2012 last night and the funk never blew off. This is on sale again and I am not buying more. I think the Fevre Domaine is a better buy at a similar price point. Lowering my score owing to the funk. 1/30: I finally had a good bottle. Lovely floral nose. I actually did a double take and sniffed several times as it was so uncharacteristic. Nice Chablis stoniness and grip. QPR not quite up there with the Fever and Defaix but finally a decent bottle of Pica. There is hope for the balance of this case.

dgkula commented:

1/1/15, 8:29 AM - Yeah, I checked the online order last night and I had checked 'no vintage substitutions' on the order but did not check at the shop when picking up. Live and learn ...

Comment (See all 2 comments)

dgkula commented:

dgkula commented:

dgkula commented:

dgkula commented:

Search

Report a Problem

(4 comments on 4 notes)

dgkula commented:

dgkula commented:

dgkula commented:

dgkula commented:

Search

Report a Problem

Your report has been submitted!