Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(6 comments on 4 notes)

1 - 4 of 4 Sort order
White
2017 Weingut Lehnert-Veit Piesporter Goldtröpfchen Riesling Gruft Grosses Gewächs Mosel Saar Ruwer
5/25/2022 - forceberry wrote:
92 points
With the 2015 vintage I was told Gruft was the same thing as GG Piesporter Goldtröpfchen, but only bottled in magnums - yet this wine was served from a standard-sized bottle, so I don't know who to trust! Fermented spontaneously. Aged in old oak barriques. 12,5% alcohol. Tasted blind.

Pale lemony color. Varietally correct nose immediately identifiable as a Riesling with its aromas of ripe citrus fruits and crunchy Granny Smith apple, some peachy tones, a little bit of sour apple candy, light floral notes of white flowers and a hint of nashi pear. The wine is dry, precise and light-to-medium-bodied on the palate with intense flavors of ripe, slightly sweetish citrus fruits, some sour apple candy tones, a little bit of apple peel bitterness, light steely mineral notes, a hint of tangy salinity and a subtly lifted touch of VA. Very high and wonderfully structured acidity. The finish is crisp, long and lively with tangy, precise flavors of saline minerality and tart lemony citrus fruits, some apple peel bitterness, a little bit of stony minerality, light sweeter nuances of peachy stone fruits and a faint lifted hint of VA, bordering on subtly acetic.

A very crisp, intense and still so very youthful GG Riesling. Immensely tasty and very promising. At the moment the wine is still a bit nervy and high-strung, but it shows good potential for future development - I'd let the wine wait for another 5 years, perhaps even more, in order to let it show its best. Terrific stuff with lots of upside.
  • Mr_r commented:

    7/30/22, 9:29 AM - Both the standard and magnum sized bottles of the 2015 Piesporter Goldtröpfchen are the same ’Gruft’ matured in small oak barrels, but for some reason it’s not stated on the label of the standard-sized bottle. From 2016 onwards it says Gruft on the label of the 750 ml bottle as another cadaster-specific GG from the Goldtröpfchen vineyard, called ’Hohlweid’, was introduced. (The Hohlweid is made entirely in stainless steel, but in later years with some whole berries left in for added texture). I suspect the 2015 Gruft magnum came out when there were two different GG:s and the label needed clarification. The 2020 vintage now even states the exact cadaster name - Ober der Gruft - on the back label.

  • Mr_r commented:

    7/31/22, 11:50 PM - Short answer: yes.

    Long answer: The 1971 German wine law prohibited the use on the label of any geographical location narrower than an official vineyard site (e.g. Piesporter Goldtröpfchen). Since 2014 it is allowed to use narrower geographical terms and the 2021 reform of the wine law (which replaces the old law in 2025) expressly allows for the use of narrower geographical terms so long as they are registered in the official cadaster (aka the land register of Germany). The German term for such a site is a ’Gewann’.

    However, to make things more complex, the 1971 wine law lumped together several vineyards into one while usually retaining the name of the most well-known one. One such case is the Piesporter Goldtröpfchen, which used to be much smaller until several other vineyards were consolidated into it. One such vineyard that got stuffed into the Goldtröpfchen is the Gruft, which is shown e.g. already on the 1868 Prussian tax map. Another vineyard, the Hohlweid, is marked on the 1906 (fourth edition) of the Prussian tax map.

    From a historical standpoint what today are Gewanne can be either a former single vineyard or a sector within a single vineyard. There are also cases where these historical sectors are not in the land register, but they are referenced to in the context of the old tax maps.

    It is very common to leave out any prefixes, since they don’t usually carry any information. Examples of these are Zeltinger Sonnenuhr ’Bömer’ (’Im Bömer’), Ürziger Würzgarten ’Kranklei’ (’In der Kranklei’), and Erdener Treppchen ’Herzlei’ (’In der Herzlei’). Sometimes they do carry information, such as Saarburger Rausch ’Auf dem Rausch’ as the long name distinguishes the Gewann from the actual vineyard.

    When the front label says ’Gruft’ and the back label says ’Ober der Gruft’ it is the same thing - a historical vineyard that lives on as a Gewann.

    However, things are not so simple when it comes to the ’Hohlweid’. It is one historical vineyard, but nowadays two separate Gewanne - ’In der Holhweid’ and ’Unten in der Hohlweid’. As Lehnert-Veit’s current 2018 Piesporter Goldtröpfchen GG Hohlweid does not carry the exact Gewann name, it is not possible to know without asking whether this refers to the historical Hohlweid as a whole or just to either of the current Gewanne.

    The approximate locations of each Gewanne can be viewed on the cadaster map of the state of Rhineland-Palatinate here:
    https://maps.rlp.de/?layerIDs=7,172&visibility=true,true&transparency=0,NaN¢er=351192.87790265493,5528127.46188297&zoomlevel=10

  • Mr_r commented:

    8/1/22, 7:27 AM - (The Gewann ’Im Bömer’ - perhaps best known from a bottling by Selbach-Oster - lies in the Zeltinger Schloßberg vineyard and not in the Sonnenuhr as I falsely claimed.)

White
2017 Rita & Rudolf Trossen Riesling Pyramide Purus Mosel Saar Ruwer
12/10/2019 - forceberry wrote:
79 points
Fermented spontaneously with natural yeasts in 1000-liter stainless steel tanks. Fermented over 6 months, aged for 11 months on the lees. Bottled without fining, filtration or sulfites. 12,5% alcohol.

Deep and very slightly hazy copper color. Slightly wild, waxy and fine-tuned nose with somewhat sweet-toned aromas of honeysuckle, orange marmalade, some beeswax, a little bit of nuttiness, light grapey tones and a hint of bruised apple. The wine is light-to-medium-bodied, dry and rather acid-driven on the palate with crisp flavors of tart lemony citrus fruits, stony minerality, some oxidative nuttiness, a little bit of bruised apple, light smoky notes, a hint of Tawny-ish caramel and a touch of tangy salinity. The wine is quite intense and structured, but rather flat in the fruit department. The finish is dry, crisp and quite saline with intense flavors of tart lemony citrus fruits, some oxidative nuttiness, a little bit of bruised apple, light honeyed tones and a hint of white currant.

This really doesn't taste like a "unique take on a Riesling", this tastes more like a Riesling that has been kept too long open so it has oxidized. It's not funky, weird or faulty as all too many no-sulfite wines are, but it's nothing particularly captivating either. I wonder if this wine is supposed to be like this (i.e. it is vinified into this style and bottled like this) or if this bottle was just oxidized for one reason or another? Overall the wine is enjoyably fresh and focused, but if this is the style the producer is seeking, I fail to see the point.
  • Mr_r commented:

    12/11/19, 12:08 PM - This is, unfortunately, the house style ever since the early 2010s when importers and sommeliers (especially restaurant Noma in Copenhagen where Trossen wines are a staple of the wine list) started requesting that the wines be unsulfured. Since this ”natural wine” is made reductively in stainless steel (an alloy that does not appear naturally on this planet...) and the variety is the high-acid, low-pH riesling grape, the wine ends up like this: clean but oxidized. These same importers then went to Thorsten Melsheimer and Ulrich Stein and asked them to make unsulfured wines, too. Their ”natural” wines end up being different beasts since they are fermented and aged in old oak, which exposes the wine to oxygen early on and later protects the wine from tasting oxidized in the way Trossen wines do.

Red
2015 Jaagu Annemäe talu Rondo Otepää
12/16/2017 - forceberry wrote:
67 points
100% Estonian Rondo, vinified in a plastic wading pool. 11% alcohol. Tasted blind.

Slightly hazy and somewhat mahogany-hued pomegranate color, making the wine appear somewhat aged. The nose feels somewhat unclean with reticent aromas of raspberry, some sappy greenness of willow bark and a hint of unripe leafy character. The wine is very light-bodied, tart and racy on the palate with almost unripe and somewhat sappy, green flavors of fresh raspberries, tart green apples and some crowberries. The tannins are not particularly ample, but they feel quite underripe, green and aggressive, giving the wine noticeable tannic astringency. The finish is quite green-toned and coarse with light yet harsh, green tannins and medium-long, underripe and sappy flavors of tart green apples, underripe raspberries, redcurrants and chlorophyll.

Ugh. A thin, green and unbalanced red wine with no body nor any sense of ripeness. Although the tannins are not particularly ample, they are still aggressive enough to give the wine quite heavily astringent tannic structure. Not really an enjoyable wine. My guess was that it was a Latvian Zilga, so I wasn't that far off.
  • Mr_r commented:

    10/25/18, 12:36 PM - Nick: They have it in restaurant Leib in Tallinn. The restaurant is one of the best in town, whereas the Rondo is quite the opposite :) http://www.leibresto.ee/en/

White
2015 Martin Müllen Kröver Kirchlay Riesling Spätlese trocken ** Mosel Saar Ruwer
3/4/2017 - forceberry wrote:
88 points
12% alcohol.

Pale green color. Restrained and crisp nose with subtle aromas of sharp lemony fruit, some stone dust and a hint of smoke. The wine is ridiculously crisp, bracingly acid-driven and tightly-knit on the palate with racy flavors of ripe green apples, lemony citrus fruits and wet stones. There's obviously a lot of ripe fruit, but all of it is underneath the racy acidity, making the wine appear quite closed and austere. The long and dry finish is lively, crisp and racy with sharp flavors of green apples, grapefruit, some lemon zest and a hint of chalky bitterness.

A remarkably racy, rather austere and very tightly-knit Mosel Trocken Riesling that feels rather closed right now. The ripeness from this warm vintage is quite obvious, but it doesn't translate to expressive, fruity character - at least not yet. Impressive, but rather lean and inapproachable stuff, even though it isn't particularly austere in style. I suspect this wine will need more than a decade before it starts to drink nicely and perhaps another one to reach its apogee.
  • Mr_r commented:

    1/11/18, 9:52 PM - When it comes to acidity, this one goes to eleven. There’s 11.4 g/L of it in this one :)

1 - 4 of 4
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close