3/25/24, 6:28 AM - I paid $36 for a regular bottle. NYC and post Covid prices. Expectations change when I hit $35 as compared to what else you can buy. Winesearcher shows you can buy it for $21 today.
3/25/24, 8:21 AM - Thanks for the feedback and educating me on the impact of CellarTracker on the wine consumer market. Everyone is free to use CellarTracker in a way that suits them. I rate my wine based upon my palate and what I consider the right score for me. Price or value is definitely a factor in how I rate a wine and what I expect at a given price point. Same as I would do for anything else I purchase. I’m often quite surprised by all the 90+ ratings but nobody can account for someone else’s tastes or perspective. Hopefully most wine consumers read reviews before they make wine purchases, factoring in the views of the person setting the score. If they don’t and only go by the raw number, that is on them. I think there are loads of good wines out there. For me something exceptional, to score In the 90s needs to be something with more complexity and stands out more from their peers. Maybe you should post a review for your magnum, and get your friends to as well, and then my score will be diluted to something that makes you feel better. This is probably EXACTLY what the founder of this website hopes will happen as he works hard to keep it authentic and prepares to rollout features where people will pay to participate. Have a great day and remember, life is too short to drink bad wine.
8/30/23, 5:48 PM - Fun note!
6/19/21, 6:56 AM - Good note. Love the reference to flan. I have 1 bottle left. I think you either like this style or not.
4/27/21, 5:00 AM - The wine was not flawed but I don’t feel it was anything more IMHO than average for the price I paid. Perhaps review the definitions of the rating scales provided before you extend criticism towards others because you don’t agree with their rating. And even then, taste is relative. If you love this wine, lucky you. Personally, I feel too many people on the site over inflate their ratings. If every wine is deemed 90+, exceptional or outstanding, you are quite fortunate, but then isn’t that your average? Certainly if you are the wine maker, I apologize for hurting your feelings. I prefer a more balanced, nuanced, and less hot, GSM, where you can pick out the components to the different fruit. This felt more like a fruit smoothie to my palate.
4/27/21, 5:29 AM - Ok fair enough. Then I hope you continue to enjoy this wine. The beauty of this site, people who have similar tastes to mine, will maybe think twice before buying it. People who tend to agree with you, will enjoy it. Not a perfect science but it helps remove some of the mystery when laying down money on a bottle of wine. With so much to choose from, why get stuck with wine you don’t really enjoy? Cheers.
12/19/20, 4:12 PM - You seem a bit generous on the rating for such dissatisfaction!
11/23/20, 3:05 PM - Better second day wine.
11/7/20, 4:54 PM - Sounds like you have an agenda! Wow.
8/22/20, 7:12 AM - I tried it last in March 2018 and keep hoping as I have another bottle. A friend who knows a bit about wine says the fruit will fall out and all I’ll be left with is the alcohol. Bummer.
7/20/20, 6:30 PM - How do you know what wine I drank?
5/29/20, 10:37 AM - Curious to hear. This wine is just too much work IMHO.
1/13/20, 3:55 PM - I have been sitting on this for years even before I had the pleasure of meeting you! Recognized your screen name!
10/29/19, 6:04 AM - I have 2 left. Better get cracking. Anything else you can share?
10/29/19, 8:42 AM - Thanks. Been “saving it” for that steak dinner I never seem to cook. This is helpful in terms of planning.
9/12/19, 6:26 PM - Not want to share with anyone. That is helpful. Glad I have a half bottle.
8/14/19, 5:16 AM - Totally get the nail polish note. Good one.
6/30/19, 6:20 AM - That’s sad. Is it possible it’s in it’s sleeping phase st the moment?
6/30/19, 3:20 PM - I have 2 left as well. That is too bad, but a reminder not to wait too long. Ugh.
5/18/19, 7:01 AM - Poopy? Hope you are well otherwise!
3/7/19, 5:10 PM - But that you are comparing to a y’quem says a lot!
2/10/19, 3:52 PM - Am struggling with these.
12/27/18, 5:29 AM - Been saving a bottle. Can’t wait!
12/24/18, 6:08 AM - The shut down part is disturbing. Hopefully a phase?
8/8/18, 5:32 PM - Great note. This has been my summer standby. It has enough umph to stand up to most summer dishes. 2015 yet still very fresh and alive. It holds its own.
3/26/18, 9:32 AM - Sad...but helpful as I’ve been holding two.
3/23/18, 9:12 AM - Interesting descriptors. Shrimp shell. I’m curious.
3/11/18, 7:45 AM - I will finally be opening mine at a dinner in a few weeks. Will look for these notes. Excited.
2/3/18, 7:01 AM - Great detailed note. Gave me a good mental image. Thanks!
4/22/17, 3:35 PM - Trying today. Helpful note. I think it has opened up a bit more - fruit is powerful but could see this.
12/3/16, 6:04 AM - Great note! So nice for a change to read something that actually gives a visual of what to expect. Thanks!
11/29/16, 2:36 PM - I read the rating guidance on the site and try to use that more religiously. Im saving my 90s for the really special ones. Then you will know I mean it!
11/13/16, 2:26 PM - Im going to say that this is a much better 2nd day wine!
9/30/16, 2:30 PM - Better day 2 - not corked or flawed. At this price point, I would want something low maintenance PnP
4/2/16, 1:19 PM - That is depressing. Doesn't Bordeaux sometimes go to sleep and then wake up again? Could this be the case?
4/3/16, 7:22 AM - I've been sitting on a few bottles for a few years now so will remain hopeful. It would be quite disappointing to say the least. Thanks again.
1/21/16, 4:40 PM - I would revise my rating to one more positive now that it is warming. I sense it was too cold at first. Definitely more fruit is coming forward. Not my favorite....but probably more drinkable. Still has a bitter note that isn't my favorite. Fortunately, there are other things go to drink.
1/8/16, 6:51 PM - Hmmm. I wonder if aging will help? I hope so as I have a few bottles.
1/9/16, 6:02 AM - Ok thanks! I do tend to enjoy CNdP so feel a bit more optimistic. Think I will wait a bit more on it, and very much appreciate your perspective. Thanks!
1/5/16, 3:21 PM - Ha! Apparently my fingers typed Prosecco by mistake. Not a huge Lambrusco fan either.
12/1/15, 11:38 AM - Ha! You are correct on palate! Thanks. I've been lazy. I do pay NYC premium on wine and it may not have been the most economical store but many stores don't carry a lot here from this region. I am not sure it was worth $44 retail, though I did enjoy it.
11/14/15, 6:19 PM - Addendum. A few hours in it has opened up quite a bit. I would describe it as a scent value Malbec. No surprises, what you would expect, nice fruit, dependable.
11/3/15, 4:39 AM - Thanks. I'm sitting on 2 bottles and also have a 2008, which I'll probably break into first. However, seems no rush.
10/14/15, 6:50 AM - Lovely, poetic review! Thanks. I have 3 bottles that I've been storing with anxious anticipation. I'm wondering if decanting might help it open up more quickly?
8/20/15, 5:01 PM - Brought it to a wine dinner earlier this week. I let it sit for about 40 minutes uncorked before serving which made a huge difference in terms of opening up. I enjoyed it so much that I subsequently purchased 3 more bottles. I think it's a lovely summer red. Not your "typical" Gamay. I'm curious how it will age.
8/10/15, 7:08 PM - Thanks for the note. I purchased a few bottles last fall and trying to figure out when is the right time to break in. I enjoyed a glass at a wine bar last fall and thought about it for days later so figured it was time to purchase. Looking forward to enjoying it and this review helps convince me should be soon.
3/29/15, 10:17 AM - It benefited from decanting in that the palette opened up, and came together a bit a slightly more balanced way. However, I tend to favor a wine with more subtlety. This wine, lots of fruit, lots of wood, high alcohol, not high tannins. As another review stated, this is a BIG wine. Holds its own with a flavorful steak. Needs food.
2/22/15, 4:44 PM - It has opened up. 2 hours in. It's a nice "budget" interpretation of a typically expensive varietal. Good quality and value for price. A nice balanced wine.
2/18/15, 6:45 PM - As it warmed up I taste more fruit on palette but I still don't love it. Still a lot of alcohol on palette for 13%. Not good balance IMHO
1/17/15, 5:24 AM - Not saying all, but some of the Central Coast, CA Syrahs, can be nice and worth a try. There seem to be two main styles, fruity or more peppery. The peppery ones are my favorites. Some of the winemakers are producing some interesting Rhone style blends.
1/17/15, 5:15 AM - Update to my review. I had 1/3 left in the bottle which I consumed the next evening. Much better and what I had expected from this wine. Definitely got the signature sour cherry candy flavor on the palate as well as meatiness and much complex spices. So it does open up eventually. Suggest you give it time to breathe or even a decant. I would buy it again but just need to let it sit open for longer before consuming.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search