12/9/22, 3:49 AM - I too think this wins needs more time. It certainly has the stuffing (tannin and acid wise) to last. I say give it 3+ years for balance. I recently had Dana Estates Vaso 2016, also an entry level wine made from grapes of young vines. Lots of life left.
11/2/22, 1:30 AM - Fun read. Thanks! Lived in the States a while back (Bmore) and had myself a 07 broken stones. Won me over, but my later experiences don’t bring me back. I have a G2 19 in the cellar (cabinet really). Will leave it be. Haha
11/2/22, 3:12 AM - Not that I mind getting overwhelmed at times.
12/26/21, 11:26 AM - Great 1st note. :)
10/17/20, 9:31 AM - You and me both. Will wait on my other bottle. But I enjoyed it all the same. And don’t regret popping it.
1/10/20, 2:01 AM - I don’t have much experience with Colgin. But had the 2010 IX shortly after release. I had the same impression then. Yet I remeber feeling this will be magnificent with some bottle age. I think that is what Tauziet is aiming for. I sure hope the 2016 IX will come around. Got two.
3/17/19, 10:45 AM - Great comment. I take it I should let my bottles lay. At the same time, you make me want to bring it always.
12/31/18, 4:18 AM - Thanks! I plan to pop a bottle tonight. Should a be on the watch for something? Or how come it didn’t merit a higher score?
12/31/18, 4:23 PM - Works for me. I’d take your comment over any score. Exactly what feeling you want the wine your serving to elicit. Our guests enjoyed it too. Happy new year!
7/15/18, 12:00 AM - I’ve had this multiple times over the past 12 months and temp now seems to be critical; it’s best right out of the cabinet (12-14°C). I don’t mind some smoky oak, but there’s been a lack of structure and complexity as of late. The wine seems subdued compared to a year ago.
5/14/18, 10:32 AM - Couldn’t agree more. A spectacular wine.
12/1/17, 12:41 PM - Gave a 2nd bottle more time in the decanter (ca 2 hrs) and that really made a difference. Revealed more structure and varietal. 94+ points.
5/6/17, 8:27 AM - I gave a 2nd bottle more time in the decanter (2+ hrs). Better. Still nothing like the 12 though. Good even after a couple of days in the fridge. Maybe hold off for a year or two?
12/31/16, 4:42 PM - Not shallow anywhere. Gorgeous throughout.
11/19/16, 9:05 AM - There's structure inherent to the dominating varietal here as well. Other dark fruits, licorice and black pepper. Wine of the year for me.
1/17/16, 1:17 AM - My understanding is Joly used to make age-worthy wines that were austere in their youth. I've really only tired the last couple of vintages (2011-), but my impression is that he's progressing "fast" towards natural wines. In fact, I perceived the Les Vieux Clos 13 as oxidized and dead upon release. The bottle of Coulée de Serrant 12 I had yesterday was good, but much less lively and mineral-driven than the one I had last summer. Could be it's entering a muted state and will come around, but my gut says it's past zenith already. In sum, Joly's "quick" move across the Loire valley chenin blanc spectra is not a preferred development IMO. All the best, Richard
4/29/15, 12:09 AM - Pop and pour.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search