Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(28 comments on 26 notes)

1 - 26 of 26 Sort order
Red
2012 Belle Pente Pinot Noir Estate Reserve Yamhill-Carlton
10/29/2023 - curtr Likes this wine:
93 points
Wow! at a great point in development.
  • curtr commented:

    2/21/24, 6:44 AM - Belle Pente does not make an over extracted style. Ted Lemon at Littorai was trained in Burgundy in France. Beautiful wines that pair well with food. Some are lighter, while others are bolder. If you are interested in Littorai, their wines are available on their website mailing list.

Red
2015 Ahh Pinot Noir Barrel 2 of 4 Bien Nacido Santa Maria Valley
Good structure. Drink 2023 to 2025.
  • curtr commented:

    2/21/24, 6:35 AM - Ahh is a great source of Pinot Noir made with purchased grapes from selected sights. Unfortunately, the smoke from the Fires in California tainted the vines that were used to produce Ahh after the 2015 vintage. The last vintage they produced was 2015. I only have 2014 and 2015 left in my cellar.

    When Bruce and Krassimira Rector started the Ahh label, they bottled in 1.0L size since a 750 ml was not enough wine for two people. Unfortunately their glass supplier stopped supplying the liter bottles several years ago.

    A great winery. My new favorites are Belle Pente(Oregon) "Reserve" and "Murto" Pinot Noir and Littorai in Sonoma.

Red
1984 Heitz Cellar Cabernet Sauvignon Martha's Vineyard Oakville
10/21/2023 - curtr Likes this wine:
92 points
Grew in depth with air, though not in the league with 1982 that I enjoyed 3 years ago. This wine started to fade at 2 hours. Drink over 90 minutes. Still a nice showing.

Served along with 1955 Inglenook - Cabernet Sauvignon and 2004 Quilceda Creek - Cabernet Sauvignon.
  • curtr commented:

    10/23/23, 4:58 AM - Guessing the correct amount of time to breathe wine is a challenge. Also there is sometimes provenance issues with the bottles storage over the years. Clearly your bottles have been in your possession from the beginning. My friend's bottle was purchased a few years ago. Thank you for leaving your comment. I will pass it on to my friend as I believe he has at least one more bottle.

Red
2015 Château Trotanoy Pomerol Red Bordeaux Blend
5/14/2022 - curtr Likes this wine:
95 points
Not as dark as the 2015 La Fleur-Petrus. Great future, however will need many years to mature. Drink 2035-2048.
  • curtr commented:

    12/3/22, 5:02 PM - I ment drinking in 2035 and finish up by 2048.

  • curtr commented:

    12/3/22, 5:04 PM - I fixed my original tasting note.

Red
2000 Château Lafon-Rochet St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
Friday Tasting Group: In HONOR of 1 of the Group's Mentors (Vintage Wines Ltd., San Diego, CA): Should you be interested, you can peruse info for this vintage which I’ve uploaded. 😉

N: Slightly closed; RIPE berries with undertones of earth?

P: Med body; RNDISH entry with NICE, ALMOST swtish frt met by some puckerish astringency which only somewhat resolves by the LONG, slightly bitterish finish. Might still improve? 13.0% ABV; My EXC-, as this IS *ult* somewhat pleasant. [As of mid May '19, wine-searcher still shows several vendors from $80-$99.]

Note: My TN of 3/8/2019 was WAY more positive.
  • curtr commented:

    1/14/22, 6:30 AM - Paul is a friend of mine. The one thing we have noticed is that there is bottle variation as wines get older. Also, wines go into and out of phase. My notes recommend trying my next bottle in 2024 and finish my remaining 2 bottles by 2028. We had a dinner on December 18th where bottle variation was evident in 1982 Leoville Las Cases, 1986 Pichon Lalande and 1989 Mouton Rothschild (notes posted under "CellarBord").

Red
2005 Ridge Monte Bello Santa Cruz Mountains Red Bordeaux Blend
5/15/2016 - llink wrote:
93 points
PWTG Ridge Monte Bello tasting, Flight of four vintages: 1999, 2002, 2005, 2006. Groups #1, My #1
Very dark fruited nose, with some coffee grinds and dill. Really deep nose, very luxurious. The palate is rich, complex and in a really good place. There are the beginnings of some secondary aromas and smoothness on the palate, but its still very primary and very well endowed.
  • curtr commented:

    11/14/21, 3:41 AM - I plan to try my first bottle in 2025 and possibly the 5th bottle by 2036. All depends on the wine's development over time. One can only guess if not tasting actual bottles.

Red
2002 Ridge Monte Bello Santa Cruz Mountains Red Bordeaux Blend
12/19/2020 - WildeMeeuw Likes this wine:
92 points
Kleur: Diep donkerrood.. Aroma / bouquet: Vol en opvallend belegen bouquet maar minder tertiair dan de fles die ik in 2017 proefde. Belegenmaar geen spoor van maggi of marmite. Wel gedroogd fruit, vooral gedroogde pruimen. Smaak / Afdronk: In dit stadium is deze Ridge Monte Bello werkelijk briljant. Krachtig, een indrukwekkende vulling en tegelijker tijd harmonieus en zacht. Geweldig lange afdronk. Algemeen / potentieel: Ik blijf me verbazen over de drinkbaarheidshorizon van Robert Parker. Tot 2022? Absoluut. Tot 2032? Ongetwijfeld. Maar tot 2072??? Nog 50! Jaar???? 50 + Kleur: 5 + Aroma / bouquet: 12 + Smaak / Afdronk: 17 + Algemeen / potentieel: 8 = 92/100

Color: Deep dark red .. Aroma / bouquet: Full and remarkably mature bouquet but less tertiary than the bottle I tasted in 2017. Matured but no trace of maggi or marmite. Dried fruit, especially prunes. Taste / Finish: At this stage, this Ridge Monte Bello is truly brilliant. Powerful, an impressive filling and at the same time harmonious and soft. Great long finish. Overall / potential: I never cease to be amazed by Robert Parker's drinkability horizon. Until 2022? Absolutely. Until 2032? Doubtless. But until 2072 ??? Another 50! Year ???? 50 + Color: 5 + Aroma / bouquet: 12 + Taste / Finish: 17 + Overall / potential: 8 = 92/100
  • curtr commented:

    11/14/21, 3:31 AM - My drinking range based on my bottle this year is 2028-2036. You can drink beyond 2036, yet the character is very different and the fruit starts to get replaced by mushroom and earthy tones. I am not a fan of that style.

Red
2002 Ridge Monte Bello Santa Cruz Mountains Red Bordeaux Blend
4/10/2021 - wchrisw Likes this wine:
92 points
Magnum. I had a big build up for this wine as I started prepping for it 2 weeks ago. I went to my wine storage facility to stand bottle upright on 3/27 to let any sediment fall. I opened it 4/9 with ah-so opener in anticipation of drinking 4/10 so I wanted to do a slow ox for a couple hours before recorking and then decanting following day. Cork broke. Took a sip after 30 minutes to check it out. It was still very lively. Next day deanted for 5 hours. It didn't taste 19 years old at all. Classic Monte Bello minerality, "weightless" as those at Ridge say, cassis, good acidity, could still go several more years. Bottle threw no sediment. Wine was great however I was expecting something more.
  • curtr commented:

    11/14/21, 3:26 AM - If you have another magnum, I would recommend waiting atleast 13 years. Drink 2033-2041. This is the oldest vintage in my cellar and 2017 is my only magnum.

White
2013 Domaine Jean-Marc Pillot Chassagne-Montrachet 1er Cru Les Vergers Clos Saint-Marc Chardonnay
7/18/2020 - Nicephoras wrote:
A blind, but again, my bottle. Decanted for about two hours (which it needs). This is a big wine, with serious heft. On the nose, this has more of the white fruit that I associate with Puligny, but the body is rich without ever suggesting the richness comes from oak. Next to a PYCM Perrieres, this was probably the bigger wine - this comes close to grand cru weight. (The guesses were all Puligny or Meursault.)
The finish is maybe a touch short, but with a decant, this is spectacular right now.
  • curtr commented:

    11/10/21, 2:21 PM - I agree with the need to decant many white Burgundy. I will make a note for my remaining bottles.

Red
2010 Château Kirwan Margaux Red Bordeaux Blend
11/12/2020 - Misology24 Likes this wine:
91 points
I'm bad; opened far too soon and knew it while pulling the cork and decanting for two hours for a special occasion. Clear, medium garnet color. Dry, medium acid, medium(+) tannin, medium(+) body, medium(+) alcohol. Still developing. Medium(+) intensity aroma and flavor with characteristics of black cassis/black currant, black raspberry, tobacco, anise, cedar, chocolate, leather, and wet stone. Medium(+) finish. Can drink now but has potential for aging. Quality level is very good. My recommendation is to leave cellared until at least 2025. That said, a very nice wine!

Paired nicely with a seasoned and grilled, 2-inch thick New York Strip with cilantro chimichurri drizzle and a double-baked potato. A little 30-year Tawny Port and St. Agur blue cheese for dessert - absolute Heaven!

Please let me know if this type of review "does it for you." Always looking to improve.
  • curtr commented:

    1/4/21, 9:10 AM - I look for people who taste and recommend how long to cellar before the wine is in a good place. I prefer to drink wines when they are mid plateau or later when there is more character development. I appreciate the experience of others at the earlier places on the development curve. I last had this wine on 10/16/2017 at a Kirwan dinner with my Bordeaux group. I published the note under CellarBord. I said wait until 2022. I will change to 2025 start drinking date based on your note. I like your format.

Red
1982 Heitz Cellar Cabernet Sauvignon Martha's Vineyard Oakville
5/21/2017 - paulst Likes this wine:
95 points
Rubber and tar nose; sweet earthy robust blackberry, raspberry and cherry; textured; sweet long finish.
  • curtr commented:

    10/10/20, 8:25 AM - Paul, I had this on 9/12. This wine is holding up very well and should continue for another 7-10 years without a problem. We drank side by side with the 2007 Abeja - Reserve from Washington. The 1982 Martha's had more character. Both were drinking well.

Red
2005 Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon Estate St. Helena
I had this bottle 9 years ago at a restaurant and it was one of the first truly great wines I had; fun to be able to try it again; served with beef tenderloin and red wine reduction; the nose initially showed a fair amount of oak, but with 30 min in the decanter this resolved and the nose became more balanced; creme de cassis, blueberry liqueur, a subtle hint of bell pepper, vanillin notes from the oak, violet, and just a hint of mocha. The palate is absolutely silky with filigreed tannins, ripe voluptuous fruit, and well judged acidity. Despite the density of the flavor, it does not feel heavy at all and there is not really any noticeable heat. A long finish rounds this out perfectly. A great example of ripe (but not overripe) Napa cabernet from one of the best producers. This still seemed very youthful to me at 15 yrs of age and really is still not quite at peak. Should provide another 15-20 years of stellar drinking.
  • curtr commented:

    5/20/20, 8:38 AM - I am reviewing drinking ranges for my wines as I have lots of time presently. I have adjusted my drinking range on 2005 Spottswoode to 2025-2035 per your tasting note. I plan to try my first bottle in 2025. I have 2006, 2013, 2014, 2015 and 2016 to enjoy in the future.

Red
2000 Château Rauzan-Ségla Margaux Red Bordeaux Blend
2/18/2016 - paulst Likes this wine:
90 points
Rubber and tar with rugged texture and loaded tannins; great in 20 years.
  • curtr commented:

    1/10/20, 4:36 AM - We had a bottle at the meeting last night. At 2 hours in the glass, started showing glimpses of what the future holds. This is early drinking window. I would check in again in 7-8 years. 90-91 pts now with upside.

Red
2000 Château Lafon-Rochet St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
1/16/2019 - paulst Likes this wine:
88 points
Light color; light soft cherry; soft fruit; light structure w/o tannic support; lean finish; not a great effort.
  • curtr commented:

    1/17/19, 2:40 PM - I have 3 bottles in my cellar and none left in Providence. I will try one soon and see what I find. It was drinking well in 2017 and seemed to have several years of life left.

Red
2011 Herdade do Mouchão Alicante Bouschet Alentejo
This is a cool wine to know about for folks like me who can see something appealing in the idea of Chateauneuf-du-Pape in theory but end up hating the taste of actual Chateauneuf-du-Pape in practice. The grape here is alicante bouschet, a genetic relative of grenache, and it has a similar warmth and heartiness but thankfully only a more distant resemblance in terms of flavor, none of that candied kirsch. It is still seriously rich stuff that calls for a winter stew. It combines red and black berry flavors with a minerality reminiscent of metal shavings and a more developed leatheriness that gives it a more Iberian feel. I'm told this is one of *the* signature dry reds from Portugal - first time I've ever had one so I can't evaluate it in that context or say anything about how it might develop - but I'd kind of hope it can mellow out a little because winter-stew nights aren't the norm around here.
  • curtr commented:

    12/15/18, 7:58 AM - I had the 2003 in my cellar. The wine was fully developed at 14 years of age. Patience is important.

Red
1982 Château Mouton Rothschild Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
Big, rich and closed at the moment. I see the potential, though I will have to be patient. Try again in 2025.
  • curtr commented:

    1/26/17, 11:31 AM - The 1982 seems to be in closed zone at the moment. I got very little pleasure on 12/31. I am hoping that the Mouton will emerge again in 8 years. I have 2 bottles remaining from my original case bought in the 80's. We will see if I can be patient.

Red
2012 Soos Creek Ciel du Cheval Vineyard Red Mountain Red Bordeaux Blend
2/2/2016 - SMHalps Likes this wine:
90 points
Brought it to a pizza party. I thought it would show better, but I did open it a day after it arrived via cross country shipping. Not bad, just seemed a little thin. Not as much fruit as I was expecting. Maybe the next bottle will be better. I haven't had the Ciel Du Cheval in years. I usually only get the Champoux, which I always enjoy.
  • curtr commented:

    5/26/16, 1:35 PM - I have experienced bottle shock from drinking bottles after shipping. I recommend waiting 2-3 months to allow shock to go away.

White
2010 Domaine Henri Boillot Meursault 1er Cru Les Genevrières Chardonnay
7/27/2015 - WoodieBayArea wrote:
89 points
this was the first of a six pack bought from WineBid (via Amazon) -- wondering now if that combo isn't optimal... this wine was disjointed and didn't work for me or my wife, tried over three days and didn't see the great fruit, acid, or minerals that we usually love about the copious amounts of white burg with drink... was surprised, hopefully just an off bottle, 89 might be generous for this specific bottle... never think of bottle shock for young white burgs -- anybody disagree? (we did drink soon after receiving the shipment)
  • curtr commented:

    1/30/16, 1:47 PM - I have a rule that I don't drink red or white bottles for at least one month that have been shipped. No one has confirmed that white is affected too. However, I have twice had white Burgundies shipped 10 days to two weeks before a dinner that came across muted. I now buy bottles earlier and allow them to rest for at least a month.

Red
1996 Château Calon-Ségur St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
8/9/2014 - paulst Likes this wine:
94 points
Tar and cedar; complex; textured; blackberry; long finish.
  • curtr commented:

    8/13/14, 3:16 PM - I found some Magnums for sale. Probably too expensive.

Rosé
2011 Château de Peyrassol Côtes de Provence Rosé Blend
1/21/2013 - Kirk Grant wrote:
Dinner with Doug & Becky; 1/20/2013-1/21/2013 (Waltham, MA): FROM MAGNUM: Excellent. Lovely and elegant with an almost fragile sense on the nose that if you don't inhale fully there may be something you miss. While I'm glad to have tried this wine...I will not be spending the coin for another magnum of it. Maybe this really deserves more attention in the summer...because it just wasn't as exciting as I had hoped...
  • curtr commented:

    5/5/14, 11:49 AM - My rule for Provence Rose is to begin drinking when released in late April/ early May and finish my last bottle by the October. The acidity begins to disappear in November/December and by January is well on its way to being a flat lifeless wine. I believe you held this wine too long. I found a bottle of 2011 that I misplaced and tried it in May 2013. There was no acidity or character remaining in the wine.

Red
2009 Reininger Syrah Walla Walla Valley
4/5/2014 - WaWineWill wrote:
91 points
Decanted briefly. Enjoyed over the course of an afternoon and evening. Bouquet of black fruits, smoke, sweet earth and hoisin. On the tongue -- plum, cassis, macerated cherry, fig compote, smoke and molasses. With more time and air, roasted meat, iron and tar notes emerged. There was a touch of heat that never really seemed to mellow, nor did the somewhat tannic finish. Guessing this needs more time in the cellar, and with the lovely flavor profile potential, this is a good thing.
  • curtr commented:

    4/18/14, 10:34 AM - I had a bottle during a visit to Seattle in November and the wine remained very tight for entire 3 hour dinner.

Red
2008 Château Pontet-Canet Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
Big, balanced, lots of potential. I will try my next bottle in 2022. Long life ahead.
  • curtr commented:

    10/11/13, 7:08 AM - I have tasted at least 8 different vintages of Pontet-Canet. I really like the style of the Chateau. However, you must be very patient with this wine as it takes many years of evolution to truly enjoy the wine. As I stated in my tasting note, I will wait 14 years past the vintage date before I will start sampling bottles from my case. I find you can get a general impression of the wine after release. Then it takes a period of time before the secondary complexities start to appear. Pontet-Canet takes a long time for this to happen.

    If you taste some of the better 2008 less expensive wines, the time it takes to reach the developed stage is much shorter. The wines may never reach the level of complexity of the wines like Pontet-Canet, yet will still be very enjoyable. I am still drinking my wines from the 80's and 90's as I wait for my younger wines to mature. Many of my friends put a few bottles away of the very good vintages of the better wines while drinking the better value wines on a regular basis.

Red
1982 Château Latour Grand Vin Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
11/5/2012 - Sleepy Dave wrote:
Alcohol :: 12.5%
The legendary Latour. Almost hit the peak (at least for the bottle). It has all the greatness of a Latour: incredible depth, scale and class. However, the overall profile is not as bright as I would expect from a great Latour, a little bit musky which I thought took away some balance and purity. Well, I ain't complaining though! I will reserve my rating until I have tasted another bottle to compare.
  • curtr commented:

    1/13/13, 10:59 AM - I respect that you did not rate what might have been a slightly off bottle.

Red
2008 David Arthur Meritaggio Napa Valley SuperTuscan Blend
9/14/2012 - mflesh wrote:
93 points
Enjoyed tonight at Del Frisco's in Fort Worth. Wine was uncorked to a dark red stain with zero bleed. The wine was decanted. Some was poured into the glass. The wine had a very herbal and brambly nose, with some flint, minerality, leather, smoke, and an herbal kind of component, rather dusty. I'll start reviewing the wine after it had been opened for 30 minutes. The wine was, from start to finish and even after opening, very elegant. Soft, full bodied wine. On the palate was a blackberry fruit front with maybe some young slightly ripe plum, trending towards a creme de cassis and some dark chocolate mocha, but had a very interesting flinty, rocky component that would sometimes show itself. Finish was leathery, spicy with food, but rather subdued without. The best thing about this wine was that it went with Italian marinated shrimp, a salad with an avocado ranch, steak, creamed spinach and broccoli and each one of these courses showed a slightly different side of the wine. The shrimp showed more of the mid and finish. The steak accentuated the spice and the front. Overall quite a treat. Thank you to the Sangiovese component! This wine is still fairly young. Definitely don't agree with the 2014 community "drink by" date at all. Drink now with decanting, or hold for probably up to 5 years.
  • curtr commented:

    1/10/13, 11:44 AM - I appreciate your comment on aging this wine. Predicting how long a wine will last has never been an area I am comfortable predicting.

White - Sparkling
1996 Veuve Clicquot Champagne Brut La Grande Dame Champagne Blend
12/31/2012 - curtr Likes this wine:
91 points
Starting to lose its fizz. Still a nice bottle, yet on the decline.
  • curtr commented:

    1/5/13, 6:23 AM - I have stored it on its side since I purchased it. The temp in my cellar is 56 F at all times. I was unaware that I had a bottle remaining(it was in its original gift box on top of one of the racks). The previous bottles were consumed more than 6 years ago and all were in great shape. Bottle variation? I had a bottle 96 Dom Perignon that was at its peak drinkability last winter and should stay there a few more years.

White - Sparkling
N.V. Charles Heidsieck Champagne Brut Réserve Champagne Blend
12/24/2012 - curtr Likes this wine:
89 points
I agree with John Gilman that this champagne has not aged enough to come together. Try again in 2014.
  • curtr commented:

    12/26/12, 5:06 PM - The bottle I had on December 24, 2012 stated on the bottle label that it was disgorged in 2012.

  • curtr commented:

    1/3/13, 11:29 AM - Yes, I believe it is the new packaging. I think it's great that Charles Heidsieck puts the disgorge date on the back label of the bottle. I wish more champagne house would consider this practice.

1 - 26 of 26
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close