Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(7 comments on 6 notes)

1 - 6 of 6 Sort order
Red
2018 Orin Swift Machete California Red Blend
7/29/2023 - 3daywinereview.com wrote:
65 points
20 People Bring a Bottle (Good, The Bad & The Ugly) (Edina, MN): Not only are the labels stupid on Orin Swift Wines the juice inside the bottle is much worse. Other than Caymus who gets more for their juice. These are bulk grapes at best in these bottles with some Mega Purple thrown in. Sweet, watered down, brown sugar and damp earth. Again when people rate these are you applying the tasting process correctly? Love the appellation of California on these.
  • msh305 commented:

    11/24/23, 2:41 PM - I think the labels are awesome! And obviously you're all alone with your childish rating. Cheers!

Red
2021 Le Macchiole Bolgheri Rosso SuperTuscan Blend
과실의 집중도가 훌륭했던 와인, 그러나 아직은 따지 말아야 했던 와인.
아주 쉽게 말하면 와인을 떫고 써서 안 마신다는 사람들이 마셨으면 역시 내 생각은 틀리지 않았어라고 할 와인.
쓰고보니 악평인 것 같지만 생각보다 (특히나 가격을 생각하면) 괜찮았던 와인.

노즈에서는 블랙 과실의 향기가 꽤나 강하게 느껴진다.
오크향이 느껴지긴 하는데 온도가 차갑게 서빙되어 그런지 아주 가볍게만 느껴진다.
곧이어 기분 좋은 바닐라 향이 나서 나쁘지 않았다.

팔렛에서는 일단 탄닌이 너무 빡빡하고, 바디감 역시 상당히 묵직하다.
호주 쉬라즈 느낌만큼이나 매운(?) 맛이 느껴지는데 나는 이걸 싫어하지 않긴 하는데 여튼 꽤 강렬하다.
밸런스가 분명히 깨져있는 건 맞는데 개인적으론 와인이 아닌 독주를 마시는 느낌이라 그리 나쁘지 만은 않았다.
  • msh305 commented:

    11/21/23, 1:10 PM - English please

  • msh305 commented:

    11/21/23, 1:10 PM - English please

Red
2006 Fontodi Flaccianello della Pieve Colli della Toscana Centrale IGT Sangiovese
6/25/2017 - wurzel68 Likes this wine:
91 points
Brauchte erst eine Weile Luft zum Atmen. Dann entwickeln sich Sauerkirsch- und Pflaumenaromen, Veilchen, Zigarrenbox, mineralische und sekundär-erdige Töne. Weicher Wein mit geschmeidigem, feinen Tannin; leider etwas zehrend und alkohollastig im langen. sonst hervorragenden Abgang.
  • msh305 commented:

    8/23/17, 3:53 PM - Schultz!

Red
2008 Quilceda Creek Cabernet Sauvignon Columbia Valley
11/8/2016 - Wine12345 Likes this wine:
95 points
Opened the bottle this morning, expecting to drink it in celebration of today's big election. Instead, we drank the bottle in quiet, sad consolation. A wonderful bottle of wine, and a terrible day for our country.
  • msh305 commented:

    11/13/16, 2:44 PM - When I want your liberal comments, I'll beat them out of you. Oh wait, that's what disgruntled crybaby libs are doing right now! Go set yourself on fire and let the rest of us enjoy our wine.

Red
2011 Robert Foley The Griffin Napa Valley Red Blend
8/28/2016 - msh305 Likes this wine:
92 points
This was the last of my 6 bottles of 2011 Griffin and I believe it's reached its peak. We finished 3/4 of the bottle on the first night and polished it off on day 2. Unlike previous bottles which were better on day 2, this one was not. This is an outstanding cab blend for the money and I wouldn't hesitate to buy more if I could find it. Though with about 2 cases of 2012 and 2013 waiting in the wings, we're looking forward to tasting the younger brothers.
  • msh305 commented:

    8/30/16, 2:13 AM - I believe it's reached its peak because this was the first time that there was no improvement on the second day. With all previous bottles the wine showed improvement on day 2, but not so this time. I don't think there's any need to rush your last two bottles, but I would finish them at a single sitting. Cheers!

Red
2007 Stewart Cabernet Sauvignon Nomad Napa Valley
8/24/2014 - 1961Vintage wrote:
88 points
Somewhat disappointing...Thats all I'll say. Enjoyed the 06 and 07 much better
  • msh305 commented:

    3/5/16, 1:36 PM - 1961vintage, this IS the '07.

1 - 6 of 6
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close