Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Tasting Notes for amateur62

(1,598 notes on 1,184 wines)

1 - 50 of 1,598 Sort order
Red
4/22/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
Decanted 3 hours before dinner that helped a lot to open. Nice mature nose with tar, ethereal and dark berries, on the palate earthy notes, medium+ bodied and long, balanced finish.

Very classic Nebbiolo that would be hard to differ from a Barbaresco, 93 points for the nose, 91 points for the palate. Drink within the next 6 to 12 years.
White
4/21/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
Was quite muted and a bit flabby when I opened it just after the Kabinett from the Juffer that was very expressive. From the second bottle, there were only two glasses consumed, the rest we enjoyed two days later, time helped a lot and it was really good with a nice Riesling nose, good minerality, high acidity, quite dry, medium bodied and good length.

Seems as it enters now a bit difficult stage, the youthful easiness it had a year ago is gone and it requires more patience now, so I will wait now a couple of years with my next bottles.
1 person found this helpful Comment
White
4/19/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
93 points
Wow, is this good. Expressive Riesling nose from the first minute, full of fruit with a hint of petrol, on the palate good balance between acidity and sweetness, good depth and long finish.

Textbook Kabinett in a good spot now, for sure, it will age nicely but there is also no reason not to drink it now. A big step up compared to the Brauneberger Riesling J trocken, we had at the same evening.
White
4/15/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
89 points
Chardonnay aged in used barrique (30%) and stainless steel, 13% vol.

PnP. On the nose sweet blossom and ripe orchard fruit, on the palate quite lush, round and good persistence. No obvious difference on the next day.

Quite different compared to the tasting at the domain 2 years ago, the mineral touch is gone and the sweet fruit dominates now. Not a complex wine at the current stage, nevertheless, it was a good choice for the aperitif.
Rosé - Sparkling
4/14/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
89 points
87.6% Pinot Noir, 12.4% Chardonnay; base vintage 2016; dosage 8g/l; disgorging 10.11.2020.

Big bubbles but surprisingly long lasting, on the nose brioche and shy red berry fruit, on the palate dry, fresh and linear, finish shows medium length, precise, not bad at all but a bit simple.

Not much difference compared to the bottle from the same lot 3 years ago.

Looking at the price point, this gets more and more crazy with Champagne, this might be OK for the prestige wines, but 60€ or more for basic bottlings (even if it is labelled as Grand Cru)? In Jura, I get for the same price 3 or 4 bottles of similar quality.
1 person found this helpful Comment
White
4/13/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
89 points
Grillo aged in stainless steel, 13% vol.

Have expected another style when thinking on the Cure song “Friday I'm in Love”, nevertheless, the bottle was not bad. Needs air to open, starts quite shy with white fruits and a mineral touch, on the palate fresh, dry and medium bodied.

Good at aperitif or with sea food, drink now or within the next 4 years (88-89).
White
4/11/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
91 points
PnP. Needs a bit air to open. Nice Riesling nose, floral with some yellow stone fruit and a hint of Petrol. On the palate medium acidity, needs a bit time to get more depth, slightly creamy, medium to long finish, 90-91+.

First vintage with the "Prädikat Grosses Gewächs", in 2017 it was still “Erste Lage”. At the beginning of its drinking Window, will age nicely for many years.
White
4/7/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
Double decanted an hour before dinner and followed over the next two hours. On the nose dried pineapple, fresh herbs and a suggestion of hazelnut, on the palate creamy and rather full bodied (14% vol.), medium acidity, nice bitter note that matched perfectly with the fish we had, good length.

Less on the mineral side than La Verchère from the same vintage, more Côte de Beaune like. Beginning maturity, starts to make fun, but needs a lot of air to show its best, I will wait another 2 years with my next bottle.
White
4/6/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
90 points
Shows a light straw with a green reflex. Quit similar to last tasting note, a bit more developed on the nose, similar to a Riesling with green apples and white stone fruits. On the palate it is still very fresh and light (unbelievable that it shall have 14.5% vol.) without any signs of maturity, medium length.

If I had to guess the age of the wine, I would say 3 to 4 years old, drink now or within the next decade or so.
Red
2008 Château de Fieuzal Pessac-Léognan Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
4/4/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
Decanted an hour before dinner. Similar as the bottle 30 months ago but a tad better with leather, forest floor, dark fruits and a suggestion of gamey flavours, on the palate smooth tannins, medium+ acidity, good concentration and a long, slightly rustic finish.

Classic old school Bordeaux, in a good place now, will hold for another 6 to 10 years but will most probably not improve anymore, a short decant of 30 to 60 minutes is recommended.
1 person found this helpful Comment
White
PnP and enjoyed over 4 days. Superb from the very first moment, shows lemon and walnut with a suggestion of curry and lovage. On the palate some creaminess, good freshness, depth and good length.

Best on day one and day four, in between it was a tad less compelling. It is already very good, though still very young and will need many years to peak and to show more complexity, I will wait a couple of years for the next bottle.
Red
3/23/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
93 points
Tempranillo (90%) from vines over 60 years old, complemented by Graciano (10%), destemmed and fermented in stainless steel tanks controlled temperature for 18 days. Aged 4 years in 4-year-old American oak barrels. Total acidity 5.9 g/l, alcohol 13.5% vol.

Decanted 2h before dinner, but it still improved with more time. Superb intense nose, dark fruited, tar and ethereal, on the palate good freshness, dry and full bodied, good length with still some edges but not disruptive.

Classic Reserva from a superb vintage, developed nicely within the last 30 months but requires still more cellaring time to peak. Drink now with a long decant or within the next 2 decades, 92-93+.
3 people found this helpful Comment
White - Sweet/Dessert
2011 Château Rieussec Sauternes Sémillon-Sauvignon Blanc Blend (view label images)
3/22/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
94 points
PnP from a small bottle out of the fridge. Less intense than the last bottle, needed some minutes to open. On the palate notes from botrytis, dried apricot and honey, on the palate sweet, good freshness, creamy, dense and long.

Great achievement, drink now to enjoy the perfect balance this wine shows now or wait a decade for the first tertiary notes, that will add the complexity you are looking for when opening a bottle of Rieussec.
4 people found this helpful Comment
Red
3/22/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
93 points
Was double decanted the evening before and an additional decant 2 hours before dinner. Nice nose with a mixture of cherries, tar and first notes of maturity. on the palate good structure and high acidity, present tannin and a long finish with still some edges but without any heat at 14.5% vol.

Very old school Barolo, already very approachable but will be best in a decade or so I think, 92 to 93+.
Red
3/22/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
93 points
Was double decanted 24h before dinner. On the nose starting a bit shy and opens with air, still very primary with red berries and red stone fruit, on the palate pure and very elegant, dense but not heavy, good length, superb.

Quite different to the Valferana 2011 we had just before. Still very youthful, already very good but just at the beginning of its drinking window, will easily go for another 10 to 20 years, 93+.
Red
3/22/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
Was double decanted 24h before dinner. Smells incredibly good with rose petals and tar with underlying red stone fruit, on the palate it starts elegant with high acidity and smooth tannin, but gets a bit rustic with additional air, medium+ bodied and good persistence.

Old school Gattinara, very good now if giving it enough air, but has the structure to go for another 10 to 15 years, 92+.
White
3/17/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
PnP and drunk over 2 days. Linear and boring on the first day, better on the second day with more freshness and depth, on the nose lemony and fresh herbs. Not bad but was more interesting 2 years ago, will it come back with more age? Let's see.
Red
3/16/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
Destemmed and fermented in stainless steel, aged in big oak barrels and bottled in January 2013, 14% vol.

Decanted 2 hours before dinner. Mature nose with red stone fruit, underwood and a suggestion of mushrooms, on the palate smooth tannin, medium+ acidity, full bodied and long finish.

It's my first bottle from this brand and expected something more modern looking at the label but in fact it is a very old school Brunello, slightly on the rustic side but still very enjoyable, drink now or within the next 4 to 6 years.
White - Sparkling
3/15/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
89 points
Chardonnay 50+%, Pinot Noir 30-35%, Pinot Meunier 10-15%, 15-30% reserve wine, aged 4 years, 12% vol., bought 16 months ago in the local supermarket.

Cork was in shape as it would have been bottled recently. Tiny bubbles, apple and brioche, medium acidity, slightly creamy with a good mouthfeel, medium length, well balanced.

Good basic Champagne for a fair price (for Champagne).
Red
2002 Château Branaire-Ducru St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
3/10/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
Fresh, red berries and elegance were the first impressions when I opened the bottle to check that it has no fault, so I decided not to decant. 4 hours later at dinner it showed a darker fruit profile and first tertiary notes, on the palate good freshness, medium+ bodied and rather elegant, smooth tannin and a good length, everything in a good balance.

Classic old school Médoc at peak now but well stored bottles will easily go for another 6 to 8 years. Matched perfectly with our home made gratin dauphinois and the beef.
1 person found this helpful Comment
White
3/10/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
91 points
More than 60 years old vines, natural farming, fermented with indigenous yeasts, 7 months "sur lie", 12% vol.

PnP. Starts quite lemony and with a fresh sea breeze, on the palate very clean, high acidity, rather light and with medium length. With air it gets a suggestion of green apples, more depth and the acidity gets less prominent, very good.

Nice Muscadet in a good spot now and with superb price to quality relation.
2 people found this helpful Comment
White
3/7/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
Chardonnay from natural farming, aged about 24 months in barrels of 650 l and 24 months in stainless steel, bottled without any additives 19.08.2022, 14.5% vol.

Restaurant Lokal, Biel. PnP. Needs air and gets better with every minute. On the nose apples and a touch of exotic fruits that get replaced by citrous notes at the end of the course, some yeasty notes, medium to high acidity, dry, good depth and long finish with a hint of lemon zest. The fairly high alcohol content was not noticeable, no it was even rather light on its feet.

Natural wine from one of the best, without any oxidative nor funky notes, still a bit young and will profit from another couple of years in the cellar, 92+. Always a pleasure to drink these wines, give it enough air at this stage, best would be to decant for an hour.
2 people found this helpful Comment
Red
3/3/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
80% Tannat, 20% Cabernet Franc. Maturing on the lees for 12-14 months in 60-80% new barrels, 14% vol.

Decanted 3 hours before dinner, that helped a lot to open. Quite different to the last bottle 3 and a half years ago, the primary fruit and the notes from the oak are gone, there is still some dark fruit, but in addition it shows tar and roses, on the palate good freshness and structure, medium to full bodied but still rather elegant and with good length.

In a nice place now, first maturity, the nose is more suptle than a couple of years ago and the tannins are still there but fine grained, quite Barolo like, it's the first time I get this from a wine from Brumont. Was perfect with the brasato we had. Drink within the next 8 to 12 years and give it a lot of air.
1 person found this helpful Comment
White
3/3/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
PnP. On the nose white blossom, white and yellow stone fruit and a suggestion of petrol, similar as the last bottle 15months ago, but on the palate the sweetness is gone, still with good freshness but less charming now, not that it would be unpleasant, but something is missing, hope it is just an in between phase and will be better again in a couple of years.
White
3/2/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
93 points
Chenin Blanc from biodynamic farming, 13% vol.

When I opened the bottle it was quite lush and not what I was expecting, the note from Julian Marshall is a spot on it, but after an hour in the decanter it was delicious. On the nose sweet and fresh notes with kumquat, quince and a suggestion of yellow stone fruit, on the palate creamy but dry, very good mouthfeel and long finish.

Very good now if giving it enough air but there is no doubt that it will age nicely for many more years. One of the best Huet I had up to now and still fair priced.
Red
3/1/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
91 points
Opened an hour before dinner but required more time in the glass to come together. Very nice nose with red berries and some funky notes in a perfect balance, on the palate it starts a bit thin but gets more depth with time in the glass, good freshness, smooth tannin, medium+ length.

Has improved a lot within the last two years and is most probably at peak now, drink within the next 2 to 4 years and give it enough air.
Spirits
2/28/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
Nice Armagnac nose, starts intense on the fruit and some spiciness, evolves in the glass with a warm profile of cinnamon and notes from the oak. On the palate slightly creamy but without any sweetness, intense, fresh and long. Quit complex for a 12 years old Armagnac and worth the money.
Red
2005 Château Monbrison Margaux Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
2/26/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
Cabernet Sauvignon (50%), Merlot (30%), Cabernet Franc (15%) and Petit Verdot (5%) fermented in stainless steel vats, ageing for 18 months in oak barrels (of which 40 to 60% are renewed each year). 13.5% vol.

Decanted an hour before dinner. Starts with sour cherry and a hint of ethereal, turns towards black currant and gets more and more dominated by tertiary notes (leather and underwood) with additional air. On the palate good freshness, dry and full bodied, long finish.

Classic Margaux and the best Monbrison vintage I have tasted up to date with a superb price to quality relation, drink now or within the next 6 to 12 years, depending on your preferences on mature wines.
White
2/24/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
91 points
VDP Erste Lage, 12.5% vol.

Opened an hour before dinner. Nice Riesling nose with apricot, lemon zest and a suggestion of petrol, on the palate high acidity, nearly dry, a saline touch, dense and a good length with a hint of a nice citric bitterness.

Already very good but still very youthful, good promise for the future, 91++.
Red
2/19/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
Decanted 90 minutes before dinner. Starts restrained and quite austere, needed another 90 minutes to get approachable. Showed dark berries, leather and balsamic notes, on the palate very dry and tight with high acidity, medium+ body and long slightly drying finish.

As often with Tondonia and Bosconia Reserva, I love them when released because of the pure fruit and the freshness, then 2 or 3 years later (as now) they get into a difficult phase and at the age of 16 to 20 years (depending on the vintage), when getting mature and more complex, they get incredibly good again. If drinking now, give it a decant of 3 to 5 hours but better wait a couple of years, it will reward your patience.
3 people found this helpful Comment
White
2015 Clos Floridene Blanc Graves Sémillon-Sauvignon Blanc Blend (view label images)
2/18/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
91 points
52% Sauvignon, 48% Sémillon, aged 9 months in oak barrels.

PnP on the first day and the rest two days later. I should have known better because of the previous tasting two years ago, this wine is not suitable for PnP, it requires a lot of air, so it was quite simple on the first day but 2 days later it was much better with more depth and freshness. On the nose gooseberry, lemon and an exotic touch, on the palate clean with good balance between the high acidity and the creaminess, not at all heavy though it has 14% vol., medium+ length.

Drink now or within the next 8 years and give it enough air, best after one to two hours in the decanter.
Red
2/17/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
89 points
Zweigelt, aged 8 month in new barriques, 14% vol.

PnP. On the nose red stone fruit, dark berries and very shy notes from the oak, on the palate dry with good structure, medium to full bodied and medium+ length with still some edges that ask for food. Surprisingly classic in style. Drink now to 2031.
White
2/17/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
87 points
Viognier fermented spontaneously, aged 6 months in amphora, 12% vol.

PnP. Starts quite shy with white stone fruit, floral and a green touch, on the palate clean, medium acidity, light to medium bodied and length.

A rather light Viognier without any over ripeness, what I usually appreciate but unfortunately also without the depth Viognier can have. Don't know why people get the idea to plant these French varieties in such a warm climate as there are so many Italian grape varieties that are much better adapted to this climate.
Red
2016 Ruffino Chianti Classico Riserva Ducale Chianti Classico DOCG Sangiovese Blend, Sangiovese (view label images)
2/16/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
89 points
Opened 5 hours before dinner. On the nose nice Sangiovese typicality with prune, dark berries (elderberry) and first shy tertiary notes, on the palate fresh and dry, a bit straight forward, medium+ bodied and long finish with still some edges.

Old school Riserva, a bit on the rustic side and best with food. In a good place now but with enough structure for 6 to 10 more years. Superb price to quality relation for 12 sFr/€.
White
2/13/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
100% Savagnin, oxidative treatment (sous voile), 14.5% vol. PnP and enjoyed it over a week.

Needs a bit of air to show its beauty. Starts with walnut and a touch of lemon, gets in addition the typical curry and lovage notes with time and air, on the palate quite creamy with high acidity, dense and very long. Already very good on the first day but even a tad better the next days (92+).

According to the warm vintage powerful and Vin Jaune like, drink within the next 2 decades.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
2/11/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
89 points
Primitivo aged 18 months in French and American oak barrels, 14.5% vol.

PnP. Still very primary with ripe dark fruit, quite jammy, the oak is well integrated, on the palate full bodied, medium acidity, smooth and with good length.

These bold wines are not my favourites but I have to agree that it was a good match with the Piccata Milanese. Still in a good place but it's better to wait not much longer with the last bottle.
Red
2/10/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
88 points
45% Syrah, 32% Merlot, 20% Petit Verdot and 3% Cabernet Sauvignon aged 16 months in French oak, 13.5% vol.

Shows a classic profile without any edges, Bordeaux like with a touch of Syrah, correctly made, but nothing remarkable, just another wine for the international market that could be produced anywhere. Drink within the next couple of years.
White
2/10/2024 - amateur62 Does not like this wine:
83 points
Disappointing, no Savagnin (Heida) typicality. I used to love the wines from Gillard, but since a few years they get more and more simple.
Red
2009 Château Citran Haut-Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
2/6/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
91 points
Blending according to the label 50% Cabernet Sauvignon and 50% Merlot (according to the technical sheet 42.5% Cabernet Sauvignon, 55% Merlot and 2.5% Cabernet Franc), aged 15 months in French oak barrels (35% new), fining with white egg, 13.5% vol.

Decanted an hour before dinner. Mature classic Médoc showing leather, underwood and black currant, good freshness, tannins still show their edges, medium+ bodied and long finish.

Not the most exciting wine but very solid and superb with cheese and bread and as always with a superb price to quality relation, drink within the next 4 to 6 years.
White
2/4/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
88 points
Good basic Albariño, light, fresh and mineral, the fruit is slightly restrained but still typical for the variety, medium length.
Red
2/3/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
89 points
PnP just after the Pommard Cru Clos de la Commaraine from Jadot. Starts quite linear and a bit simple, gets better with air, shows red stone fruit, leather and a suggestion of forest floor, on the palate fresh with some stemmy notes, medium+ finish. Hard to rate, on one hand it gives the impression that it needs some more years to gain in depth but on the other hand I'm afraid that the fruit will fade away with more cellar time.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
2/3/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
90 points
Needed about an hour in the decanter to open, showed then red stone fruits with earthy notes, good freshness, soft tannin, long finish. Good solid village level but would expect more from a premier cru, similar as the bottle 3 years ago but needed a bit more air, drink now or within the next 4 to 6 years.
White
2/3/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
91 points
Quite similar to the bottle 3 years ago, there's not much evolution since. Nice Riesling typicality with apricot and sweet flowers, on the palate rather creamy and quite sweet but in good balance with the high acidity, medium+ finish. Very good now, though not very complex yet, will hold for many more years and only improve with time, 91+.
White
2/2/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
91 points
Decanted 30 minutes before dinner but required even a bit longer to open. On the nose kumquat, sweet blossom and a mineral note, on the palate dry with good acidity, a bit creamy, a hint of bitterness that asks for food, long finish.

In a good spot now, but has enough structure for an additional 6 years.
Red
2004 Château Chasse-Spleen Moulis en Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
2/1/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
92 points
Cabernet Sauvignon 50%, Merlot 46% and Petit Verdot 4%. 13% vol. Perfect fill and cork.

Decanted half an hour before dinner and served it rather cool (~16°C). On the nose dark fruited, leather and a hint of forest floor, on the palate fresh and dry, good depth and long finish.

Classic old school Médoc, was perfect with cheese, dried sausages and bread. In a nice spot now, less mature and more elegant than the bottle I had two years ago, drink now or within the next ten years.
White
1/28/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
91 points
PnP. Starts a bit shy and requires 15 to 30 minutes to open. On the nose apples, quince and a touch of honey, on the palate quite lush now, medium acidity, good depth and long finish. Was very nice with food, got some bitterness with more air and when drinking it on its own.

A last glass on the next day was similar with an additional touch of white stone fruit and the bitterness was was gone.

Much better than two years ago and shows that it has still some good years ahead. Quite different to all Savagnin I have tasted up to now, reminds me a bit to the Rhone wines. Unfortunately my last bottle, would be interesting to see how it develops within the next couple of years.
White - Sparkling
1/27/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
89 points
Chardonnay, Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier, 12% vol.

Small but persistent bubbles, shows brioche, apples and a nutty touch, medium acidity, slightly creamy and medium length. Good basic Champagne, should be enjoyed within the next one or two years.
White
1/26/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
91 points
Natural farming, spontaneous fermentation and ageing on the lees, 11.5% vol.

Restaurant Le Vivant. PnP. Open from the start with green apples, citrus and a yeasty touch, dense with mouth watering acidity, good depth and persistence, 91+.

Shows nice Riesling typicality with unmistakable flavours from the natural wine treatment, in a good place now, drink within the next couple of years.
White
1/26/2024 - amateur62 Likes this wine:
91 points
Chardonnay from natural farming, aged on the lees and bottled unfiltered and without sulphite, 12% vol.

Restaurant Le Vivant. PnP, needs some minutes to open. On the nose it starts with ripe apples and yeasty notes, gets pears and a suggestion of petrol with more air, on the palate medium acidity, creamy and medium to long finish with a slightly tannic grip, somehow similar to a red wine.

Interesting wine, give it a bit air and don't cool to much, best at 14 to 16°C, drink within the next couple of years.
White
1/21/2024 - amateur62 wrote:
Carricante grown at 600 to 650 meters above sea level, fermented and aged in 10-hectolitre barrels. 13% vol.

The nose was very muted at opening so I decided to decant an hour before dinner that helped a lot. On the nose citrus flavours with a mixture of mineral notes and a touch of honey, on the palate dense, dry and fresh with a long, slightly bitter finish that asks for food.

Not easy to judge this wine, the nose improved a lot with air but on the palate the bitterness got stronger with air and time. It gives the impression of a great white that is somehow in a difficult in between phase, I will wait an additional 2 years for my next bottle before rating it again.
2 people found this helpful Comment
1 - 50 of 1,598
More results
  • Tasting Notes: 1,598 notes on 1,184 wines
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close