Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(22 comments on 20 notes)

1 - 20 of 20 Sort order
Red
2019 Thymiopoulos Terra Petra Rapsani Red Blend
10/31/2023 - SuperSomm wrote:
Medium ruby colour. Medium and developing nose with strawberry, raspberry, cedars leather, wet leaves, forest floor and violet. Medium (+) taste of strawberry cedar, leather, wet leaves and forest floor. Long and dry finish. High acidity. Medium tannins. Medium body. A very good Rapsani Red. Drink now or over the next eight years. Goes well with duck, mushroom, pork or veal.
  • plinymajor commented:

    4/23/24, 6:43 AM - Thanks for your note. This great wine is however not a Naoussa wine (where the producer is based), but from the appellation Rapsani, a 150 km more in the south in Thessaly, where xinomavro is blended with krassato and stavroto. It's a side project of Apostolos Thymiopoulos and I hope he'll keep making this wine.

Rosé
2021 Château de Manissy Tavel Tête de Cuvée Red Rhone Blend
3/26/2024 - chablis28 wrote:
89 points
I had higher hopes for this. I'll admit, I was swooned into buying one to try because of the cool old-style label but also because of Envoyer's tasting note for it. 100yr old vines was intriguing! As someone else noted it lacked some expected intensity and complexity. A very solid $10-$15 rose' I paid $26 for. If I had loved the wine, the btl might have made it on cool wine btl shelf:).
  • plinymajor commented:

    3/28/24, 4:11 AM - Thanks for your tasting note. It's a pity you're not fully convinced. Haven't opened one of my 6 2021's, but experience with de 2019 showed that they need a healthy amount of airing (open in the morning, drink in the evening) before they really open up.

White
2020 Caveau de Bacchus Melon à Queue Rouge Arbois Cuvée des Docteurs
Tast Vinica Lleida. Uva absolutamente desconocida. Estilo particular de los Jura. Diferente, salino, complejo. Con unos años mas seguramente estaria mejor.
  • plinymajor commented:

    2/16/24, 10:18 AM - Melon à queue rouge es un clono local do Chardonnay.

Rosé
2021 Château de Manissy Tavel Tête de Cuvée Red Rhone Blend
Dried cherries, orange peel, apples, airy herbs, a little meaty and spicy... savory and fresh at once, this is for food, i would say liberally herbed roast chicken.
  • plinymajor commented:

    9/24/23, 12:40 AM - Thanks for your review. Got 6 bottles of this vintage, but haven't tried it yet. Did you decant it? I've noticed that the 2019 vintage benefits a lot from a long decanting (=opening and decanting in the morning and drinking it in the evening). The initial reductive aromas disappear and all you get is glorious fruit...

Red
2019 Niepoort Conciso Dão Red Blend
9/5/2022 - FEDEVIDAL Likes this wine:
89 points
Se decantó durante el servicio, no previamente. Presenta un color fresa muy claro al borde y más oscuro al centro. Al principio el aroma es un efluvio de fresas, caramelo o jarabe de fresas, al cabo de un tiempo la intensidad disminuye y la fresa pasa a un segundo plano, ahora la intensidad es media y hay cerezas , grosellas rojas , casis, acompañadas con tierra negra, con toques de laurel y pimienta. La boca presenta un cuerpo medio ( aunque al principio parece tener poco cuerpo), taninos muy suaves y discretos, alta acidez, tono ligeramente dulzón, expresión muy frutal referido a fruta roja y fresca y final largo. Quizá una mayor guarda lo haga evolucionar favorablemente.

Se compone de la variedad Baga , tinta, que al parecer es autóctona de Portugal y Jaen , blanca, que podría ser lo que aquí llamamos Xarel.lo aunque no estoy seguro.

Un vino sorprendente y especial, que parece responder al principio de minina intervención, muy puro, fresco, natural, con mucho equilibrio, muy interesante en todo caso. En la mesa hubo opiniones muy contradictorias sobre este vino desde quién lo encontró un simple vino joven de diario, a quién lo consideró como extraordinario
  • plinymajor commented:

    6/28/23, 11:50 PM - Descripción muy interesante y reconocible; un vino sobre el que las opiniones están divididas. Para mi es extraordinario. Jaén no es una variedad blanca sino tinta y se llama Mencía en España.

White
2011 Domaine Rolet Côtes du Jura Vin Jaune Savagnin
6/2/2023 - RoelD Likes this wine:
94 points
A source of excellent Jura-wine this domain was recently taken over by a well known Burgundy house as is the case with several houses in the region (e.g. dom.Jacques Puffeney). Seductive golden yellow color, smashing nose with walnuts, curry,a not unpleasant touch of rancid butter :-) and all possible aldehydic tones of a vin jaune. On the palate bone-dry, similar to a classy fino-Sherry with just a little more body. Bracing acidity and a finish of almost 60 sec. Slightly less complex and rich than a recently drunk Jaune from Stéphane Tissot la Mailloche from the same vintage, but it is a close call.
  • plinymajor commented:

    6/4/23, 7:29 AM - Thanks for your note. Unless I’ve missed something very recently, I guess you are alluding to the takeover of domaine Rolet by Devillard in 2018. This family acquired Rolet together with two other French families, but since 2020 they’ve quit because of differing views with the two other families, one of which is a Parisian hotelier.

White
2020 Colli di Lapio Fiano di Avellino Fiano di Avellino DOCG
A salty minerality to it. To the nose. And vivid on the palate. Briny, and lively. Its the Greco. No wonder it tastes different.
  • plinymajor commented:

    12/11/21, 4:47 AM - What do you mean by 'its the Greco'? Did you taste the 2020 "Alexandros" Greco di Tufo or the regular Fiano di Avellino?

White
2017 Colli di Lapio Fiano di Avellino Fiano di Avellino DOCG
9/2/2019 - Erik R. wrote:
Lemon yellow. Shy lemon and almond and maybe some fennel. Grapefruit, and a sweet honey note. Young and round, low altitude and hence less smokey and structured than say a west side higher altitude like Ciro Picariello. Zesty acidity finish. plenty of fruit and acid to seemingly age well.
  • plinymajor commented:

    11/9/21, 7:41 AM - Interesting TN in which you link smokiness, structure and altitude. However, the altitude of these vines (550m) is in fact not really a lot lower than those of Ciro Picariello (600m). The clear difference in fruit, structure and smokiness between the Lapio zone and the Summonte zone is probably linked also to soil composition, orientation and maybe (as d’Agata suggests) to the presence of an unknown variety in some vineyards that is being erroneously labeled as Fiano. Fascinating region!

Red
2019 Yannick Amirault Bourgueil Le Grand Clos Cabernet Franc
1st of 6. Obviously very young at this stage. I opened it one day before consuming. Dark purple colour. Very pure and generous black/blue fruit (cassis, brambleberry, blackberry) in the nose, combined with some yoghurt and a vegetal streak. Mouth confirms this, ripe fruit but good freshness, a little vegetal, very tight and tannic, though enjoyable with food. Long long future ahead. I'm not opening the next bottle before 2025... At €15 very good qpr.
  • plinymajor commented:

    8/20/21, 2:33 AM - I bought it at Colruyt in Belgium. It's a big supermarket and they have a selection of premium wines that you won't find on the shelves but have to order and pick up at the local store.
    The €15 was a promotion, normal price was around €19 but it is now out of order. For this price, you can have at this moment a 2017 Couly-Dutheil Clos de l'echo...

Red
2016 Antonio Vallana e Figlio Boca Nebbiolo Blend, Nebbiolo
Far too young, for my tastes, anyway. That said, and as most would expect from Vallana, this is seriously well made. A compact medium body at the moment, though I'm confident it will fill out some as it ages. Woodsy, herbal, and more soil than fruit driven just now. A 2oz glass I left uncovered overnight showed a tinge of oxidation, but it also allowed some of the underlying red fruit to emerge - even if just a little. This will be much more enjoyable in 4+ years, which is how long I'll be holding my remaining four bottles before taking another peek. I'll have to ask Francis Fogarty next time I see him, why he chose to go with a DIAM5 closure (vs, at least DIAM10) as, to my palate, this has another decade ahead of it, at least. HOLD. 13,0% abv., 2025-2035. Based on my feeling of its apogee, it's highly recommended+

http://www.italianwine.blog
  • plinymajor commented:

    4/15/21, 11:03 AM - Thank you for this TN. It's been too long for me to pass by in Maggiora, but when I visited the winery last time in 2017, Marina Fogerty told me they chose for DIAM5 after experimenting with different DIAM types because with more dense corks, the wines evolve too slowly or don't evolve at all. It certainly had nothing to do with the price of a more dense cork, since that difference is minimal. I don't know how long a DIAM5 is able to keep the bottle closed but I'm testing this with my Gattinara '05 and '07, as well as with the Boca '10 which I was able to purchase back then. Greetings from Belgium.

Red
2015 Château Capbern St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
5/30/2020 - mukden wrote:
89 points
Candidate. But too hot but deep dark red; good bit of St Estephe tannins ; in time this could be quite good. Bit steep at 40 euro.
  • plinymajor commented:

    5/30/20, 11:39 PM - Restaurant price? For the moment, these 2015 Capberns are for sale at a Belgian retailer for only 16 euro.

Red
2015 Mastroberardino Taurasi Radici Taurasi DOCG Aglianico
5/29/2020 - pepmi wrote:
89 points
We've entered the sixteenth wine region on our north to south tour of the Italian wine regions. My family came from Campagnia to America in the wave of Italian immigrants in the 20th Century. Taurasi, meaning roots, reflects the beginnings of this wine as well as that of my family.

Deep purple Aglianico in the glass. A nose of chocolate, blackberry and plum. In the mouth, notes of cedar, licorice and anise. Aglicanico reminds me of Zinfandel in its sweet, rustic earthiness.

What this wine lacks in elegance it more than makes up for in its vitality. Appreciate for what it is rather than what it is not.
  • plinymajor commented:

    5/30/20, 11:37 PM - Thanks for your review. If you want elegance in a Taurasi, you just have to wait much longer. The 2015’s apparently are already broachable very young, but it isn’t unusual for a Mastroberardino Radici Taurasi to show its true elegant and aristocratic nature only after 10 years or more. These wines are made for decades of cellaring and some producers even wait 10 years or more before releasing a vintage.

Red
2010 Cantine Antonio Caggiano Taurasi Macchia dei Goti Taurasi DOCG Aglianico
3/15/2020 - Adam T 12 Likes this wine:
90 points
I would recommend holding this wine. It’s a bit disjointed right now, either I missed the drinking window or it hasn’t opened yet. I’m hoping it will be better in 2-3 years.
  • plinymajor commented:

    3/16/20, 1:40 AM - I experienced the same with my last bottle opened in january. It felt like drinking a classed growth way too early.
    One year before however, the wine was very open (see my TN), now I'd wait a couple of years.

White
2017 Aphros Vinho Verde Loureiro Branco
3/14/2020 - PT insurgent wrote:
Fairly oxidative style, ripe apple, ripe pear, bruised apple notes. Only 11.5% alcohol which is great, but acid isn't all that high which is interesting.
  • plinymajor commented:

    3/16/20, 1:31 AM - I think there must be some bottle variation or maybe a conservation issue.
    Having read your TN, I opened a totally different bottle yesterday evening. Everything in my glass was still fresh lime, unripe apple, green herbs and salinity. A little cidery touch maybe, but I would relate that to the biodynamic winemaking.
    The low-sulphite approach might also be the reason of the oxidation you describe?
    I had some serious bottle variation myself with the loureiro espumante reserva from this wine maker...

Red
2015 Kir-Yianni Xinomavro Ramnista Naoussa
2/15/2020 - RussK wrote:
91 points
Russk. This was my favorite Xinomarvo from the Westside whiners nebbiolo tasting. Very well behaved. On day 3, femine, with a nice citrusly cut to it. Medium bodied. Just bought 3 more.
  • plinymajor commented:

    2/16/20, 2:25 AM - Curious about how it compared with nebbiolo. Did you taste it blind? Any characteristics that stood out?

  • plinymajor commented:

    2/16/20, 1:32 PM - Thanks for the update. Glad I still have 5 bottles and loads of time...

Red
2010 Produttori del Barbaresco Barbaresco Nebbiolo
12/5/2019 - fitzi wrote:
Out of the bottle, lean and mean; nothing there but a thin curtain of drying tannins. A day later, the beginnings of fruit flavors & aromas on the mid-palate - tar, licorice ... the usual suspects - and a soupçon of finish; everything still rather thin and delicate for the appellation. If this wine continues to develop, it could offer a quite attractive bottle in a few years; if not, it's kind of a yawn. I lack the experience with Nebbiolo varietals to express an opinion about where it's heading.

Better with food than alone - no surprise there.
  • plinymajor commented:

    12/5/19, 7:43 AM - In my experience, there is some bottle variation. Had the 10 as WOTN in a verticale in november 2018 from 10 to 15, and two months later another bottle like the one you describe...

Red
2010 Antonio Vallana e Figlio Boca Nebbiolo Blend, Nebbiolo
Think Benny-G's was a bad bottle. This is sweet ripe fruit surrounded by pretty, grainy tannin. Rose, just-cooked cranberry, and blood orange. Think this'll age for at least five more years. Really good.
  • plinymajor commented:

    2/22/19, 11:35 PM - I think you shouldn’t underestimate how many time and air this wine needs to reveal its fruit. I’ve noticed that it only starts to shine after 24h of airing.

Red
2013 Antonio Vallana e Figlio Spanna Colline Novaresi Nebbiolo
P&p. Flowers, sour cherry, bread crust. Plenty of tart acidity. Tannins are noticeably grippy but certainly manageable. Texture is on the watery side. All about traditional character/typicity. Fairly straightforward, enjoyable for what it is. The floral notes are nice and expressive, gaining in depth and pungency over the course of a few hours.

Closure note: Diam 5 cork, somewhat surprising as I thought this wine could be cellared for a long time (update: some perspectives on this in the comments).
  • plinymajor commented:

    2/8/18, 10:56 PM - Thanks for the tasting note. Concerning your note on the cork: I was at the Vallana winery one year ago and Marina told me they experimented with both the Diam 5 and Diam 10 and concluded the 10 was too tight and didn’t let the wines evolve enough. Vallana also use Diam 5 for their Gattinara and Boca, which are supposed to have a cellaring potential of decades. In a 2012 Molettieri Cinque Querce Irpinia Aglianico (the second wine after a Taurasi, a bit like this Spanna after a Gattinara) I’ve found the Diam 10 to result in a very young, acidic and tannic wine after 5 years. Of course that is not unusual for aglianico, but in comparison with other ‘12 aglianico wines from with a regular cork, it was exceptionally young and harsh. I guess the 10 in Diam 10 means: do not touch during the first 10 years...

  • plinymajor commented:

    2/9/18, 8:54 AM - Well, for all the experience I’ve had with Diam, opening a bottle with Diam 5 is never a disappointment. The wines that are closed with a five are generally from houses I trust for delivering good quality at fair price: Etna Terre Nere, JC Boisset, Rabasse Charavin, Vallana... Marina also told me that the price difference between Diam 5 and 10 is minimal, so it’s not really a budget choice. And there’s still Diam 3 and Diam 1 too for wines that ought to be drunk in short term.

Red
2012 Produttori del Barbaresco Barbaresco Nebbiolo
9/26/2017 - Motz wrote:
94 points
Dark in color, surprisingly so for Nebbiolo. Heady bouquet of naturally ripened fruits and berries, along with orange zest, muddled flower petals, potpourri, spices, and minerals. Strikingly dense attack, in every good way, featuring superb satin texture. The middle graces every part of the palate before profound tannins clamp down at the back. The gritty finish evokes the color crimson for a long, lingering while. The highest quality Barbaresco from the vintage that I recall tasting, and, the same producer's cru bottlings excepted, better than any 2011 too.

Why did Produttori del Barbaresco declassify their cru fruit in 2012? Who knows!? Thankfully, we have the distinct pleasure of benefitting from it. Likely to last for another two decades. 94-95.

Post Script:

I know the reasons given for declassifying the crus in this vintage, and in 2010, decisions for which I am deeply grateful. And, of course, I hope that Produttori declassifies forthcoming vintages. This aside, I have a few thoughts as to these declassifications.

I have tasted several underwhelming crus in recent vintages, one or two even nondescript. The somewhat angular 2008 Muncagota and Pora bottlings, for example, leave much to be desired, whereas the same vintage Montestefano shows like a Tuscan Sangiovese-Merlot blend. In 2009, the Pora came off as fairly straightforward (simple), and the Ovello showed like high quality Barbera, or slightly wonky Barolo. It seems that a house that boasts as many crus, and sources as much fruit from them, as PdB does, and that does not hesitate to declassify, would want to avoid producing cru bottlings like these.

Also, it seems that PdB declassified in the more moderate climate vintages and bottled the crus in hotter vintages, which might be interpreted as a marketing ploy for New World consumers, as hotter vintages typically show more fruit.

Again, only speculations, and certainly not complaints, as the 2010 and 2012 vintages rank very high in quality at very affordable prices.
  • plinymajor commented:

    9/27/17, 5:59 AM - Nice tasting note. Concerning your speculation about the cru bottling: if the PdB only bottle their crus in hotter vintages because of marketing reasons, what about their decision to bottle them in 2013 and 2014, both colder and/or rather rainy vintages?

White
2010 Jean-Claude Boisset Marsannay Blanc Chardonnay
1/31/2016 - plinymajor Likes this wine:
90 points
Fresh and deep lemon, buttery, yeast flavors and minerality. All you want from a nice bottle of white Burgundy. Stil going strong, this 2010.
  • plinymajor commented:

    3/4/16, 12:09 AM - That sounds bizarre indeed. It was the ninth bottle of 12. Initially the wine was very closed and oaky. After two or three years, dominant taste of citrus and sour citrus candies. Now very balanced, but I don't think it will improve so I'm opening the last ones next week for dinner with cod, sauteed Jerusalem artichokes and mushrooms.

1 - 20 of 20
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close