2/20/24, 6:50 PM - Thanks for a contemporary, informative review. I'm appreciate that you mentioned your mood, as I believe that mood affects body chemistry and perception, which affects how you appreciate the wine. If you had a shitty day, and are writing e-mails at 9 o'clock at night, and this is still a great wine, that really says something.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
1/16/24, 4:48 AM - Ready to go? More time?Drink lots of wine!Magnum PI
1/14/24, 10:18 PM - I have to say, your score and your notes were way off. I respect your experience, but completely different from what I got. Maybe try another bottle.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
1/13/24, 5:46 AM - Good morning. Nobody seems to score this wine very high except the pros. Any thoughts on that? I tend to drink nicer Bordeaux 10+ years of age. Nobody seems very optimistic that the reward will justify the wait.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
12/17/23, 8:27 PM - Wait . . . you drank this at a campsite? Boy Scouts has sure changed!
12/10/23, 5:36 PM - Perhaps this wine is still a bit disjointed?
11/23/23, 5:27 PM - This is a great bottle. I just drank one a couple of nights ago. I was shocked at how strong it was, and the complexity after a couple of hours. I would put this up with my great wine buys of all time.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
9/27/23, 6:07 PM - Where did you get this for $7?
9/27/23, 6:05 PM - Thanks for the insightful review. I am enjoying one of the last ‘15’s in my cellar. Opening up nicely into a classic, affordable, Bordeaux.
6/24/23, 6:47 AM - The wine was in a decanter for an hour, and we drank it over the following hour. Brookie was born in 1990, so every year we have a bottle from that vintage. In my opinion, the Cheval Blanc was not as good as the Lafite, but Brookie felt just the opposite. I suppose there could be some bottle variation. I have had Cheval Blanc from numerous vintages, and to me, this underperformed. I am sure others would disagree.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
6/18/23, 7:35 AM - Thanks for an outstanding review. Perhaps best I've read. Lafite is my favorite wine, and I admit to having been lured into opening a bottle or two early. The problem with being born in 1966 is that although I can afford Lafite, I have to start doing math, which is an uncomfortable prospect at best. I'm still waiting for the 00's to come around. Keep the reviews coming!
5/21/23, 8:31 AM - Interesting note. I have had the '15, and thought it was okay for the money. Do think there is any chance the bottle might improve since you tasted it in '21?Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
5/7/23, 8:33 PM - Great insights, and I love your nick! I have found that with some producers, the '08 (in SR) can outshine the '07, as odd as that sounds.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
5/6/23, 9:04 PM - I have a bottle that I just found in my cellar. After reading your review I am going to grad the corkscrew and drink it in the dark! I feel that grenache based wines have a tendency to drop off very quickly sometimes compared to other varietals.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
5/6/23, 8:48 PM - Where is this in it's drinking window?Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
4/30/23, 7:34 PM - Correct on all accounts! Excellent QPR. I drink of lot of this label and it seldom disappoints. Could be mistaken for a village level wine . . . Rasteau or Lirac perhaps. A lot of wine in this humble bottle.Drink lots of wine!Magnum PI
4/30/23, 7:29 PM - Here here! This is one of my favorite SR labels. Very good QPR.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
4/27/23, 10:34 PM - I read into your review that a few (5-7) more years would help.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
4/23/23, 7:31 PM - Excellent analysis. Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
4/2/23, 9:54 PM - Time will indeed tell. 30 years? I am still waiting on my 2000's.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
3/20/23, 6:04 PM - What was the decant and what was the evolution of the wine over time?Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
3/10/23, 9:28 PM - So, you think you will like it better in 10 years? Hasn't truly started opening yet?Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
2/26/23, 9:57 PM - Just drank a Jadot '90, which was declining, but once open was still very good. You may be correct on your projected window.
2/26/23, 9:55 PM - Great review. For what it's worth, a few weeks ago I had a Jadot '90 that was on the downhill but still very enjoyable.
2/25/23, 8:33 PM - I enjoyed reading your review, as I thought it clarified my thoughts. Dark fruit, bitter chocolate, sour cherry. I hadn't thought of medicinal, but once I read your review, I agreed. A bit alcoholic I thought. I agree with the port like structure.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
2/9/23, 5:19 AM - Thanks for the great review. A lot more time . . . 5 years? 10 years? Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
2/9/23, 3:41 PM - So, you think wait another 20 years if I (or my heirs) want the optimum drinking window?
2/9/23, 4:53 AM - Thanks very much for the excellent review. Is there a link we can access?Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
2/3/23, 9:07 PM - Time will indeed tell. The only way to know is to know.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
2/1/23, 8:54 PM - Very accurate
1/26/23, 4:18 AM - Thanks for your review. I have two bottles, and very little experience with high end Burgundy, and Clos de la Roche specifically. Did you decant this wine? Did it seem to open during the evening? Were you able to have more than one glass? I'm curious as to what you assess the drinking window to be? Thanks for your thoughts.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
1/24/23, 5:58 PM - 20 more years? Have you had the wine since your note in 2017? Still of the same opinion?Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
1/18/23, 8:04 PM - Thanks for your note. I just picked up the '18 today. 40 year wine, eh? Not too shabby for $90.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
1/2/23, 8:34 AM - Great note. If you want another glass and are in Nebraska, stop by!Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
1/2/23, 7:54 AM - Great review. Thanks for the detail. The information regarding the development of the wine over days makes it a TINY bit easier to keep my hands off my bottles!Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
12/13/22, 8:48 PM - After reading your review, I can't decide which I want more: a 35 year old Harvard MBA or a bottle of Haut Brion! I think I'll try for both!Drink lots of wine. Magnum PI
12/10/22, 7:47 AM - Thanks very much for the info. Ideal drinking window?Magnum PI
12/11/22, 3:28 PM - Thanks for your response. I have never heard of your wine, but I am going to pick up a few bottles.Magnum PI
12/11/22, 9:43 AM - I drank this bottle in 2019 and didn't care for it at all. Opened a second bottle last night with Indian food and was blown away. Very similar analysis to yours. I thought it was the most herbaceous CDP I have had. Didn't show much with my initial glass right out of the bottle, but with 20 minutes in the decanter it had opened into an amazing wine. Excellent balance, complexity, finish. Very classy.
12/7/22, 5:45 AM - Still quite young? Needs another 3 years?
12/9/22, 6:56 AM - Thanks for your response. I have to admire a bottle at this price point with such a long evolutionary window. I may pick up a case. Best wishes to you for the holidays.Drink lots of wine!Magnum PI
11/25/22, 9:49 AM - You are very correct with your analysis and notes. I enjoyed this bottle undecanted yesterday, Thanksgiving, with my loving family and a traditional meal. I thought it was really outstanding. More time required? According to "the experts". I have more, so we shall see. If this bottle gets better, I will regret not buying more for $14!Drink lots of wine!Magnum PI
11/19/22, 7:29 PM - Completely agree. Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
11/21/22, 3:42 AM - Indeed
11/14/22, 3:52 AM - Just drank this bottle last night undecanted. A pleasant surprise. I kind of wish I had opened a bottle earlier to experience it in its youth. Still very enjoyable. Opened quite a bit with air and showed better than expected complexity.
11/11/22, 9:02 AM - Wow! What a great review! I drink a lot of CDP, and this bottle has been on my radar for a while. My favorite CDP ever is the '07 Deus Ex Machina. We shall see how this compares.Drink lots of wine!Magnum PI
11/10/22, 4:56 AM - How were the bottles from the 80's? The very first bottle that got me into French wine was the'89 Beaucastel, which was WS wine of the year.
11/10/22, 4:55 AM - Sounds like it's time to pop a cork! Thanks for a great review! Drink lots of wine!Magnum PI
11/7/22, 6:45 PM - Appreciate the lead up to the tasting . . . adds context . . . I have had the '05 and '07, and as an avid SR drinker, I think this is one of the very best. Looking forward to trying the '16 in 7-10 years.Drink lots of wine.Magnum PI
10/18/22, 10:01 AM - Any thoughts on when this bottle may hit it's prime drinking window?
10/18/22, 10:00 AM - Any thoughts on when it will hit it's prime window?
10/17/22, 4:57 AM - So, perhaps sit on my bottles for . . . . 3 - 5 years?
10/4/22, 4:59 AM - Just read your note before writing mine on the '12 which I had last night, decanted, with Indian food. I was disappointed also, but my take was different. Musty nose initially, then dissipated, then came back when I re-filled my glass, numerous notes, most prominently sour cherry, way too sour, brine/olive, earth, not harmonious at all, not much of a persistent finish. Overall, not very pleasing. I thought maybe it was too young and needed more time. But, maybe I waited too long and this either is coming undone or never had it in the first place.Drink lots of wine!Magnum PI
10/4/22, 4:55 AM - Just read your note before writing mine on the '12 which I had last night, decanted, with Indian food. I was disappointed also, but my take was different. Musty nose initially, then dissipated, then came back when I re-filled my glass, numerous notes, most prominently sour cherry, way too sour, brine/olive, earth, not harmonious at all, not much of a persistent finish. Overall, not very pleasing. I thought maybe it was too young and needed more time. But, maybe I waited too long and this either is coming undone or never had it in the first place.Drink lots of wine!Magnum PI
10/4/22, 4:58 AM - Just read your note before writing mine on the '12 which I had last night, decanted, with Indian food. I was disappointed also, but my take was different. Musty nose initially, then dissipated, then came back when I re-filled my glass, numerous notes, most prominently sour cherry, way too sour, brine/olive, earth, not harmonious at all, not much of a persistent finish. Overall, not very pleasing. I thought maybe it was too young and needed more time. But, maybe I waited too long and this either is coming undone or never had it in the first place.Drink lots of wine!Magnum PI
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search