Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(25 comments on 18 notes)

1 - 18 of 18 Sort order
Red
1998 Penfolds Grange South Australia Shiraz Blend, Syrah
2/1/2024 - Nontaco Likes this wine:
93 points
Just a splash decant, so maybe it needs serious time in decanter and/or more age….but that said, I expected a helluva lot more (especially since I have a case). It’s dark, brooding, has that deep, sultry Syrah profile but lacking depth, burst of flavor, complexity. It somehow compares more with a Clape Cornas or an aged Tempier, but at same time lacking the profound character and ties to the land I taste (or imagine) when I drink those. Hoping this ages into something a bit different and more attractive.
  • sthugo commented:

    2/1/24, 11:08 PM - Nontaco thanks for your tasting note much appreciated. With much experience with Grange this vintage is still considered a youngster and needs more time to develop. But if you want to drink a "young" Grange then I suggest at least 8 hours decant beforehand. Hope the rest of the case shows better.

Red
1998 Seppelt Shiraz St Peters Great Western
8/19/2022 - chatters wrote:
Festival of Phil (Phil's place, Putney, Sydney): From Coravin. Meaty, savoury, slightly sour smelling red over black fruits, a little pepper and leather. Fruit is almost a little jubey on the palate, black hued with chalky, drying, grainy tannins, then swing by but the fruit, assisted by the alcohol, persists and carries long. Nice.
  • sthugo commented:

    8/25/22, 2:39 AM - Hey mate enjoyed your notes. I'm at Putney as well so if you have a spare space next time at Phil's ... more than happy to bring a couple of bottles from the cellar to add to the next tasting.

  • sthugo commented:

    12/7/22, 12:02 PM - Hey Phil thanks for reaching out. Dropped you an email hope you received it?

White
2017 Grosset Riesling Polish Hill Clare Valley
2/22/2018 - chatters wrote:
Acid haus (Stanley Street Gallery, Sydney): Green apple more than citrus, mineral, floral top notes. Juicy, tangy, spicy, savoury minerals, fruit is a little muted against this but still holds it's own. Kind of nice
  • sthugo commented:

    3/5/18, 11:46 PM - Mate thanks for the tasting note. Bought a case of this on release and still haven't tasted it. Glad to hear you think it is ok!

Red
2016 Chatto Wines Pinot Noir Huon Valley White Label Southern Tasmania
11/23/2017 - chatters wrote:
Spicy, red cherry and berry. Quite rich on the palate, some mid-palate burr but also a little alcohol warmth. Also a touch of slightly sour acidity to clean things up a little.
  • sthugo commented:

    11/24/17, 11:57 PM - Mate thanks for your tasting note. Although can't tell if you liked it or not? From your previous notes I think we have a similar palate and I bought a six-pack of this plus the Isle so am very interested if your liked/disliked. Haven't tasted myself as am holding more for long term drinking so would be interested in how you think this will be in 5/10 years??

  • sthugo commented:

    12/2/17, 12:16 PM - Thanks mate ... time will tell I suppose! Fortunately I am in no hurry. On the Lafon, planning to do a mini vertical (3 vintages) with some friends over the holidays so looking forward to that. Will let you know how we go.

  • sthugo commented:

    12/8/17, 12:35 AM - Mate you are more than welcome but we had planned the tasting to be up in Brisbane. If you are up there early January let me know! BTW enjoyed your Hunter write up ... like you ... enjoy the Mt Pleasant wines. I haven't been to Brokenwood for years but based on your reviews might check it out next time. Although on weekends, getting in the door is a bit of an issue!

Red
1998 Château Lafon-Rochet St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
10/13/2017 - chatters wrote:
The Grand Tour - day twelve (Bordeaux): Decanted. Farmyard, leather, leather, crushed rock, black currant, spice, tobacco on the nose. Soft, sweet black fruit then fine, soft slightly floury tannins. There is some leather as well but this is surprisingly youthful. Yum..
  • sthugo commented:

    11/3/17, 1:28 PM - Hey mate have a few of these in the cellar. Good to hear you enjoyed the bottle!! You mention surprisingly youthful. Do you have any thoughts on will it improve with more bottle age, and a future drinking window? Notice CT has 2016 as the latest it should be drunk!

    Thanks
    Andrew

Red
2009 Château Sénéjac Haut-Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend
1/26/2017 - chatters wrote:
Coravin fun - Senejac mini-vertical (Kennards, Waterloo): From Coravin. Lovely ripe blackcurrant with the beginnings of some leather but also some almost confected cherry notes here as well. Touches of dusty spice. More fleshy than juicy with black tea notes joining the blackcurrant fruit and surprisingly fine grained tannins. Little alcohol warmth on the finish as well but not too obtrusive. Yum.
  • sthugo commented:

    2/3/17, 11:28 PM - Thanks for the notes mate ... have the 2009, 10 and 11 in the cellar. Agree with you, love this label and also Lafon Rochet from Bordeaux ... my two favourite bargains from the region. I pick this up regularly from Costco so you can try there if you need to find the current release.

White
2016 Seppelt Riesling Drumborg Vineyard Henty
11/21/2016 - CamWheeler wrote:
92 points
TWE 2016 Expo: Floral, pencil, crisp green apples. Pure on the palate, very clean and precise. Has spark and plenty of brightness about it. Excellent and should have a long life ahead.
  • sthugo commented:

    12/17/16, 11:37 PM - Agree with your note. I really like this as well. Birth year wine for our daughter which meant I HAD to buy a case!

Red
2009 Château Lafon-Rochet St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
9/23/2016 - chatters wrote:
Planet of the Grapes (Planet of the Grapes, Bow Lane): Vinfaticide. Double decanted for about 2 hours. After another hour just began to blossom from brooding, bruising beast to beautiful black currant cored fruit bomb with polished oak. Impressive length and intensity. Very nice.
  • sthugo commented:

    10/10/16, 8:46 PM - Thanks for the notes. Loved Planet of the Grapes while we were living in London. In fact had my leaving drinks here. Nice collection of wines to choose with only the 10 quid corkage. Need something like it in Sydney!

  • sthugo commented:

    10/12/16, 3:31 PM - Yes had some very nice experiences with the guys from POTG. They also have a wine shop around Holborn which I used to frequent when living in London. One day I walked in and they instantly gave me a glass of red to guess. It was a 1989 Mouton Rothschild from Magnum. Now how many wine stores/bars in Sydney would that happen at?!? In regards to Coravin, I worked for a restaurant group in London and we had Coravin at a few of them ... remember having a meeting with one of the restaurant managers and we had a glass of 1996 Lynch-Bages and a 2001 d'Yquem over lunch. Hard life!

Red
2013 St Hugo Cabernet Sauvignon Coonawarra
7/23/2016 - alohashirt wrote:
87 points
The big red fruit nose makes promises that aren't delivered on the palate. This is very tight, minty, with a bitter cherry taste reminiscent of some italian reds. I was disappointed by this but I don't think that it's a bad wine - more that it's too young and I have an aversion to bitter young wines.

This isnt a heavy red but it does have a long finish. I'm confident that there are many palates that will enjoy this much more than I did.

If I see a ten year old bottle, I'll buy it.
  • sthugo commented:

    7/25/16, 9:17 PM - Alohashirt,

    Thanks for your tasting note. Totally agree with your views at this point in time. As you can probably tell by my User ID, I am a big fan of this wine and it needs at least 10 years before it begins to shine. I am currently drinking the 1994 vintage which has peaked and drinking beautifully. Hope you can find an older bottle!

    Regards
    Andrew

White
2005 Kanta Riesling Balhannah Vineyard Adelaide Hills
9/15/2015 - CamWheeler wrote:
90 points
Negociants Australia Portfolio Tasting: Lime, kerosene and floral notes. Developing nicely, there is a toasty element to it and good length. I think this is a good checkpoint for this wine, though I think another 5 years wouldn't hurt it badly.
  • sthugo commented:

    5/28/16, 3:30 PM - Cam thanks for the note. In regards to your last sentence, did you mean "wouldn't" hurt it badly ... or do I need to drink these in the short-term?

Red
1998 Penfolds Grange South Australia Shiraz Blend, Syrah
1/31/2016 - Altiplano Likes this wine:
97 points
Best of the best. May be nearing the end of its good drinking life. This bottle was shared with three fronds. Loved by all.
  • sthugo commented:

    1/31/16, 11:53 PM - Thanks for your note and glad you enjoyed the wine. However, I think this wine will only be entering it's prime drinking window come 2030. We had a bottle of the 1966 Grange a few years ago and it still had plenty of life in it ... and the 1998 is definitely a step up from this wine.

Red
2013 Mount Pleasant Wines Shiraz 1880 Vines Old Hill Vineyard Pokolbin
5/31/2015 - CamWheeler wrote:
94 points
Hunter Valley Roadtrip 2015: Licorice, earth, floral notes, blackberry and meat. Fantastic balance, the fine tannins provide excellent structure with the fruit power restrained and focused around that core. Should shine with enough time.
  • sthugo commented:

    1/26/16, 1:56 AM - Cam,

    I to thought this was a pretty good wine even though not from the acclaimed 2014 vintage. Love your notes. Thanks for sharing.

    Regards
    Andrew

  • sthugo commented:

    1/26/16, 2:04 AM - Love what McWilliams's are currently doing ... following in the footsteps of O'Shea and letting the individual vineyards speak for themselves. Some fantastic single vineyard releases to look forward too!

Red
2010 St Hugo Cabernet Sauvignon Coonawarra
7/11/2015 - Kenneth Long wrote:
75 points
Easy to drink ...... But it does not have the characteristic of a full body red wine . Not sure it can be cellared.
  • sthugo commented:

    7/12/15, 12:36 AM - St Hugo shows best at least after 10 years bottle age so I think you may have drunk it to early. Not trying mine until 2020.

Red
2010 Château Lafon-Rochet St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
6/6/2015 - chatters wrote:
Ultimo lunch time tasting (Ultimo wine centre (but now vintage cellars)): Blackcurrant and a slightly inky quality along with crushed rocks, cedar and slight brambles. In the mouth there is dense black fruit then firm drying but fine textured tannins. Long. Very long in fact. Oh, this is rather nice. Lovely in fact.
  • sthugo commented:

    6/15/15, 2:19 AM - Thanks for your note. Have an unopened 6 pack of this wine. How long would you recommend before I break it open?

    Thanks
    Andrew

  • sthugo commented:

    6/15/15, 11:37 PM - Thanks mate. I will make sure I lose them in the cellar for a few years.

Red
1998 Wynns Coonawarra Estate Cabernet Sauvignon John Riddoch
10/10/2014 - chatters wrote:
Lamb for supper and my hands fell on this in my drinking fridge. Double decanted then left for a brief half hour (I figure it's fully mature so won't need much more than that). On the nose there are aromas of biscuit, leather, very slight brambley fruit, gamey meat, slight oxidation and a certain sourness/volatile acidity note. On the palate the wine is dry with a certain juiciness, the initial impression in the mouth is of slight oxidation then muted sour fruits, spice, drying leather rolls into a furry tannic grip which is joined by some alcohol warmth. The tannin persists on the gums. Hmm. I'm happy this is the last bottle - a touch over the hill for me but still obviously a good quality wine.
  • sthugo commented:

    10/10/14, 4:38 PM - Mate, interesting to read you tasting notes for this wine. Thanks for sharing. Do you think this wine is past it's best or do you think your bottles may have been heat effected? Just asking as the CT drinking window suggests best before 2017. However, reading your notes I m thinking I should pop one to see how mine are tracking. Grateful for any feedback. Andrew

  • sthugo commented:

    10/11/14, 7:58 PM - Thanks. You have convinced me to open one in the near future. Will let you know how it shows.

Red
2010 Penfolds Bin 389 South Australia Cabernet-Shiraz Blend, Red Blend
7/22/2014 - UofM Likes this wine:
91 points
3 hour decant. Wonderful nose; picking up leather, spice and mineral notes. Went well with ribeye steaks. Nice dark fruits and some lead pencil. Not much heat to speak of. My only complaint is that after the first glass I noticed it began to fall apart a bit. Will let the other bottles sit for a another year.
  • sthugo commented:

    7/22/14, 10:52 PM - Thanks for the tasting note. Not sure if your bottle was cork or screw cap? This is a long term wine which should last for +15 years with ease ... under screw cap ... but variable under cork!

Red
2006 Hobbs Shiraz Barossa Range
3/18/2011 - markellen.foodies@gmail.com wrote:
92 points
Had purchased from W Wine Boutique thinking it the Amarone styled Gregor, based on the blurb. It wasn't. Still marked down from $130 to $50. Good $50 Aussie Shiraz with a slight green note. Not = to the best Barossa Shiraz. I would like to try the Gregor, however am leery of Paul Hobbs global winemaking!
  • sthugo commented:

    7/7/14, 10:26 PM - This wine is not related to Paul Hobbs in anyway.

Red
2010 Penfolds Bin 389 South Australia Cabernet-Shiraz Blend, Red Blend
5/8/2014 - JDani Likes this wine:
92 points
Decanted 2 hours prior to consuming. Black fruit, mint, and lots of sage. The finish was medium to long. This would go well with smoked ribs or spicy barbecue. Potential for higher score, but will wait 5 years to open another bottle.
  • sthugo commented:

    5/8/14, 9:06 PM - Not sure how many bottles you have of this but I would wait at least 10 years before you open up another one. However, if you have plenty then fire away :)

1 - 18 of 18
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close