2/19/24, 8:52 PM - Outstanding note that perfectly describes this wonderful and idiosyncratic wine.
11/12/23, 6:35 AM - I can see that I caused some confusion! I meant that this Zin blend tasted to me like a Bedrock Syrah. I love Bedrock Syrahs, and this wine struck me as being in that style. Here, I could have come up with a better description, but was tasting a number of wines and jotted down my impressions quickly.
11/11/23, 2:17 PM - I felt exactly the same!
8/22/23, 5:19 PM - Thank you for the outstanding review. If this were available in the US I would buy it.
5/23/23, 2:39 PM - I agree with both of you! These are exceptional wines.
5/23/23, 12:42 PM - I appreciate your review. Maybe I underrated it at 93, but I try to temper my exuberance for older Zinfandel that's this great.
9/10/16, 3:30 PM - Mezzomorto nailed it on the description
3/16/23, 4:18 PM - Sadly, they have not had a bottling line this one. The producer is known for reasonable pricing, decent quality, and large volume. In my opinion, under those circumstances, a truly great bottling line this one is a rarity. If you hear otherwise, I’d love to know!
3/17/23, 8:49 AM - Thank you ! I haven’t looked in some time. I will try to find it and will comment if I get to try it.
2/21/23, 7:00 AM - Excellent note. So informative. Thank you !
12/2/22, 4:57 PM - Loved your tasting note!
10/20/22, 11:48 AM - Excellent post, and I wholeheartedly agree with you on Oreno.
10/18/22, 5:10 PM - Outstanding note! Thank you
8/7/22, 8:27 AM - I read about Montefalco and was exploring what’s available now, and of course, came across this tasting note. Thank you for sharing all your perceptions on the many wines you taste
5/18/22, 3:52 PM - I couldn't agree more about how Caymus declined after it became mass-produced. Found one bottle of this in my cellar, and while I'm happy that I have this surprise, it's a real shame I cannot buy Caymus anymore.
3/22/22, 1:38 PM - Thank you for detailed tasting notes in the story link!
3/20/22, 2:16 PM - I loved the thoughtful review but the aside was just wonderful. Thank you for sharing!
2/12/22, 10:15 AM - I greatly enjoyed your detailed tasting note. Your comments about the sensory experience resonate with how I experience wine.
2/10/22, 10:52 AM - Very helpful. I will open one soon and provide a note.
2/6/22, 9:01 AM - Thank you for the detailed review. None of the reviews here seem to be in accord with the Jeb Dunnick 94 rating, in which he compared this not an Aubert Chard.
2/2/22, 8:15 PM - Missed BotB this year so I appreciate the note.
2/6/22, 8:16 AM - That's very kind of you! My wife dislikes Spanish wines despite my best efforts to persuade her otherwise, so I buy very few, though I'm interested in a new local vendor. I buy almost entirely from Andy (he's awesome) and two terrific vendors in NY. These days I buy mostly Italian, Bordeaux, some Napa and Washington cabs, and way too many Zins/Syrahs/Petites from Bedrock/Carlisle/Turley/Ridge. I recall you too are a gentleman farmer, and I hope you are enjoying our easiest growing season. I've got lettuces, kales, collards, pak chois, and lots of different herbs going. Just completed a bumper star fruit crop, and I'm hoping for a decent showing from my finicky mango trees. It would be nice to meet up in person sometime, perhaps at a WW event. I'll add you as friend here and post a message next time we plan on attending a tasting. Feel free to do the same, or you can reach me at btrushin@ctllp.com. Cheers!
1/22/22, 7:16 PM - The 81 rating is a typo, right?
1/11/22, 1:30 PM - Please give this wine some more time before you try it again, at least a year and better a year and a half or two years. Or give it a decant and then wait for several hours. And finally, the serving temperature of Brunellos is so important. I like to pour them basically just above “cellar temperature” and it’s so enjoyable to see how the wine evolves in the glass as it warms up a bit. Cheers!
1/3/22, 8:32 PM - I just sent my 2018’s into storage, and saw your honest and very insightful review. I’d love to read your thoughts next time you taste this wine.
12/29/21, 1:41 PM - Duplicate entry
12/22/21, 12:16 PM - Good point. Given the very high quality level of every wine released by Carlisle, I assumed this was an off bottle. It didn’t taste tainted but I’m no taintspert so anything is possible.
12/14/21, 7:53 PM - Best damn tasting note! Very descriptive and accurate. I’m one of those fans and your note is dead on. And very funny.
8/30/21, 8:54 PM - Score makes no sense in the context of the review, at least on Cellar Tracker. Seems as though this person actually liked the wine, but such a slow score in 2021 when most modern wines are well made just doesn’t seem right to me personally. So I view it as an outlier. A shame because the reviewer’s opinion matters just as much mine.
3/29/21, 11:23 AM - This review is spot on
1/12/21, 2:29 PM - ChrisR, thank you for the very interesting information! I generally view old world wines as being capable of aging over ten years and the best ones don’t really show optimally until they get close to or a bit beyond 20 years, especially Bordeaux, CdP, Barolos, Toros and Riberas. Capable means the serious players in good or great years, and of course the storage must be solid. Sadly I have had few good experiences with New World wines beyond 10-15 years. Even when they can go the distance they tend to come up short.
12/11/20, 7:37 AM - Bam_Man: Thank you for your kind words. I buy most wines in sets of three, four, or six bottles, and occasionally more when I know the wine well and think it can go 20 years or more. That way I can drink the wine as it evolves. Why not go for it! I almost always try a bottle at ten years old if I have three, except maybe for really good Bordeaux and Barolos, which can easily go 20 years. When you do try it, please post as I’d like to know what you think.
12/11/20, 7:38 AM - Jjlgd: Thank you for your nice comment, and for your point about warm vintages of Oreno. I love hearing about the older vintages of Oreno, and I have never tasted the 2000 vintage. I agree with you that Oreno doesn’t show very much when young. I remember trying well-made wines like Diamond Creek, Mondavi Reserve and some Schraders at wine tastings and thinking they seemed balanced and well-made, but they made no real impression on me. I thought it was a case of “The Emperor Has No Clothes,” but many years later I realized these wines were made for the long haul and just didn’t show their full potential young. Many young wines that are built for the cellar seemed somewhat tannic to me, and I mistook the absence of the big tannic structure for being an unimpressive wine. So your comment about the 200 resonated with me.
11/9/20, 12:56 PM - Go Gators!
10/7/20, 6:28 PM - Spot on!
12/13/19, 5:13 PM - Enjoy that wine! I live in both worlds: insufferable and stuffy snobbery, yet I can really enjoy any wine that’s not truly undrinkable (and even that works over I’ve as a gentlemen’s drink on a hot afternoon).
12/13/19, 2:34 PM - Excellent point about professional vs. consumer scoring, and why I rely on Cellar Tracker more than any professional.
11/23/19, 12:21 PM - Perhaps the greatest wine review ever. I’m insanely jealous I didn’t write it.
2/2/19, 11:36 AM - Go Gators!
11/6/18, 4:13 PM - Excellent description of where this wine is now
7/8/18, 10:01 AM - Go Gators! -Brad
5/29/18, 4:21 AM - 375 ml half bottle. I hope to read your review if you have a bottle.
4/29/18, 9:07 PM - Outstanding review. Thank you.
4/3/18, 6:13 PM - I thought my comment was unnecessarily mean-spirited. This tastes NOTHING like Roundup.
7/17/17, 11:38 AM - Thank you for the tasting note. I was thinking of asking Andy to find me the 2014 vintage of this wine and am sorry to have missed missed a Wine Watch tasting featuring Sicilian wines.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search