6/11/22, 6:42 AM - I guess I've always viewed the score as an assessment of the quality level of the wine and the "like it" or "don't like it" as more personal preference (sort of "note to self: don't re-purchase"). I suspect there are wines I would rate a lower score, but like, and probably higher that I don't like. Does that make sense, or am I not doing it right?
10/8/21, 10:14 AM - Just confirming this was the 2019, 2020 seems early for it to have been released, am I missing something?
10/9/21, 12:11 PM - No not aware of your site, just saw your user review on CT. Usually I see a "BT" on a review when it's from the barrel, but duh, makes perfect sense. Just wanted to confirm you weren't reviewing a different vintage before I got too excited about 2019, thanks!
7/31/21, 3:46 PM - It’s interesting you say that. I overweighted 2016 Napa Cabs, given the glowing reviews of the vintage, and also given the fires the next several seasons (I figured there would be smoke taint risk). I then mostly didn’t touch them, planning to let them age. Occasionally I’ll pull one out because I’m curious. Every time so far, across maybe 8-10 producers, I’ve been underwhelmed, certainly compared to the same bottles from 2012 and 2013. If what you say is right, I may have missed the young window and should just wait 3-5 more years. Obviously it will differ by winemaker and bottle, but I just haven’t been particularly impressed so far.
6/13/20, 3:19 PM - Thanks! Yes I decanted, but poured the first glass immediately. Notes are over about 2-2.5 hours in the decanter.
10/11/20, 9:16 AM - Thanks!
7/9/20, 6:43 PM - It's from the right bank, isn't it? Are you saying it's closer in style to the left bank Bordeaux?
7/8/20, 8:08 AM - I don't have enough experience w Syrah/Shiraz (and usually CdP or US-based, so very different), and certainly not with Penfolds, to confidently proclaim that it's not still on the upswing. I too have a few different vintages of this (all younger), and this was the first one I'd opened. Highly recommended, but can't comment on whether a few more years might make it even better...
7/8/20, 8:03 AM - Great point! There are so many wines, grapes, regions, variations, I do think when something doesn't hit me right, it's often just due to lack of experience/exposure, so I "judge it," based on my prior reference points. At some level, we each "like what we like," but I agree that just describing a wine that's different that what you're accustomed to is a good approach, then making the mental note "SB w Sem is a different experience than New World SB," is part of the point of trying new things and taking the time to make notes. Helpful comment, thanks.
7/7/20, 6:07 PM - Fun write up! Bill is a friend, my first boss back in the day, and he's a great guy...glad you followed his advice!
2/25/20, 8:12 PM - I don't understand, is this a review of L&M Red 2010, or something else? Confusing intro...
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search