The Year in Wine at CellarTracker. Check out CellarTracker Insights >

Comments on my notes

(25 comments on 20 notes)

1 - 20 of 20 Sort order
Red
2015 Pertimali (Livio Sassetti) Brunello di Montalcino Sangiovese
2/3/2023 - Hawkeye_Addict Likes this wine:
92 points
I like this wine, although it seems further along than it should be for a 2015. Lots of secondary notes already. Mushroom and compost for sure. Blue fruits on the palate with strong tannins. The tannins alone will carry this for another decade. Cheers!
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    2/4/23, 4:19 AM - Maybe it was just this bottle? I had one last summer that I don’t recall being like this. If you have a couple, might be worth popping a cork to see.

Red
2014 Boyanci Cabernet Sauvignon Beckstoffer Missouri Hopper Oakville
1/29/2023 - MK9786 wrote:
flawed
Cork in terrible shape in both bottles: dry and crumbly. Recent order with Wine Access.

Update: Good customer service, replacements are being sent.
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    1/29/23, 2:21 PM - Oh no! I have three shipping soon from Wine Access as well. Not good. Did you contact them?

  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    1/31/23, 7:54 AM - Would love to hear what they come back with. Keep us posted!

  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    2/2/23, 7:08 PM - Thank you for the update. Glad they took care of it for you.

Red
2018 Harlan Estate The Maiden Napa Valley Red Bordeaux Blend
11/13/2022 - eschaefer Likes this wine:
95 points
What a pleasurable young Napa cab. Big and you g it was hedonistic. Purple black with a dark fruit core. Medium bodied actually. Not overweight, which was nice. Aromas of smoke, black fruit and mint. Super great texture and body. Very silky. I drink a lot of old cali cabs but I was happy to drink this young un. Highly recommended.
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    11/16/22, 3:24 PM - I only have 3! I am going to wait several years before I pop #1. However good to hear it’s already pleasurable. Cheers!

Red
2019 Domaine du Grand Tinel Châteauneuf-du-Pape Alexis Establet Red Rhone Blend
1/9/2022 - Jeff Leve wrote:
95 points
Earthy, floral, herbal, and already displaying loads of sweet, fresh, ripe, cherries and kirsch, with purity, elegance and lift, this refined wine is going to be delicious with only a modicum of aging. The wine is made from 100% old vine Grenache. Drink from 2024 - 2037
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    11/5/22, 10:59 AM - LMAO! This is amazing.

Red
2010 Château Smith Haut Lafitte Pessac-Léognan Red Bordeaux Blend
7/9/2022 - ASMB Likes this wine:
92 points
Definitely needs more time... A lot more time.
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    7/13/22, 6:15 PM - I had this two days before you and completely agree. With that being said, with a good decant, it was very enjoyable. Cheers!

Red
2016 Joseph Phelps Insignia Napa Valley Red Bordeaux Blend
6/12/2022 - Libbidog Likes this wine:
100 points
One hour decant. It's perfect. Exceptional, juicy black fruit. Vanilla, spicy, dusty earth, cigar box. Multi-minute finish. Complexity is off the charts. For my taste in Cali cab, it gets no better. Life and wine are good!
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    6/12/22, 6:50 PM - Love this! Glad I have several in the cellar. Cheers!

Red
2018 Harlan Estate The Maiden Napa Valley Red Bordeaux Blend
3/20/2022 - msuwine wrote:
94 points
This ripe and dense Cabernet needs another few years to open up, but it has all the youthful signs of the full, savory, and earthy characteristics that make the Maiden one of the best “second” wines in the Valley (and no doubt one of the most expensive). Similar to an Abreu Rothwell Hyde I tasted recently, this 2018 is more brooding and grainy than many others of this vintage (albeit ones I tasted more than six months ago, so this all could be timing - the moving target of vinous analytics). Anyway, this wine is very good now and should become great later - and I would recommend opening it later (i.e., 2024).

Dark red in color and medium in body, the wine offers aromas of blackberry, pencil lead, leather, and tapenade. The flavors are precise but raw (like a thoughtful sermon passionately delivered), with notes of boysenberry, cocoa powder, dried thyme, and crushed gravel, with a grippy and earthy finish (read: not sweet, definitely tannic). 14.5% alcohol. This was more harsh and less integrated than a (stunning) 2014 Maiden tasted on the same evening, but the 2018 was undoubtedly made of the same ilk (perhaps with a bit more punch. Bottom line, this is a classy and delicious wine that needs - and will reward - time. Decant at least three hours if drinking now, but ideally wait another few years. 94+ at the moment.
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    3/28/22, 6:14 AM - Can’t wait to get my shipment from the winery. Glad to hear it’s good now, but like you, anticipating great things in a few years. Thanks for sharing!

Red
2005 Château Léoville Poyferré St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
12/31/2021 - partymonk Likes this wine:
94 points
Dark purple in color. PnP. Beautiful nose, all the bdx earth/tobacco/cedar box, dark fruit, still a bit closed, easily agebale for another 20+ years. Palate was quite similar- great structure, well smooth tannins, medium finish.
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    3/6/22, 11:19 AM - I have an ‘05 magnum of this as well! Glad to hear it can still go a while longer. Thanks!

  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    3/7/22, 10:27 AM - Good to know! Thank you!

Red
2007 Viñedos de Páganos Rioja Gran Reserva El Puntido Tempranillo
12/17/2021 - WineKnut Likes this wine:
91 points
Purplish garnet with no sediment in bottle. Medium slow legs.

Nose is well on it's way. Dusty, vanilla, tobacco, leather, thyme, fig and baked cherry. A bit hot at first, but faded with a little air.

Palate is similarly developed. A hint more red fruited, but still confirming nose.

Finish is super long. Offering up a huge lingering graphite, well... experience is the only word I can come up with.

Really enjoyed this tonight. Perhaps a bit rustic, but really tasty. Maybe not for the long haul. The fruit is definitely heading into the background.

Updated in comments.
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    12/28/21, 2:43 PM - This is a good little nugget. Thanks for sharing!

Red
2016 Harlan Estate The Maiden Napa Valley Red Bordeaux Blend
8/30/2021 - msuwine wrote:
96 points
Midnight in Oakville: This wine shows what a restrained hand can do in a generous vintage - and the results are remarkable. Similarly purple in color and full in body to the Carter OG, the Maiden offers more pure aromas of black cherry, fresh embers, anise, and bay leaf. The flavors are similarly generous without being sweet (read: unencumbered by oak or extraction), including notes of boysenberry, camphor, peppercorn, and trail dust, with a silky and integrated finish. 14.8% alcohol.

This is even better than when I tasted it 18 months ago (2/20 - 95 points), with more class and integration. This was in the same realm as a 2016 Abreu Madrona I had a few nights ago, with less intensity but just the same amount of class. 96+ at the moment, with upside in 2023 or later. The best Maiden I've tasted since the 2013, this wine is only going to get better.
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    11/13/21, 9:48 AM - I really enjoyed reading this. Thank you.

    I bought a three pack of the 2018 Maiden when the estate opened it up recently. With such large yields in ‘18, as was reported, what are your thoughts on the leftover from Harlan Estate maybe not having as much parity as in smaller yield years?

Red
1995 Chateau Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon The Montelena Estate Napa Valley
8/19/2021 - Hawkeye_Addict Likes this wine:
92 points
Still has some youth to it. Tannins are still very present. Agree with the comment below that it is Bordeaux like. Pencil shavings, cigar box, forest floor. Has a cedar chest old car smell that I enjoy. Not a ton of fruit left on the palate, but it hasn’t gone completely tertiary. Dark fruit for sure of what’s left. Enjoyable with my ribeye. Enjoy!
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    8/20/21, 7:51 PM - I would say about an hour, but drank by myself over the next two. Didn’t change all that much. I my was very pleasant though. Some friends that aren’t used to old wines commented that that it seemed very medicinal.

Red
2018 Good Decisions Cabernet Sauvignon Howell Mountain
7/15/2021 - chapulin Likes this wine:
94 points
This is a Wine Access NDA cabernet; these wines tend to be very hit or miss. The quality heavily depends on whether the wine was made by the NDA winemaker or by the Wine Access (or contracted) winemaker, and it's almost impossible to know which. The description suggests that this is a declassified wine from Kinsman Eades, though of course it's impossible to know for sure. But context aside, this Howell Mountain wine was pretty incredible. Blackberry-like fruits dominate at this early stage, and the oak is very prominent. Tannins are very fine-grained, and the wine shows little evolution after being open 24 hours. Given this was $40, it would be very difficult to think of a better AVA-labelled wine at this price. I bought 2 bottles and regret not buying more. Of all the Wine Access NDA Napa cabernets I've had, this is by far the best
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    7/16/21, 11:33 AM - I have three bottles coming my way! Excited to let them rest for a couple years before popping the cork on the first.

  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    7/16/21, 1:12 PM - I’ve had the Radio Silence and The Phoenix, and both were exceptional for the price.

  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    7/23/21, 3:30 PM - @CaroPalms - I would agree with that and tend to do the same. Good observation!

Red
2010 Château Smith Haut Lafitte Pessac-Léognan Red Bordeaux Blend
6/18/2021 - LiteItOnFire Likes this wine:
94 points
Starting drinking 1hr in last glass 3 hours. What a wonderful wine, thoroughly enjoyed, and while might not be perfect spot it is in a very good drinking window. For sure has sediment and decanting needs but when it opens up it explodes from the glass with ripe plum, black currants, in ripe blackberry, blueberry, boat load of red fruits, tremendous lift, cigar, earth, coffe grinds, and a super long voluptuous finish. What a great wine with depth and pleasure to go around. So good. 94 - 95
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    6/27/21, 7:26 AM - Just picked up a couple bottles from Wine Access. Excited! Arriving in mind August though. Boo.

Red
1984 Stag's Leap Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley
6/12/2021 - jviz wrote:
94 points
Very much alive and drinking great. This wine had a few people confused for Bordeaux. Very sappy and balanced, with red fruits and some spearmint. Fully resolved. I have yet to taste an 84 from Napa that disappoints. Thanks Tmud
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    6/24/21, 7:30 PM - Great to hear this! Have a magnum in my cellar I’ve been saving for my birthday. Anxious to give it a go in a couple weeks. ‘84 is my birth year and have always wanted to try wine from then.

Red
2016 Château Bernadotte Haut-Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend
6/15/2021 - Hawkeye_Addict Likes this wine:
90 points
Awesome QPR. Easy drinker that prevents me from raiding my cellar.
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    6/16/21, 9:05 AM - Glad I could help!

Red
2007 Viñedos de Páganos Rioja Gran Reserva El Puntido Tempranillo
3/29/2021 - Hawkeye_Addict Likes this wine:
93 points
Fruitier and juicer than I anticipated. Color is more than of Cabernet than Rioja. Most Rioja I’ve had is lighter in color with dusty tannins, and very vegetal. This was way different in a good way. Definitely had the old world minerality I love. Very balanced on the palate with refined tannins and acidity. Good now but also could hold for another 10 years or more.
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    3/29/21, 5:30 PM - Thank you! I did decant. There was actually a fair amount of sediment in this particular bottle. Opened up nicely as well after 3 hours or so.

Red
2018 Bevan Cellars Ontogeny Napa Valley Red Bordeaux Blend
2/27/2021 - Francois Le Mouel Likes this wine:
98 points
I had such a blast with my first bottle that I couldn't resist and opened a second bottle (of course, just to confirm my first impression...strictly for academic reasons;))

Very consistent with my first note. I would just add: "...notes of incense; like Sally Field in the Flying Nun throwing a party at the convent..." This wine is like a mini-wheat, it has a very serious side, as well as a fun side.
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    3/10/21, 8:40 AM - A mini-wheat. Love it.

Red
2016 Mayacamas Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Mt. Veeder
12/11/2020 - NostraBacchus Likes this wine:
98 points
100% Cabernet Sauvignon from Mount Veeder. Wow, this is really good, the sheer class and sophistication is really amazing. Deep dark red berries, black cherries, notes of new leather, some tobacco, graphite, a touch of scorched minerality, some espresso roast. It's medium-full bodied, but seems lighter on its feet, while at the same time has incredible mid-palate persistence. There is high tannin that is excellent quality and high acidity providing tons of freshness and brightens up the overall appearance. Long finish with excellent complexion building up. There is an almost creamy mouthfeel to it which is really intriguing, as other people have commented. This has depth without weight, something only the best wines in the world achieve. Wow.
This is built for the long term...
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    1/4/21, 2:12 PM - Excellent notes/comments. Have four bottles of the ‘16 in my cellar and am waiting at least 5 years to open the first. Thanks for sharing your experience!

Red
2016 Château Pontet-Canet Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
8/1/2020 - vintage1949 Likes this wine:
96 points
A high quality Bordeaux wine that is drinkable in four years? Impossible. A 2016 Bordeaux wine that shows off its class in 2020. Incredible. A 2016 Pauillac with a nose that is what some may call beguiling. Intriguing.

Someone here with the name of Mark and another CTer wanted me to open one bottle of a six pack of Chateau Pontet-Canet. Thought it would be a tannic waste. Wow was I wrong.

Let’s start with the nose. Pouring a small amount into a Riedel glass and letting it sit for a little over an hour allowed the fruit to blossom. I was expecting a tight as a drum nose-maybe bitter not scents that revealed the quality of the vintage. I was greeted by a warm blanket of cassis, cigar box, black fruit, and tobacco.

This warm blanket coated the tongue with the presentation of the nose causing one to smile. No hole in the middle here but a mouth filling, cascading offering of what I consider true Pauillac flavors.

In time I think layers of complexity will form creating an even bigger smile on my face. I guess that Mark guy and another friend were correct. Now it is time to sit back and dream of the flavors to come. Dave
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    12/21/20, 1:58 PM - Great review! Just picked up four bottles recently and am already itching to get at one. I plan to wait until 2026 though, at the 10 year mark, to open the first one and see how it is. Cheers!

Red
2018 Wine Access Cabernet Sauvignon Radio Silence Napa Valley
12/19/2020 - Hawkeye_Addict Likes this wine:
92 points
Smooth in the mouth. Moderate tannin. Pretty typical Cabernet on the nose and palate. Feels like it has the potential to be special in a couple years. Leather, dark fruit and rose petal.
  • Hawkeye_Addict commented:

    12/19/20, 6:25 PM - @KillerJones - Was it the 2018 vintage? I think this a different grape source than previous Radio Silence vintages. If you look on Wine Access, I think they explain where this NDA came from.

1 - 20 of 20
© 2003-23 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close