Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(9 comments on 8 notes)

1 - 8 of 8 Sort order
Red
2018 Faustino Rioja Reserva V Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
1/27/2024 - lhpontes Likes this wine:
78 points
Dependable as always, nice wood and spice.
  • peeks13 commented:

    3/30/24, 12:17 PM - Your note strikes a somewhat positive slant. How come the 78 score then?

Red
2017 Domaine Charvin Châteauneuf-du-Pape Red Rhone Blend
On a warm summer evening such as this, a bottle of Charvin feels perfect, and even more so with the 2017 before me with its intensely elegant nose of raspberries, garrigue and citrus.

Its palate has spunk, length, lots of stars and very interesting flavors of fruit and heated hill shrubs. Its length makes this a joyous song in my mouth. Absence of oak, its rarity, heritage, and purity make this bottle ever more perfect for Monday sunset with the crickets.

I’m somewhat of a strange wine lover as I do not particularly like Grenache, but here, I do.

This cuvee has a delicious crunch, probably from its whole cluster fermentation in concrete. So endearing is this crunch that I’m tempted to create a new word for it: Crunch-Garrigue. The presence of citrus, raspberry and crunch of herbal tars slowly taint my mouth and build with every sip rendering it more crunchy with garrigue. Love this! Excellent! Celebrate on 9-11! I drink to the memory celebrating life as the moments of mortality bring profundity of now.

A case of this to enjoy for years to come! It will assuredly get better.

The next day, 29 hours later from undecanted bottle, poured the last glass:
Gorgeous nose with pronounced cola and berries. Could live in this nose. Flowers, perfume.
Palate of concentrated flowers with crunch of garrigue. It’s concentrated potpourri. Energy galore! It spanks my palate. It explodes in my mouth. It's rich and makes me wow as to its density and levity. Great wine.

As fresh as this is from overnight in bottle with about 6oz left, this is a cellar keeper. It will last for a decade more +.
Excellent wine. Well made.
I keep revisiting the nose in my Riedel Burgundy glass: Holy fresh flowers aromas with garrigue. Just love it!
  • peeks13 commented:

    9/16/23, 10:29 PM - Given your long description, why didn't you rate it?

Red
2019 Buena Vista Cabernet Sauvignon Chateau Buena Vista Napa Valley
2/3/2023 - peeks13 wrote:
87 points
3 hour decant and drank over 3 more but it still stayed in vanilla oak-town until the last glass. Make of that what you will. I think the last glass evolved more to the cabernet experience I had hoped for but by then I had lost interest. I could buy another bottle and experiment with the cellaring or ageing, but I won't.
  • peeks13 commented:

    2/4/23, 2:36 PM - If it were the more challenging 2020 smoke taint vintage I would agree on expectations but I've had some nice 2019s across price points and regions. For this Buena Vista I would have been happy with a well-balanced Bordeaux grapes blend but it was all oak. If you like that oak-influenced Caymus or Silver Oak Alex Valley then getting this at half the price is right up your alley.

Red
2016 Pahlmeyer Cabernet Sauvignon Jayson Napa Valley
9/26/2020 - Mdb1982 Likes this wine:
93 points
Jayson Cabernet Sauvignon reveals its classic expression with deep, elegant black fruit aromas, and hints of plum, licorice, vanilla, fresh cream and the suggestion of forest floor. A juicy entry leads into a dense mid-palate; mocha, dusty chalk, and attractive herbal hints round out the rich flavors. Fine tannins support the fruit character for a complex, balanced wine that pairs well with food.
  • peeks13 commented:

    2/15/21, 1:18 PM - I agree with your tasting note. Had my last of 2 bottles last night and should have decanted longer, up to 4 hours for best enjoyment.

Red
2015 Bodegas El Nido Jumilla Clio Red Blend
3/2/2020 - RDHudak wrote:
93 points
Goosebump good. plenty of juicy fruit, with a very well balanced structure and just enough tannin to firm up the fruit. Absolutely singing! That said, I completely disagree with Peeks13, as several tried it blind and loved it.
  • peeks13 commented:

    12/2/20, 2:06 PM - Another CTer PM'd me with similar comments as yours. My perspective is coming from one of, "when did you join the Clio party?" I always loved Clio (since 2006) but lately it has underperformed IMO. I notice that the comments are consistent...big, juicy, easy to drink. True. And while many love that I view it as a negative given what Clio is capable of.

Red
2015 Siro Pacenti Brunello di Montalcino Vecchie Vigne Sangiovese
3/2/2020 - Burgundy Al wrote:
95 points
Suckling's Great Wines of Italy (Loews Hotel - Chicago IL): Walk around tasting. Clearly modern styled, but so many great things are going on here. Old vine concentration with ripe black and red cherry, sweet and savory spice with floral character. There is wonderfully bright texture coming from great acidity and soft, elegant tannins. Great now with so much upside.
  • peeks13 commented:

    3/24/20, 2:53 PM - Sounds like it was a great tasting. How did you know about it? Did you get on a list? I need to be on this list.

Red
2014 Sean Minor Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley
12/30/2017 - Cancan12 Likes this wine:
98 points
Full bodied. Dark berry, plum and hint of oak aroma. Cherry, plum and oak flavor. Very smooth and rich, with a nice finish. Excellent value.
  • peeks13 commented:

    12/31/17, 11:44 AM - 98 points?

Red
2006 Cellers Can Blau Montsant Mas de Can Blau Red Rhone Blend
9/15/2012 - toddmk wrote:
93 points
Absolutely delicious. Outstanding nose. Great core of dark fruit with nice earthy complexity. For $20 this is an amazing value. Unfortunately, I only had one bottle.
  • peeks13 commented:

    6/1/13, 3:04 PM - I'd love to know where you found this for $20...usually it's $40 by me.

  • peeks13 commented:

    6/1/13, 3:04 PM - I'd love to know where you found this for $20...usually it's $40 by me.

1 - 8 of 8
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close