Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(68 comments on 58 notes)

1 - 50 of 58 Sort order
Rosé
2021 Château Miraval Côtes de Provence Rosé Grenache Blend, Grenache
1/31/2023 - Yagil wrote:
89 points
Very enjoyable excellent rosé
  • Yagil commented:

    3/27/23, 1:55 PM - Thanks for your comment.
    It's a typo error: corrected to 89.

Red
2017 Descendientes de José Palacios Bierzo Villa de Corullon Mencía
Don’t know what others see in this, but it has high acid but not the fruit to back it up.

Disappointing.

2-12-23 second bottle a little different with some fruit still shining. Second bottle would score a 89. I have 4 left.
  • Yagil commented:

    3/9/23, 11:33 AM - this is quite a good wine.
    if the 2nd bottle score was 89 - why didn't you put 89 as the score?
    83 isn't the right score for this wine. perhaps the 1st bottle was flawed.

Red
2007 Domaine de Marcoux Châteauneuf-du-Pape Red Rhone Blend
8/13/2022 - Yagil wrote:
93 points
Coravin tasting
med- ruby-brown
pronounced aromas intensity of red cherries, strawberries, plums, tobacco, leather, earth, pepper, oak-vanilla
developed
dry, high acidity, med velvety tannins, high abv, med+ body, pronounced flavors intensity consistent with the nose, complex, elegant, balanced, harmonious, long finish, excellent wine - met my expectations!
can drink now - suitable for further 3-5 years aging
  • Yagil commented:

    8/21/22, 6:36 PM - יבואן לישראל?
    אין לי מושג
    הובא אישית מחו״ל

Red
2008 Château Lynch-Bages Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
6/7/2022 - Yagil wrote:
93 points
Premium Mature Bordeaux Blend (at my home): Excellent. (Almost) at peak.
  • Yagil commented:

    6/18/22, 10:55 PM - Almost at peak = surely ready to drink

Red
2009 Henri Bonneau Châteauneuf-du-Pape Réserve des Célestins Red Rhone Blend
5/29/2022 - Yagil wrote:
95 points
Deep Ruby
Pronounced aromas intensity of dark forest fruits, cherries, prunes, earth, leather, forest floor, mushrooms, tobacco, tea leaves, oak-vanilla
Developed
Dry, high acidity, high tannins, high abv, high complexity, long finish, Pronounced flavors intensity consistent with the aromas.
Outstanding wine.
Drink now, at peak, though can be aged further.
  • Yagil commented:

    6/4/22, 10:57 AM - true - it wasn't a blind tasting

Red
2008 Carmel Limited Edition Upper Galilee Red Bordeaux Blend
11/10/2014 - mark_m_owen wrote:
90 points
From a tasting. This is pretty good, nice and fresh with good balance throughout. Took it's time to open up and whilst the fruit and tannin were in reasonably harmony it lacked any really interesting secondary notes. I have a bottle to see how it will develop as the tannins soften but it's a pretty expensive bottle so I hope it gains a bit more complexity.
  • Yagil commented:

    4/3/15, 6:31 AM - Hello Mark,

    Perhaps you should consider buying a Coravin, like me, then you'll be able to enjoy a single bottle during several years…
    Happy Passover!

    Yagil

  • Yagil commented:

    4/19/22, 10:52 PM - Bravo for buying the Coravin.
    Recently I replaced my 10-years-old Coravin with a newer Coravin version.

    I also bought the Pivot for easier use with bottles that are planned to be consumed within less than one month (but not on first day).
    The Pivot is very user-friendly & fast-pour vs the traditional Coravin.

Red
2011 Aubert Pinot Noir Ritchie Vineyard Sonoma Coast
11/22/2014 - Yagil wrote:
89 points
Sonoma Pinot Noir tasting (at Nurit & Asher Tishler, Mazkeret-Batya): this was my 4th CA PN - but the first to show some PN quality, though still cannot compare it to the real Burgundy PN, so I was quite generous with the score here….
  • Yagil commented:

    12/22/21, 12:00 AM - jazzwineman - you're right!

Red
2016 Jacques Capsouto Vignobles Cuvée Marco - Grand Vin Rouge Galilee Red Blend
4/12/2020 - raccah Does not like this wine:
50 points
This wine is DEAD truly dead. It has turned into Brett and dirt and nothing else. MOVE ON!
  • Yagil commented:

    9/30/21, 12:08 PM - at worst case you encountered a bottle variation;
    try another bottle, give it 15-20 at least to breeze - and you'll find a delicate charming wine.

Red
2015 La Braccesca (Antinori) Vino Nobile di Montepulciano Riserva Vigneto Santa Pia Sangiovese
8/30/2019 - Alexander Smith Likes this wine:
89 points
A standard Montalcino, with dark over-ripe fruits and berries and earthy aromas, the palate was medium-bodied with dark cherries, black fruit, liquorice, chocolate along with grippy tannins and a medium finish. rustic in style. 100% Sangiovese (Prugnolo Gentile)
  • Yagil commented:

    8/9/21, 12:03 AM - A standard Montalcino?

    (it's a Vino Nobile di Montepulciano...)

Red
2004 Bodegas y Viñedos Alión Ribera del Duero Tinto Fino, Tempranillo
6/30/2021 - Yagil wrote:
94 points
Top Spanish wines (originally RP 95+) (George & John restaurant, Drisko hotel, TLV): dark opaque red-brown-black
Intense ripe-fruity-plummy aromas with notes of chocolate, light spices & tobacco
Excellent harmony, soft & round integrated tannins, still a pleasant amount of ripe fruitiness, coated with a thick layer of chocolate, silky mature sensation with subtle notes of spices and delicate wood. Long finish of a great Ribera wine, a full bodied wine that is, still, in great shape and is very much enjoyable. Can further age 5-10 years.
  • Yagil commented:

    7/3/21, 3:34 AM - Not at all

White
1996 Joseph Drouhin Rully Blanc Chardonnay
3/1/2007 - Yagil wrote:
82 points
undrinkable; yellow; bad smell
  • Yagil commented:

    6/13/21, 5:59 PM - typo error
    should have been 82 at most

Red
2017 Cerbaiona (Molinari) Rosso di Montalcino Sangiovese
4/24/2018 - Yagil wrote:
93 points
Cerbaiona tasting (winery): BT
much more elegant nose than the Rosso 2017
Richer complexity, very well structured
Longer finish
  • Yagil commented:

    3/24/21, 11:48 AM - Frankl, I don't recall.
    Perhaps the second note referred to Brunello...

    P.S.
    What's "Gordon's (Waltham MA USA) offer "?

Red
2014 Luigi Baudana Barolo Serralunga d'Alba Nebbiolo
8/12/2019 - DanielJH wrote:
93 points
Nice enough Barolo without setting my world on fire. The nose is fragrant but doesn’t leap out like so many Nebbiolo from this region. The palate has a good hit of cherry and pomegranate juice, but the length isn’t huge. Tannins are bold and quite rustic, but well resolved after a good decant. A nice wine, but doesn’t have the X factor for this region, style or price.
  • Yagil commented:

    11/23/20, 9:40 PM - having read your tasting note - does it really deserve 93 points?
    I doubt...

White
N.V. Domaine de Latroun (Trappistes) Pinot Gris Judean Hills
7/21/2010 - Jan Schultink wrote:
82 points
An N.V Pinot Gris! Pink/dark yellow in color. Undefined glazed and slightly cooked fruit. Lacking acidity and a slightly oily, heavy texture leading to a short finish with some bread/yeast notes. What a pity that this winery with the best "story" of all wineries in Israel does not produce better wines.
  • Yagil commented:

    11/12/20, 5:34 AM - I heard from David Silverman that this is 2019 vintage - although it's not mentioned on the label...

Red
2010 Le Macchiole Paleo Rosso Toscana IGT Cabernet Franc
5/27/2020 - Yagil wrote:
94 points
Ramat-Aviv Boys meeting (at my home): Medium purple color,
Pronounced aromas intensity of dark plum, tobacco, violets, espresso, dark chocolate, graphite, cassis, dark cherries, smoke, sweet spices.
Dry, high acidity, high ripe tannins, high abv, medium-full bodied,
excellent freshness, long finish;
A superb Paleo and this is just getting better and better over the years... still young at this stage
  • Yagil commented:

    10/22/20, 4:40 AM - Hello Dave
    I believe that the magnum is already ready - but can be further aged.
    You can either review the many TN on CT and search for opinions about its readiness,
    alternatively, you can consult with Le Macchiole
    Hope this helps,
    Yagil

White
2017 Jean Claude Courtault Chablis Chardonnay
11/29/2019 - Yagil wrote:
88 points
clean, pale yellow green
med aromas intensity of lime, lemon, green-apple, grapefruit, kiwi, stone-fruit, mineral;
developing;
dry, high acidity, med abv, med body;
med+ flavors intensity consistent with the aromas, long salty finish;
can drink now - suitable for further aging;
  • Yagil commented:

    6/22/20, 12:47 AM - very good

Red
2013 Bodegas AAlto Ribera del Duero AAlto Tempranillo
4/1/2014 - Yagil wrote:
87 points
purple color, fruity aroma & flavours, already approachable
  • Yagil commented:

    1/31/20, 11:15 PM - this score (87) reflects my subjective impression.
    perhaps the wine wasn't aerated enough or a bottle variation - but surely it was below my expectation from this wine.

Red
2015 Michele Chiarlo Barbera d'Asti Superiore Le Orme
10/15/2019 - Yagil wrote:
Coravin tasting
Med+ ruby
Med aromas intensity of
Developing;
Dry, high acidity, med- tannins, med abv, med- body, med+ flavors intensity consistent with nose, med length finish, lacks complexity;
drink now - not suitable for long aging;
  • Yagil commented:

    10/15/19, 2:40 AM - T

White
2017 Marqués de Riscal Verdejo Rueda
12/23/2018 - dides Likes this wine:
81 points
DESCRIPTION
– Localisation : Castille léon, 160 km au Nord ouest de Madrid

– Terroir : Argilo sableux

– Cépages : 15 % Viura, 85 % Verdejo

– Vinification : Macération à froid pour extraire un maximum d’arômes, fermentation entre 13°C et 15°C, élevage en cuve inox

– Dégustation : Nez d’agrumes et de pamplemousse rose, légère minéralité, notes fumées, bouche rafraîchissante et parfumée

– T°C de service : entre 10°C et 12°C

– Ouverture : à la dégustation

– Accords mets/vin : Poissons grillés, crustacés,à tester sur un fromage de chèvre frais, poisson cru (sushis)
  • Yagil commented:

    5/14/19, 9:23 PM - Grape variety: Verdejo 100%
    Best served at between 8º and 10ºC
    Food Pairing: This wine pairs well with fish, shellfish, ham, pasta dishes, chicken and cold meat.
    reference: https://www.marquesderiscal.com/vinos_detalleeng.php?id=22

Red
2017 Domaine du Castel Petit Castel Kosher Judean Hills Red Bordeaux Blend
2/6/2019 - vlzat wrote:
90 points
Cabernet Sauvignon 50%, Merlot 45% and Petit Verdot 5%

Very nice and characterful in spite of expectation of the vintage. Full body, deep garnet color. Intense black dried fruits and oak aroma. Plum, black olives palate and long mineral finish. Rich and complex, well balanced, gentle acidity and sweet tannins. Best match is grilled meat. Open at least one hour ahead. Serve 18º - 22º. Drink now while young and next four/five years.
  • Yagil commented:

    4/6/19, 2:26 AM - הי
    לא נראה לי סביר להגיש מעל 20 מעלות. 18-19 זה הטווח האופטימלי.
    כ״כ לטעמי - היין צעיר מדי להנאה אמיתית. בטווח של 5- 10 שנים הוא במיטבו

  • Yagil commented:

    4/6/19, 6:24 AM - There's NO red wine that is enjoyable at 24c !

    In all wine related literature red wine serving temp is 18-19c !

    https://www.google.com/search?q=red+wine+serving+temperature+celsius&oq=red+wine+serving+temperature&aqs=chrome.1.69i57j0l5.8193j0j8&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8

  • Yagil commented:

    4/6/19, 6:25 AM - https://www.wineware.co.uk/decanting/perfect-drinking-temperature-for-wine

  • Yagil commented:

    4/6/19, 8:32 AM - Well, this is probably unique to you. You're a rare person.
    From the hundreds of wine friends I've and after having visited over 1000 wineries in the past 10 years - nobody liked red wine served above 20c at most. This is my experience and my preference - which seem to be common to the vast majority of wine lovers.

    The fact that in Israel wine (in restaurants or wine shops) is sometimes served above 20c - doesn't make it right.
    When I host friends, or being hosted by friends, or enjoy wine in a restaurant - it's always served at right temperature range - as this issue is being taken care of.

    This is a commonly agreed issue by the absolute majority. I believe you're aware to this. But it's your right to enjoy a warmer wine...
    Cheers!

Red
2010 Château Rollan de By Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend
10/29/2018 - Yagil wrote:
90 points
Coravin tasting
the wine is better than previous times I tasted it and enters its drinking period - though it should be further aged.
  • Yagil commented:

    3/20/19, 9:18 PM - Hello Dave

    you can enjoy this great vintage anytime (at least) through 2030 once it's properly stored.

    I bet you're going to open it for somme event - after all it's like 4 bottles quantity wise.

    best regards,

    Yagil

  • Yagil commented:

    3/22/19, 1:53 PM - re optimal drinking window for any wine
    on CT you can easily find "crowd-wisdom" recommendations
    and on Wine-Searcher you can find "experts" recommendation

    if you really want to be perfect with yourself - consult the winery :-)

Red
2014 Giuseppe Cortese Barbera d'Alba Morassina
10/25/2016 - Yagil wrote:
89 points
18 months in french barrique, 30% new; dark opaque red-purple; red fruits nose with spicy hints, high acidity, rich fruity flavours, lean, pleasnt sour red fruits finish
  • Yagil commented:

    3/2/19, 2:30 PM - Thanks for your comment

Red
2005 R. López de Heredia Rioja Reserva Viña Tondonia Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
11/18/2018 - Yagil wrote:
89 points
WSET course Level 3, 6th session: 70% Tempranillo, 20% Garnacho, 5% Graciano and 5% Mazuelo

Clear, med garnet
Clean, med+ (primary) secondary & tertiary aromas of dark red/black fruits, earth, leather, spices, coffee, savoury, dry fruits,
fully developed

Dry, med+ acidity, high tannins, med alc., med body, med+ primary secondary & tertiary flavours, dark roasted fruits, dry plums, earth, herbaceous, liquorice, mint, eucalyptus,
med+ finish
drink now - (not?) suitable for further ageing
outstanding
  • Yagil commented:

    11/21/18, 9:27 PM - Hello WineKnurd - Thanks for your comment.
    This tasting took place during WSET Level 3 course and it was the general opinion among us re this this specific bottle during blind tasting.
    Once knowing the wine I certainly agree with you that generally this wine can age further.

  • Yagil commented:

    11/22/18, 12:14 AM - Hello Danielgbm - thanks for your comment and your encouragement to re-taste this bottle - which I'll certainly do.
    BTW - where're you from Daniel?

Red
2015 Domaine du Castel Grand Vin Judean Hills Red Bordeaux Blend
7/8/2018 - Yagil wrote:
91 points
Domaine du Castel tasting (Ya'in Ba'Ir Rosh HaA'in): clear, deep purple/black
clean, profound intensity aromas of young fresh dark fruits with spicy hints
dry, high tannins, high acidity, well balance & harmony, good structure, medium complexity, medium level vintage, long finish, still young and requires further ageing
  • Yagil commented:

    7/9/18, 6:36 AM - Generally, top notch Israeli wines, such as the Castel Grand Vin, are at their best 6-12 years after vintage, IMHO.
    Particularly, 2015 wasn't an outstanding vintage for the Castel Grand Vin...

    for more info exchange - please contact me by email.
    andrew@cellartracker.com will share it with you...

Red
2014 Psagot Peak Jerusalem Mountains Red Blend
3/1/2017 - Yagil wrote:
90 points
Psagot Winery visit & tasting (Psagot Winery, Ma'avar Mikhmas): 42% Syrah, 42% PS, 16% Mourvedre
dark opaque red-purple
dark intense spicy fruits nose
soft firm tannins, full bodied, well balanced, good harmony, nicely structured, soft complexity, rich dark fruits flavours, liquorice, spices, pairs well with fat red meat, quality fruity mineral finish
  • Yagil commented:

    10/13/17, 3:25 PM - the wine is not very ripe rather young.
    best drinking period is 2018-2025

White
2009 Clos de Gat Chardonnay Sycra Judean Hills
4/11/2017 - Yagil wrote:
91 points
Intense ripe tropical fruits nose, butter and barrel-oak hints, full bodied, Ella balanced, mature fruity flavours, round, mouth filling. Drink now.
  • Yagil commented:

    9/22/17, 4:10 AM - Shana Tova ULYON

    It's time to enjoy this wine, as it won't improve with further ageing, more likely to become obsolete.

    You can get my email from andrew@cellartracker.com and join my tasting events group in Tel Aviv.

Red
2011 Château Tour Perey St. Émilion Grand Cru Red Bordeaux Blend
4/1/2014 - Yagil wrote:
88 points
100% Malbec, ripe black fruits aroma & flavours, full bodied, powerfull
  • Yagil commented:

    3/10/17, 8:04 PM - hello
    with CT help, as from now you can see two different wine:
    - 2011 Château Tour Perey St. Emilion GCC
    - 2011 Château Tour Perey Malbec

White
2015 Ahat Winery Upper Galilee Chardonnay
1/13/2017 - KPB Likes this wine:
91 points
Exciting Israeli red wines; 1/1/2017-2/28/2017 (Tel Aviv): For an American, the label on this wine is lovely, but challenging: not one word of English except the URL and the year! The wine is pale yellow in color, with a nose that seems slightly exotic, showing pineapple and beeswax, orange peel, hints of sweet white flowers. In the mouth a fairly dry wine, fruit is ripe but nicely framed by the acidity, long but light finish. I'm assuming this is a steel-fermented Chardonnay, although without being able to translate the label I can't be sure. I like it very much, quite Burgundian.
  • Yagil commented:

    1/13/17, 10:49 PM - Google Translation (with partial modifications) of the Hebrew label:

    One (Une en Frnaçais)
    Dry white wine

    In a late August chilly night, at the foot of Mount Meron, the Chardonnay grapes were harvested by hand.
    At dawn they were brought to the winery, sorted, separated and gently crushed.
    The fermentation process took place done in stainless steel tanks and in French oak barrels, as well as the ageing (sur lies)
    The wine has aromas of fresh lemon, is floral and slightly mineral.
    The wine is elegant, complex and refreshing.

    11.5% alcohol by volume.

Red
2004 Bodega Numanthia Toro Numanthia Tinta de Toro, Tempranillo
11/24/2016 - Yagil wrote:
94 points
Castilla y Leon tasting (at my home): P&P
dark opaque red-purple
reduced nose at first, then heavy dark fruits, roasted coffee, oak-vanilla on the nose
dark heavy fruity flavours, liquorice, firm tannins, rich earthy flavours, requires 2-3 hours of decanting, still very young and can further age 5-15 years.

after 20 hours: excellent hedonistic nose & palate
  • Yagil commented:

    12/23/16, 7:33 AM - 12 years old Numanthia, from an excellent vintage, requires 12-18 hours advance opening, or 6 hours of decanting,
    or, wait till it's 20 years old...

    both ways you'll enjoy this wine a lot!!!
    cheers!

Red
2005 Yatir Yatir Forest Judean Hills Red Bordeaux Blend
8/21/2016 - Yagil wrote:
92 points
Top mature Israeli wines 2/2016 (at my home): excellent elegant nose & palate, well balanced, structured, complexed, still quite young and can age 2-5 years.
  • Yagil commented:

    12/7/16, 8:54 PM - several reasons, such as:
    - bottle variation
    - (poor) cellaring conditions of a specific bottle
    - subjective impression of the taster
    - wine evolution
    etc.

White
2009 Midbar Sémillon Negev
3/14/2016 - Yagil wrote:
90 points
2009 Bordeaux tasting (at my home): uncorked 9 hours prior to tasting
excellent ripe fruit nose
great minerality on the palate with fruits flavours and special balance, quite unusual for a warm climate Semillon - but this one is very good!
  • Yagil commented:

    9/10/16, 7:14 PM - Sure.
    This wine requires early decanting or ventilation.
    So a practical way is to pour half bottle into an empty bottle, re-cork both, and let these horizontally in your wine cooler (or cooled wine cellar)

Red
2011 Barkan Cabernet Sauvignon Special Reserve Upper Galilee / Judean Hills
1/17/2014 - Yagil wrote:
86 points
colour: light red
nose: fresh earthy fruity aromas
palate: med bodied and acidity, firm tannins, med harmony, young red fruits with vanilla-oak flavours, short finish.
ready now and will remain enjoyable during the next 2-4 years.
  • Yagil commented:

    8/28/16, 6:56 PM - Hello Ajvandet,

    if what you have are not Special Reseve and surely if weren't stored at 16c or less - you shouldn't expect these to be drinkable any more

  • Yagil commented:

    8/29/16, 10:36 AM - it's unlikely that these wines are still drinkable

Red
2012 Fratelli Brovia Barbera d'Alba Ciabot del Fi
7/7/2016 - Yagil Likes this wine:
89 points
Coravin tasting
Lovely quality red fruits and violets nose with smoky spicy hints
Dry fruity palate, high acidity, balanced, low harmony, structured, fairly complexed, ideal wine for food.
  • Yagil commented:

    7/7/16, 12:57 PM - It's ready now and can nicely age 5-10 years more

White
2015 Lewinsohn Garage de Papa Blanc Jerusalem Mountains Chardonnay
6/3/2016 - Yagil wrote:
92 points
excellent Chardonnay. Still young.
should be aged in bottle for 1-2 years to reach its peak.
  • Yagil commented:

    6/11/16, 1:39 PM - according to the winemaker, Ido Lewinsohn:
    100% of the wine aged during 9 months in french oak barrels, of which 10% new, rest in barrels of different ages up to 7.

Red
2009 Yatir Syrah Negev
6/7/2016 - Yagil wrote:
90 points
dark opaque red purple
excellent nose of dark ripe fruits with black-pepper, liquorice & tar notes
full bodied, soft integrated tannins, structured, fair complexity, rich fruity flavours, mental, eucalyptus, roasted herbs aftertaste, fair harmony.
but the great nose is the issue!
  • Yagil commented:

    6/11/16, 11:55 AM - Today Israeli wines are being exported in large. Only recently there was an international wine exhibition in China in which many Isrseli wineries exhibited. Alternatively I can connect you to any of the top Isrseli wineries.

Red
2005 Domaine de la Janasse Châteauneuf-du-Pape Vieilles Vignes Red Rhone Blend
2/28/2016 - Yagil wrote:
94 points
celebrating my 60 with Zuker at lunch (at my home): dark translucent red-black
rich dark ripe raisins nose, with sous-bois, earthy & spicy aromas that seduce you to sniff for long minutes;
rich dark ripe fruity flavours, firm tannins, frill bodied, excellent harmony, balance & structure; outstanding complexity, spicy, leather, fungi, concentrated, unique, excellent aftertaste
  • Yagil commented:

    3/2/16, 5:51 AM - thank you!

Red
2011 Quinta do Vale Meão Douro Meandro Red Blend
2/21/2015 - Rnarkiss wrote:
89 points
Still "green"
I should have wait one more year
Dark colour nice tanins.Medium after taste
  • Yagil commented:

    2/4/16, 3:24 AM - you're more than welcome to taste it at my home...

Red
2010 Galil Mountain Yiron Upper Galilee Red Bordeaux Blend
4/27/2015 - kenthargis wrote:
86 points
First time to try this. Thought it might be interesting prior to our Israel trip. Alcohol is way up there. Mostly integrated, but still packs too much of a wallop. Fruit is interesting, if a little candied. Flavor profile did seem distinct, given the location. Glad I tried it. Didn't love it, but pleasant enough.
  • Yagil commented:

    10/5/15, 1:53 AM - Hello,
    Should you like to try higher level Israeli wines - please let me know when your visit is planned...
    BR,
    Yagil, TLV

Red
1996 Gaja Langhe Nebbiolo Costa Russi Langhe DOC
5/30/2015 - Endodr Likes this wine:
94 points
(Tasted at the Vintage Piedmont Tasting at the Wine Watch, Ft. Lauderdale). This is a fabulous, fully mature Barbera. It has a very dark, opaque purple color, and a nose of earth, florals, violets, and black fruit. This Barbera tastes of ripe blackberries, cherry cola, raspberries, leather, and smoky oak. It is old world in character, full bodied with crisp acidity, and has a smooth mouth feel. Although this wine is almost 20 years old, it still retains it's youthful fruit flavors. Excellent!!
  • Yagil commented:

    9/22/15, 10:44 AM - hi,

    you write Barbera twice in this TN - but this wine is made of Nebbiolo grapes...

Red
2003 Château Léoville Barton St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
8/26/2015 - Yagil wrote:
94 points
Wine-Septet meeting hosted by Hanan (Herbert Samuel restaurant): dark opaque red-purple
excellent tertiary aromas of dark fruits, leather, cedar & tobacco leaves
rich, well balanced, firm dry tannins, good acidity, balanced fruitiness, excellent complexity & finish
  • Yagil commented:

    8/27/15, 7:10 AM - Hello ODDS
    thanks for your comment.
    while we both fancy great BX wines, your advantage is that you have in NYC (and in The US) a much wider choice of BX wines at attractive prices!
    I'm hunting my great BX in Europe and carry these home.
    You know well that you can find great BX in The US via wine-searcher.com
    and/or use a Coravin to sample a worthy bottle multiple times.
    I'm sure you knew all this before...

Red
1997 Castello Banfi Excelsus Toscana IGT Red Bordeaux Blend
3/7/2015 - stayhappy21 wrote:
88 points
Drank this wine tonight at a family dinner at Mu Liang Zai.

Wine is brick brown with crimson hues around the edges. Fragrant nose with notes of aged oak. On the palate the wine is mellow, medium bodied but not as well integrated as expected even though all the key elements are in place. Notes of dark purple fruits are evident and the structure and acidity are still holding up very well after 28 years of age.

The wine lacks concentration and has a medium finish. Perhaps a few more years in the bottle or a couple of hours in the decanter might improve its performance.
  • Yagil commented:

    8/18/15, 8:55 AM - after 28 years of age?

Red
2010 Château Trotanoy Pomerol Red Bordeaux Blend
7/8/2015 - Yagil wrote:
90 points
Soiree with Jean-Claude Berrouet (Wine-Route, Tel-Aviv): dark opaque purple
rich ripe dark fruity aroma
coffee & chocolate flavours, spicy tones, green notes, pleasant enduring finish
  • Yagil commented:

    7/27/15, 2:51 AM - Sure - you can wait 5-10 years for letting the ageing improve this wine

Red
1996 Château Montrose St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
3/18/2015 - Yagil wrote:
92 points
Coravin tasting
transparent shining red-purple
rich ripe cassis and sweet berries, somewhat funky with barnyardy scents, wet earth and herb, menthol and toasted spice.
med-full bodied, soft firm mouth coating tannins, good acidity level, wonderful balance & harmony,
ripe black cherries and dark berries couched in bright acidity and chewy, long finish.
can further age 8-10 years.
  • Yagil commented:

    3/18/15, 2:53 PM - I doubt if it'll improve. probably not. but already great. better nose then the 2000 vintage, but inferior on the palate as the 2000 is more complex.

Red
2006 Domaine Drouhin-Laroze Chambertin-Clos de Bèze Chambertin-Clos de Bèze Grand Cru Pinot Noir
9/7/2013 - RobSchu Does not like this wine:
70 points
Anyone who rates this above 70 has tasting issues. I was gifted a $1,200 dinner and this was the wine served for appetizers. There was no nose and a sharp tannic finnish. After it breathed, there was NO taste whatsoever. After you swallow, the finish was non-existent. For such an amazing meal I was very disappointed. If you want a great Pinot, stick to the Willamette, not France.
  • Yagil commented:

    12/29/14, 2:40 AM - could it be a flawed bottle?

Red
2006 Golan Heights Winery Pinot Noir Yarden
4/2/2011 - David Paris (dbp) wrote:
85 points
Pinot Noirs from Around The World (BLIND!): Strange macerated berry component... this smells like Pinot Noir a few days into fermentation. Weird. I also get this strange honey covered barn aroma. Really funky and different. This doesn't even smell like wine to me, really... it smells more like a honey or woody maple syrup. I also got this menthol aroma on the night off that has fully disappeared the next day. Really big and fruity on the palate; more like fruit jam than wine. Really large in scale, with some funky hay covered in strawberry glaze and seaweed. Tannins build, but the 14.5% alcohol isn't all that intrusive. Lots of caramel here too. Wow, the finish initially attacks with a surprising caramel apple component. Pretty sweet throughout, I bet that this wine has some residual sugar. An interesting wine, but a strange wine. Definitely not what I would reach for when I wanted a nice contemplative Pinot Noir... it feels more like desert. * Leslie likes this.
  • Yagil commented:

    10/11/14, 6:18 AM - Hello,
    IMHO, there's no decent Pinot Noir in Israel….
    Bourgogne is my benchmark.
    Never tasted CA PN yet… next month will be the first one...

Red
2006 Margalit Cabernet Sauvignon Special Reserve Kadita Vineyard Galilee
9/29/2009 - RossR wrote:
93 points
Big bold and tannic. Classic cabernet taste & smell. You couldn't mistake it for anything else if you wanted to. I knew I was drinking it too young ... but I've been sitting on it since May. Hot & tight when the bottle was first opened, it really opened up after an hour in the decanter and continued to improve from there. This wine is on par with almost anything I've had from Napa, Sonoma, or France in the price range.

I'll sample my other bottles about 1 a year from here out. I'm expecting further improvement based on what I'm tasting now.
  • Yagil commented:

    9/26/14, 10:41 PM - Hi,

    a good Margalit should be aged for at least 6 years…. and enjoyed until it's 12 years old, generally.

White
2009 Albert Mann Riesling Cuvée Albert Alsace
9/18/2012 - jsna wrote:
80 points
I really am astonished by the other reviews. Maybe I got a bad bottle, but I dont even see the potential....I would not drink again.
Overpriced @$15 IMO.
  • Yagil commented:

    9/26/14, 9:31 PM - if you ever eat bad food in a good-reputation restaurant - would you stop eating in this restaurant?! or ask to replace your plate?

    give this wine another chance. better if you can visit this winery and get to know the person and the wines.

Red
2007 Domaine de la Janasse Châteauneuf-du-Pape Vieilles Vignes Red Rhone Blend
9/16/2014 - Yagil wrote:
97 points
2007 Chateauneuf du Pape casting - high-level wines (Osteria da Fiorella, Tel Aviv): double decanted 2 hours before
perfect at opening, but some minor deterioration within 2-3 hours.
(happened twice with the 2005 vintage till the wine wasn't drinkable)
dark opaque purple
intense aroma of black cherry, earth, animal, pepper, spice and a touch of oak-vanilla
full bodied, rich, thick, intense, mouth filling and rich array of flavours
dominant finish with structured fleshy ripe cherries
  • Yagil commented:

    9/25/14, 7:19 PM - Hello _Xenon

    Well, in the Janasse this is not the case. We used Coravin to take 1/3 of the wine out of the bottle - and it was immediately undrinkable.
    It happened also with 2 bottles of 2001 Beaucastel CDP during the last 12 months.

    I love CDP, visited there few times, but those recent unpleasant events make you feel strange about this appellation, sometimes.

Red
2007 Domaine de la Janasse Châteauneuf-du-Pape Cuvée Chaupin Grenache
9/9/2014 - la turque wrote:
94 points
Sept. 9 League of Gentlemen Tasting chez moi: Oh my goodness! Big fruit, lots of jammy tones, tons of texture and taste. Many thought this was from the New World. Incredible extraction. The sweetness of fruit makes it a pleasure to drink now, but the wine has the oomph to last a good many years and develop greater depth, layers and complexity.
  • Yagil commented:

    9/14/14, 7:20 AM - hello,

    why not write a TASTING STORY and include all these wines you tasted above, instead of putting it in a TASTING NOTE?

  • Yagil commented:

    9/17/14, 7:27 AM - I fully agree with you.
    And the TASTING STROY enables you the ideal space for this, so that viewers watching your TN can browse your TASTING STROY.

    But when one is interested at a specific wine TN and encounters your TASTING STROY in it, he's most likely to skip it and avoid the tedious task of finding the required line in the long text.

    So it's a lose-lose situation.

    The proof to this is that you're the only one so far that wrote a TS in a TN…

Red
2006 Louis Jadot Nuits St. Georges Pinot Noir
In a nice place now, fruit is still deep and there is some chewiness left but overall is drinking nicely. Not a great representation of terroir - guessing it is a blend based on my limited burgundy knowledge - but it could be interesting given another five years to allow the primary flavors to peel back. Right now there is mostly grilled meat and cherries but I wouldn't be surprised if some deeper masculine notes would be revealed in time ( coffee grounds, cigar ash, etc).
  • Yagil commented:

    4/21/14, 9:39 AM - Hi,

    What did you mean by "guessing it is a blend"? of parcels?
    In Burgundy all red are 100% Pinot Noir...

  • Yagil commented:

    4/22/14, 11:14 PM - isn't this obvious?!
    IMHO it goes without saying - since according to the label it's a regional wine (of Nuits Saints Georges appellation) as there's no specific vineyard mentioned on the label.

  • Yagil commented:

    4/23/14, 7:40 AM - Not at all. I agree with you 100%.
    Your comment is aimed at the connoisseurs, not the crowd!
    I my self enjoyed the 2004 Leroy Bourgogne which included their Grand Cru and 1er Cru of that vintage, for reasons you're probably familiar with...

1 - 50 of 58
More results
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close