• yaCellar Likes this wine: 93 points

    September 8, 2019 - Was fortunate to get this aged bottle at auction at a great price. My first Broken Stones. Age has softened the tannins to nice velvet and has likely taken (only) some edge off the rich Paso fruit, mostly from James Berry. I don’t detect much in the way of secondary/tertiary notes. That, and given a strong acid backbone, I venture this is only middle aged.

    1 person found this helpful Comment
  • Cailles wrote: 93 points

    July 13, 2019 - Saxum Tasting (Zurich): Comprehensive vertical tasting of several Saxum vineyards and a total of 24 wines. Most wines on a good to very good level in the 93 to 95 points range, just one on an exceptional (97+ points) level (James Berry Bone Rock 08). The consistency of the wine-making at Saxum is impressive but the tasting proofed to be rather a bit boring with less difference between the vineyards and vintages showing than expected and wished for. Heart Stone stood out a bit (bigger vats used, little new oak) thanks to more terroir expression. James Berry (mostly Grenache) and James Berry Bone Rock (elevated complexity and sexiness) were great. Best vintage (we tried wines from 2003 to 2011) is clearly the 2007 which produced the wines with the most depth.

    TN: This was the weakest Broken Stones wine, although all are in a fairly 93 to 95 point range (with two bad bottle 05/03). It showed a bit heat on the nose along rather thick black fruit on the nose and more sweet red fruit on the palate. Like almost all Broken Stones wines it showed almost no minerality/earthy component, little terroir expression. Medium- complexity, medium length, good balance and a soft and harmonious structural frame. Not decanted, no decant needed.

    Comment
  • Rockyii Likes this wine: 94 points

    June 28, 2019 - Popped and poured before dinner at Coste de Este in Vero Beach. Deep opaque purple with a magenta rim. I’ve been drinking roses lately and this a wonderful reminder of the type of big flavored red wines that make me a wine lover. Taste of blackberries, blueberries, licorice, cedar and slate. Really nice integrated tannins give it a pleasant dryness. A little sweet dates and raisins on the finish. Full bodied. Really nice.

    Comment
  • sirpat007 wrote: 93 points

    June 22, 2019 - Grand Saxum Tasting (Gustav in Zurich): Grand Saxum tasting over several vineyeards and vintages. 23 wines in total. What was remarkable is the consistancy in aromatics across vintages and partly also across vineyards. Big and powerful wines but not without elegance. As a vintage 2007 stood out as exceptional across all vineyards. Booker stood out as the most consistent on a high level while James Berry vineyards had the highest range, but was oustanding in some vintages. The top wines for me were 2008 Bone Rock and Booker 2007.

    Tasting note:
    Jammy red fruit, sweet spices and a herbal touch here and there. Firm and tight structure with a full body and med+ finish. Balance improving from 2010/11 but tannins still with grip.

    2 people found this helpful Comment
  • markcic Likes this wine: 94 points

    April 22, 2019 - Well my 91 days of self imposed abstinence has come to an end (it also helped bring about an 18.5 pound weight loss and some awesome results on my annual blood tests). I chose the 2009 Broken Stones as the last bottle I drank before sobriety was the 2011 Broken Stones. It has been a couple of years since I drank a bottle so I slow ox'd for 8 hours. The nose was dark fruit and hints of chocolate. The palate was dark plums, mahogany, some barnyard, a hint of licorice and a touch of spice. The finish as with most Saxums just goes on forever. Its good to be back.

    2 people found this helpful Comments (1)
  • mdvillaverde Likes this wine: 94 points

    March 11, 2019 - 60% Syrah, 20% Mourvèdre, 12% Petite Sirah, 8% Grenache. The Petite Sirah in this wine gives it power and a concentrated mouthfeel. It's full bodied an rich. If you're not looking for a fruit forward wine, this is not for you. Blackberry and cherry notes. Mildly floral on the finish, as you often find in Paso GSMs. Has a fleshy nose. I had this as a PnP and that wasn't an issue.

    1 person found this helpful Comment
  • jshufelt wrote: 90 points

    January 13, 2019 - Consistent with previous tasting notes.

    Comment
  • galewskj wrote: 90 points

    December 8, 2018 - Luis' "Bring a very good bottle" event: Decanted 1.5 hours and served fairly cold on purpose. I think the wine was better cold, because this is a monster wine and it is not that balanced. It is hard not to be impressed by the fruit, chocolate and earth on the nose and palate. Hate to say it, but the nose leaps out of the glass. I didn't find this jammy, just heavy. The lack of acid or any balancing flavor is apparent. I find it humorous that this is called Broken Stones and lacks minerality. I'll just have to say "Different strokes" and I can understand if others are impressed by its richness.

    1 person found this helpful Comment
  • rocknroller wrote: 91 points

    December 6, 2018 - Mixed Wines at Tilia (Tilia, Mpls): This was cold on serving and it did evolve as it warmed, but it was slowly. Some earth, deep and volatile, bold, blackberry, black currant. The palate is full bodied, big and concentrated, pepper, red velvet cake, ripe and lush black fruits huge pepper and spice. I don't get the fuss but it's not really my style, but obviously others love this.

    Comment
  • bobvictor Likes this wine: 94 points

    November 29, 2018 - Really great! Excellent rich flavor and complexity with a delightfully interesting and long finish. Cedar, blackberry, licorice, all very intense. I expected it to not be ready to drink and was surprised by how approachable it was, though for sure has a long rich life ahead.

    1 person found this helpful Comment