• JM_MadTown Likes this wine: 88 points

    February 28, 2015 - Just like my last experience with this wine a few months ago, the nose has expressive notes of Grenache and garrigue. On the palate continues with garrigue, sage, kirsch and worn saddle leather. The fruit is definitely fading, so I would recommend not waiting too much longer to drink these.

    Comment
  • JM_MadTown Likes this wine: 88 points

    September 13, 2014 - It has been a long time since I pulled a cork on this vintage, but I was actually pleasantly surprised. At 19 years old, it does need to be consumed.

    It has a pretty light red color with an orange rim. Notes of kirsch define the nose. On the palate, the fruit has definitely faded, but still you get the typical kirsch, garrigue, and tapenade. It has a fairly long finish. Very nice, but if you have several or more bottles of this vintage, then I would recommend that you pull some corks.

    Comment
  • Brad L wrote:

    October 23, 2010 - Non NBI cuvee, didn't write down importer. Thought I'd just check in on a 95 CNP and this bottle confirmed they are not ready. Perhaps the most long haul vintage since the 80s. Enjoyable, but still quite structured and angular. I would hold, for sure.

    Comment
  • Goldstone wrote: 85 points

    November 3, 2009 - Ch. Clos du Mont-Olivet, Chateauneuf-du-Pape Dinner (The Conrad Hotel, Hong Kong): Light translucent red colour. An attractive touch of sweat and undergrowth on the nose but not much fruit. Distinct nicotine on the front palate turning into nice cherry stone fruit in the mid-palate but finishes on a harsh tannic note. Not much length. Disappointing.

    Comment
  • Dave Dalluge wrote: 90 points

    July 24, 2009 - No notes taken, but this was the best bottle yet. The overall experience was consistent with my last note but this bottle just seemed more complete in every way.

    Comment
  • salil wrote: flawed

    October 23, 2008 - Corked. Not horribly corked, but a little bit is too much here. There's some red fruit, earth and some dried herbs underneath the wet cardboard/newspaper stink that suggests this would have been a real pleasure if it wasn't for the TCA. Ugh.

    Comment
  • tonyvelebil wrote: 89 points

    September 1, 2008 - 3 1995 Chateauneufs w the Gelbs + Rivers Marie, Kistler and More (Andrew Gelbs House): This was opened at the dinner table b/c we could and we needed to draw down Andrew's cellar. Kirschy, plum/berry fruit, less earthy than the Donjon and very nice drink but not quite up to the level of the Donjon and Cailloux, plus it was getting late.

    Comment
  • Eric wrote: flawed

    October 26, 2007 - Steak night with Scott Manlin (Sammamish, WA): Corked. Sorry Adam.

    Comment
  • Dave Dalluge wrote: 88 points

    December 3, 2006 - Pale red color. The nose gives a distinct but low intensity smell of dark cherry and garrigue. This is a light bodied wine giving earthy cherry, pepper, and garrigue. The finish is slightly acidic and the tannin is fully resolved. Saved most of this for day two, and it improved a little. The color is darker, and the wine is now medium weight. A distinct black olive has been added to the flavors, and the cherry is now earthier and almost liquor-like. This has not changed much since release, but this is the best bottle to date. I will wait to drink the remaining bottles, but this is never going to be an outstanding wine.

    Comment