• maxima wrote: 92 points

    January 4, 2020 - Super beau Bordeaux, sur son plateau,
    il procure du plaisir en ce moment, belle
    bouteille celle-ci fut.
    Du tabac, du cèdre, des fruits rouges et
    de herbes.
    En bouche, belles saveurs de cerises avec un peu
    de cassis, de chocolat et du graphite.
    Tannins bien enrobés et la finale est
    bien longue et tout en souplesse.
    Excellent.

    1 person found this helpful Comment
  • spillwine wrote: 90 points

    June 16, 2019 - 2005 tient ses promesses. Ce vin est un peu lourd et alcoolique, manque d’élégance mais OK quand même

    Comment
  • Oldmanzin Likes this wine: 91 points

    March 11, 2019 - Blue and red fruits are accompanied by a hint of green herbal notes and ever present right bank minreality. After an hour decant the wine opens up nicely. It is still evolving and I see an upside to this wine still. Delightful.

    Comment
  • imcarthur Likes this wine: 92 points

    December 10, 2018 - Drinking well now. Big fruit morphing into mineral. A vg terroir bordeaux.

    Comment
  • Argrath wrote: 90 points

    November 2, 2018 - Medium-fullish nose with plum and ridiculous dill aroma. Very Cab Franc-influenced herbs, green pepper and roots. Too herbal for my taste.
    Fullish, old-school palate that is nice but also a bit robust. Good grip with upside. Spicy, dill oak character. Roots and cabbage hints. Ready.

    Comment
  • collin wrote:

    August 27, 2018 - Not a Bordeaux drinker, but this fit my mood. I thought this was perfectly correct and as good an example of St Emilion I've had in a while. I was also reminded why I rarely drink Bordeaux. I just don't get a lot of pleasure, even when I recognize the quality.

    Comments (1)
  • 1961Vintage Likes this wine: 93 points

    August 26, 2018 - Very enjoyable. Classic well aged St E with several years of high quality life remaining.

    Comment
  • whatdoiknow Likes this wine: 92 points

    June 22, 2018 - Thoroughly enjoying a bottle after decant, and it’s not “thin” at all. Excellent expression of a Grand Cru Classe (and I do taste bell pepper), though I would drink now or in the very near future. To me, this is the difference between the elegance of aged Bordeaux and other stuff.

    Comment
  • khmark7 wrote: 86 points

    April 26, 2018 - Thought this was in decline in 2014 and still feel that way now. Less aromatic today, some pleasant mint & graphite with a palate that doesn't possess any real interesting character. Tannins have mellowed, but there isn't much left behind and the level of ripeness in 2005 didn't allow for any bell pepper, herbs or cedar character so i am less than enamored at this stage.

    Comment
  • Mark216 wrote: 92 points

    April 26, 2018 - Exquisite - perfect time to drink it.