• aquacongas wrote: 92 points

    January 18, 2019 - From Magnum
    Not in perfect condition. Missing length and fruit, but still fresh. 92

  • AB16 Likes this wine: 94 points

    November 29, 2018 - Blake tasting – drunk in magnum format. Nice toast and yeast. A-

  • tinybubbles Likes this wine: 94 points

    July 12, 2018 - From magnum. Softened and elegant with subtle spice. Burgundy-like. 94-95

  • psmith wrote: 96 points

    June 23, 2018 - I liked this more than most people. It's got an incredible level of detail and layering. Old, slightly funky mushroom notes and red cola and orange flavors. Ripe, weighty, and with a fairly subdued mousse at this stage. I could get lost in the nose here, and while it may not have quite the freshness of a '96 from a couple of months back (and certainly doesn't have P2/P3 freshness), I actually prefer this bottle and where it's at.

  • acyso wrote: 93 points

    June 23, 2018 - HDH auction at Spiaggia; 6/22/2018-6/23/2018 (Chicago, IL): Amber in colour. The nose shows a fair bit of bread, as well as a fairly good amount of fruit. Certainly, at this point, this shows a its age, and it's at the tail end of freshness for me. A bready, ripe, and rich profile, with a nice amount of acidity on the back end. It's not as linear and fresh as I'd like, but this is still a very good champagne. (A little sad it isn't as good as I remembered it being from seven years ago, though that taste came from a recent release from magnum.)

  • dream Likes this wine: 94 points

    May 22, 2018 - Good bubbles and intensity here with lovely flavors of red berries and exotic spices. Powerful and rich and showing good succulence on the finish which sports mature autumnal flavors. Really complex and really good. Seems perfect right now.

    1 person found this helpful Comment
  • T.E.D. wrote: 95 points

    May 23, 2017 - My second experience with this wind. Again extremely rich and dynamic, very long finish showing notes of naughtiness, Meleney and Berry, Long toasty least.

  • jhngo Likes this wine: 95 points

    November 24, 2016 - Freshest most alive bottle I've had. It popped when I opened it. Super young crisp with the heft of a rosé. It darkened as it opened and was enjoyable to the last drop. Wow! Stunning

  • ricknat1 wrote: 94 points

    October 14, 2016 - Very fine but I have not come to love Rose's the way I love the other bottlings so I am not the best judge. my 94 may be a rose lovers 98

  • ricknat1 wrote: 93 points

    June 23, 2016 - I much preferred this to the 82 Oen but was not as much in love as others were