• eeeeeradicator wrote: 96 points

    September 17, 2022 - Smooth to a really profound degree. It’s so well integrated that it takes a while to pick apart. Think about the 45+ second finish, though, and you can pry out everything from mint to iron to leather to smoke.

  • A&C Likes this wine: 93 points

    August 13, 2022 - This took a long time to open up. Smooth as silk. Fruit was a bit muted until it was open for awhile. I decanted for 2 hours, and it was still a bit tight in the glass. Maybe a higher rating in a few years. I think it still needs some time.

  • wine4ever Likes this wine:

    July 29, 2022 - Amazing...definitely in it's peak window. Smooth, fruity, lots of depth, hint of pepper on the very long finish. No rush to drink but awesome right now.

  • Schiffy Likes this wine: 96 points

    June 17, 2022 - Balanced blackberry and dark cherry fruit perfectly integrated with silky smooth tannins delivering a super smooth, long finish. This Cab is drinking VERY well right now after an hour decant. Nice secondary notes of mocha, currants and lavender. Really good!

  • nzinkgraf wrote:

    June 3, 2022 - a cooler vintage next to 2005 vintage.
    a total left turn from the 2005 fruit dominance. a little swampy. still shows soft to the palate, more savory w/ less fruit.

    neither 05 or 06 shows much color development. i guess when you start out at purple it takes a little longer to meander through ruby and garnet on the way to browning. No brown on either rim, but yes to garnet color.

    06 still shows the barrel spice w/out the wild blackberry fruit of 05.

    06 with more air becomes less savory over the course of the lunch. comes closer to the 05, but still with a shy-er fruit profile.

    again 97% Cab w/ 3% Merlot. mostly from Champoux with Klipsun and Tapteil.

    1 person found this helpful Comment
  • hkbob Likes this wine: 93 points

    April 9, 2022 - Deep purple. Dark fruited with blackberry, cherry compote, and some distant notes of coffee, licorice and creosote. Dense, mouth-filling palate with dark plummy fruit, some sweetness and a touch of vanilla on the finish. Fully resolved tannins. Not overly complex. Although well-made and a very good wine, to my taste this was more gloss than personality.

  • spendergast Likes this wine: 98 points

    March 8, 2022 - A great cab with dense dark fruit, notes of cassis, black raspberry, spice box with beautifully integrated tannins and long satisfying finish. Still young. Paired perfectly with grilled bistro filets.

  • sfwinelover1 Likes this wine: 98 points

    January 22, 2022 - One off auction buy ($127) 3.5 years ago. On the nose and palate, black cherries, black currants, blackberries, cassis, cigar box, anise, dark chocolate, graphite, pencil shavings and a touch of oak given wonderful backbone by notes of dark roast coffee, tar and bell pepper. Opaque purple, medium to full bodied, thick legs. Medium+ tannins which integrated with air, medium- well-integrated acidity, a touch of heat on opening. Outstanding complexity, VG+ intensity, off the charts persistence. This wine tumbled out of the bottle big and a bit disjointed with a bit of booziness and unwieldy tannins, but it was immediately clear that this was a case of when, not if, it would be stellar. It took about 2-2.5 hours for this to hit its best stride, at least for my tastes, at which point it became not just a wine of great power, but great beauty and deceptive subtlety. At that point, the wine was so good, I recorked it, although I often leave the bottle open for an hour or two when I’m having a second glass; consistent notes on night 2. Equally stunning on its own and with spicy chicken-basil-feta orzo night 1, deep dish pizza on night 2. Youthful and muscular yet displaying impeccable balance, this wine with the decant is in a great drinking window, probably unlikely to improve, but almost certain to hold here for 8-10+ years if well-stored. This is my second QC—I had a young Palengat with A_M, and I have a young Galitzine in my collection—and it exceeded my high expectations in every way, the best of a strong, growing number of WA wines I’ve had in the past couple of years, and drinking more from WA is right at the top of my wine NY’s resolutions. As I commented with a similarly scored, slightly more expensive ‘08 Ovid, it may be the height of Bay Area upper middle class privilege, but in the premium wine category, this constitutes compelling value. Just a touch more concentration, which is in no way remotely deficient, and this wine would flirt with perfection; instead, it will have to settle for magnificence. I’m a buyer at or around this price for any of the 3 premiere bottlings in good vintages. Pro scores more accurate than those on CT, IMO. 98+

  • dsimmons Likes this wine:

    December 25, 2021 - Shared with friends on Xmas eve. Great wine drunk with prime rib roast.

  • VINNICK Likes this wine: 94 points

    December 5, 2021 - Great wine. Beautiful depth and concentration. Such a great winery.