• By Antonio Galloni
  Spirits: The Tip of the Iceberg (Dec 2022), 12/1/2022, (See more on Vinous...)

  (NV The Rare Wine Co. Historic Series Madeira New York Malmsey Special Reserve Fortified/spirits) Login and sign up and see review text.

View From the Cellar

• By John Gilman
  Jan/Feb 2014, Issue #49, Madeira- Timeless Island Wines From Just This Side of Paradise

  (NV Rare Wine Company “New York Malmsey” Madeira (2009 Release)) Login and sign up and see review text.

• By Josh Raynolds
  June 2011, (See more on Vinous...)

  (NV The Rare Wine Company Historic Series New York Malmsey Madeira) Login and sign up and see review text.

JancisRobinson.com

• By Richard Hemming, MW
  2/24/2010, (See more on JancisRobinson.com...)

  (NV Barbeito, Malmsey Reserve NV Madeira White) Subscribe to see review text.

For The Love of Port

• By Roy Hersh
  Issue #49, 1/28/2010

  (NV Rare Wine Company Historic Series New York Malmsey Madeira) Subscribe to see review text.

• By Roy Hersh
  February 2008, Issue #30

  (NV Barbeito Malmsey Madeira RWC Historic Series - New York) Subscribe to see review text.

RJonWine.com

• By Richard Jennings
  12/5/2016, (See more on RJonWine.com...) 90 points

  (NV Rare Wine Co. (Vinhos Barbeito) Madeira Historic Series New York Malmsey Special Reserve) Medium brown color; walnut, dried fig, coffee, saline nose; tasty, walnut, dried fig, coffee, saline, coffee syrup palate with balancing acidity; long finish

• By Richard Jennings
  6/12/2012, (See more on RJonWine.com...) 91 points

  (NV Rare Wine Co. (Vinhos Barbeito) Madeira Historic Series New York Malmsey Special Reserve) Very dark orange brown color with ruby lights and yellow meniscus; appealing, praline, toffee nose; very tasty, praline, vaguely saline, toffee palate with good acidity; long finish

• By Richard Jennings
  10/11/2011, (See more on RJonWine.com...) 91 points

  (NV Rare Wine Co. (Vinhos Barbeito) Madeira Historic Series New York Malmsey Special Reserve) Medium brown color with ruby lights and light green meniscus; rich, dates, fresh fig, marmalade nose; rich, silky textured, tart date, coffee, lemon marmalade palate; with good acidity; medium-plus finish 91+ points

Wine Library TV

• By Gary Vaynerchuk
  By Request - Sherry and Madeira Tasting, Episode #964, 1/10/2011, (See more on Wine Library TV...) 93 points

  (The Rare Wine Co New York Malmsey Madeira) #1; COLOR-dark w/ brown edges; NOSE-comes across really earthy and gamey, but also with great caramel and taffy components; PALATE-big fruit; great viscosity; heavy; has a great intensity; this is really nice and gets really serious; really interesting balance; great style; ; WE-93; GV-93