Community Tasting Note
-
3daywinereview.com wrote: 75 points
October 1, 2022 - In-Store Tasting (Some really bad wines) (Bloomington, MN): This stuff is terrible. I hate unoaked Chardonnay. Even if it is neutral oak it adds some complexity. This has some fruit and little else there. A hollow wine.
1 person found this helpful 2,420 views
2 Comments
-
VlgJeff commented:
8/17/23, 1:24 PM - Hi 3 Day: If you hate unoaked Chardonnay, but you thought you'd try a wine store tasting sample (don't we all?) without knowing that it was an unoaked Chardonnay, then please give us your tasting notes. However, would you consider removing your numeric rating as it unfairly skews the wine's overall rating significantly lower than it might otherwise be (?86 - 89?)? Had you known up front that it was an unoaked Chard, you might have passed this wine by.
-
3daywinereview.com commented:
8/17/23, 2:36 PM - In this case no I would not remove. A to Z wines are not like they used to be. All of the wines were tasted in a real stem and because I spit get a proper pour to evaluate the wines. Trust me I would love for everyone to remove their 90 plus points for Caymus wines but that is not going to happen.