Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Madeira in Madeira

Tasted March 15, 2017 - March 20, 2017 by honest bob with 400 views

Introduction

This holiday visit was more about walking, sleeping and chilling out than serious wine-tasting. I visited D'Oliveras twice, where they are a bit surly but – amazingly – allow you to taste anything there (OK, I didn't ask to taste the ancient vintages) and don't charge a penny. Blandy's/Madeira Wine Company have become even more overtly commercial than the last time I was here in 2006: It's all about booking "standard", "premium" etc. tours, none of which actually take you into a vineyard or bring you into contact with a proper winemaker (as opposed to a tour-guide). The serious vintage tasting room (not to be confused with the bulk tasting room where the tours end up) looks just as inviting as it ever did, but charges serious prices (from about 15 EUR for a sip of a 1970s vintage) to taste serious wines. As I wasn't feeling serious, I didn't bother this time.

Flight 1 - D'Oliveiras (8 notes)

Good, if perhaps not great, wines at a keen price. Depressed atmosphere, but once you show you are interested the staff are civil, if not exactly forthcoming. D'Oliveiras bottle from their casks on a running basis, so it is important to check the rear label for the year of bottling – cask time is everything for Madeira, so in 2027, after an additional ten years in cask, the wines I tasted will probably all taste deeper, more complex and intensely acidic than these bottlings will do after a decade in a glass bottle.

White - Fortified
1988 D'Oliveiras Madeira Terrantez Portugal, Madeira
94 points
Tasted at D'Oliveiras, Funchal. Bottled 2015 (the 2016 bottling was also being sold, but was not open to taste). Intense toffee/caramel scent, hints of roasting coffee and creme brulée, utterly pure, no hint of mould or cellar funk. Slender, very acidic entry; the warm, resonant mid-palate comes at you in waves, again a hint of light-roast, acidic coffee. Very long, vibrant finish. Exceptionally fine. 94P
White - Fortified
1988 D'Oliveiras Madeira Terrantez Portugal, Madeira
93 points
Retasted at D'Oliveiras in Funchal. 2015 bottling. Identical impression to 15.02.2017. 93-94P
White - Fortified
1977 D'Oliveiras Madeira Terrantez Portugal, Madeira
88 points
Tasted at D'Oliveiras, Funchal. Bottled in 2013. This smells much "sweeter" than the 1988, and more generically of Madeira, probably because of a heavy veil of cellar funk (old barrels, dust and mould). The entry is full-bodied, sharply acidic and very sweet, but the mid-palate is inexpressive and closed, lacking the resonance of the younger wine. Short to medium, rather monolithic Madeira finish. Perhaps this bottle wasn't in great shape (athough young Madeira is supposed to be indestructable, I suppose there could have been a cork issue?) 88P(?)
White - Fortified
1971 D'Oliveiras Madeira Terrantez Portugal, Madeira
90 points
Tasted at D'Oliveiras, Funchal. Bottled in 2012. As with the 1977, quite some cellar mould on the nose, alleviated in this case by open toffee aromatics and a charming hint of lime zest. Broad, melting entry with an odd, almost medicinal character. The mid-palate is acidic/caramel-dominated. 30-second finish. Sweeter and more concentrated than the 1988, as you'd expect, but lacking its resonance and vibrancy. 90P
White - Fortified
1988 D'Oliveiras Madeira Verdelho Portugal, Madeira
92 points
Tasted at D'Oliveiras, Funchal. Bottled in 2015. Pure dark, almost burnt caramel on the nose; medium-bodied entry with caramelised sugar, burnt almond, highly concentrated; monolithic sweetness. Very long, structured, almost mineral finish. 92P+
White - Fortified
1993 D'Oliveiras Madeira Boal Portugal, Madeira
90 points
Tasted at D'Oliveiras, Funchal. Bottled in 2017. Closed right down, only a hint of dark caramel on the nose. Healthy sweet caramel entry - a sweet, simple. full-bodied, robust Boal, linear to the finish. Very good indeed but not exciting, at least at this early stage of its life. 89-90P
White - Fortified
1994 D'Oliveiras Madeira Malvazia Colheita Portugal, Madeira
90 points
Tasted at D'Oliveiras, Funchal. Bottled in 2017. Utterly pure, but closed-down scent: All I got was caramel fudge. Fat, monolithic entry accompanied by (rather than really harmonizing with) a nervous, intense acidity. Deliciously pudding-like sweet mid-palate; short, utterly pure finish. It would be interesting to compare this 2015 bottling in 2027 with a more recent bottling from the same cask - I suspect this might simply be a case of cradle-robbing. 90P(+)
White - Fortified
1989 D'Oliveiras Madeira Malvazia Reserva Portugal, Madeira
91 points
Tasted at D'Oliveiras, Funchal. Bottled in 2017. Strong dark caramel scent with a powerful acidic (almost vinegar-like) edge. Big fat, pure, monolithic Malvazia, cradle-robbed from the barrel at the tender age of 28. Later bottlings will surely offer more complexity. 90-91P

Flight 2 - Various restaurant meals (5 notes)

We ate very well indeed at Gaviao Novo (twice), which has a good and keenly priced wine list, and even a couple of bottles of Barca Velha on display; decently at Armazem do Sal (twice), where the wine-list is pricey and very patchy, and the "Sommelier" tries to get you to buy his mediocre "special recommendations" (not on the list); acceptably at our lovely hotel (Quinta da Casa Branca) but disgustingly badly at "Boho" bistro, which has the worst wine selection of any restaurant in its price category I can remember eating in, and some very odd food on the menu, all of it sugary sweet or with sugary sauces. I have not recorded about half a dozen dodgy Madeira table wines - all of which were mediocre works in progress (which doesn't mean we didn't pay serious money for them). There may be some glories yet to come, but right now it's probably best – even on the island – to drink Douro and Alvarinho etc. table wines from the mainland with your dinner, keeping proper Madeira for beforehand and dessert.

White
2015 Quinta Nova de Nossa Senhora do Carmo Douro Graínha Reserva Portugal, Douro
90 points
From 75cl. Exciting salty-savoury wine, a blend of vinosinho, gouveio, rabigato and fernão pires (which means no more to me than it probably does to you) with considerable body (14% alc) and minerality but beautifully light with great citric lift. Lovely wine, a perfect match with grilled red snapper at the superb fish restaurant Gaviao Novo in Funchal. Allowing for the restaurant's markup, a real snip at 23,50 EUR. 90P
1 person found this helpful Comment
White
2014 Parras Dão Evidência Branco Portugal, Beiras, Dão
79 points
From 75cl, good cork. The label says that this concoction is made from Encruzado "the most noble white grape of the Dao region". If this is true, then either the Dao region has a problem, or this wine was even more incompetently made than I thought it was while trying to drink it. Oxidised (but not in an exciting way), sweetish, low-acid, a bit cooked - it tastes, in fact, like cheap Southern European whites used to taste 25 years ago. Only this bottle cost 23 EUR (in a dreadful bistro in Funchal called "Boho", where ALL the other whites were either Moscatel-based or Sauvignon Blanc, and each and every dish was sugar-sweet, with reduced balsamic vinegar or sweet brown sauce to add to the pleasure). Avoid. 79P
White - Fortified
N.V. Blandy's Madeira Bual 5 Years Old Medium Rich Portugal, Madeira
86 points
Pleasant enough balance of grapey caramel and acid, but lacking grip, depth and backbone. 85-86P
White - Fortified
N.V. Blandy's Madeira Sercial 5 Years Old Portugal, Madeira
85 points
Mild, moderate and (as others have remarked) almondy, this is not quite as bland as white port, but still far from the edgy glories that Sercial can display. 85P
1 person found this helpful Comment
White
2014 Companhia de Vinhos do Douro Douro Oboé Reserva Branco Portugal, Douro
84 points
From 75cl. Very promising scent of lemon zest and passion fruit (sic); weird and unbalanced palate with strong new oak, low-acid tropical fruit-infused soft white wine (well, if you must, a bit like an overripe Grüner Veltliner blended with a deacidified Mosel Riesling Kabinett); slight bitterness, oak dust and persistent sweetness on the finish. Not my idea of fun, and no bargain at 34 EUR at a restaurant in Funchal. 84P(?)
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close