Important Update From the Founder
Read message >
Elders @ Eric's
Tasted January 30, 2022 by andtheodor with 135 views
Flight 1 (11 notes)
Red
1920 Federico Paternina Rioja Ollauri Gran Reserva Especial
Slightly herbal, green pepper thyme nose. Some dried mint and tobacco emerge. Tannin totally gone but the color is shockingly dark nonetheless. Texture is broad and very soft, with a touch of potpourri and mandarin sweetness on the finish. Not oxidized or funky at all, just completely fanned out and slowly disappearing into the sunset. Hard to score something like this but easy to enjoy and talk about it.
Red
1922 Martinez Lacuesta Reserva Especial
95 points
Raspberry tea, old wood, a touch beefy/savoury, with some bottle stink hanging around. Tender but structured and easily engages with food, a bit of sweet cherry graces the palate. Unlike the 1920 Paternina, this bottle is very much still a wine and flexing some muscle. Saturates and lingers and gets better with air. Stunning!
Red
1954 Marqués de Murrieta Rioja Ygay Reserva
First impression is maderized but there's a lot of intrigue here; tobacco, brown sugar, tangy citrus sweetness. Someone suggested an old Rioja with a splash of Terrantez thrown in and I think that captures it well. FWIW, my note from 10 years ago suggests this is evolving pretty slowly at this point in time: "Caramelly, burnt sugar, madeira-like nose with potpourri and orange peel lending complexity."
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Red
1968 Umberto Fiore Gattinara Spanna Riserva
92 points
From magnum, in top shape. Dark, tarry, minty, serious demeanor with bits of preserved cherry. Would happily follow this for hours on any other night.
Red
1968 Beaulieu Vineyard Burgundy
89 points
Typical Burgundy blend of Gamay and Mondeuse. Happily cruising along, maraschino and dried mint. Clean leather, weird herbal verve, red vines. Good, but unlike anything I can recall tasting.
Red
1968 Federico Paternina Rioja Conde de los Andes Gran Reserva
92 points
Aromas of old wood, pressed roses, cherry and spices. Juicy and tender with a clementine sweetness. Lovely old Rioja.
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Red - Sweet/Dessert
1968 Mayacamas Vineyards Zinfandel Late Harvest
Alcohol, berry pie, eucalyptus, sweetly fruited but no noticeable sugar. Smells like a sticky monster and when the dryness hits you think it's going to wither away but it holds together pretty well and certainly isn't dying. More of a curiosity than a great wine at this point and probably better to have alone instead of a flight of '68s.
2 people found this helpful
Comments (5)
Red - Sweet/Dessert
1993 Ridge Zinfandel Essence
93 points
Smells and tastes like a confiture of flame raisins with some cocoa thrown in. It's delicious and I don't know why these never seem cloying or overdone. One of the most impressive aspects of Draper's touch IMO.
Red - Fortified
1922 Martinez Gassiot & Co. Porto Vintage
93 points
Bottled in 1924. Syrupy, powerful wine with cocoa, cardamom, and star anise on the spicy palate. Clean spirit is hardly noticeable, finishes more bitter than sweet which is tolerable at its age. My favorite of the ports tonight.
Red - Fortified
1968 J.H. Andresen Porto Colheita
90 points
The sweetest of the three ports tonight with a cocoa and toffee drive. I found this slightly muddled and ashy compared to the others though.
Red - Fortified
1968 Krohn Porto Colheita
92 points
The last of 12 wines and my notes have devolved into a few shaky adjectives. Mocha, figs, marvelously aromatic. I really like these old colheitas from Krohn.