Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(6 comments on 6 notes)

1 - 6 of 6 Sort order
Red
2017 Domaine Rossignol Trapet Gevrey-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Pinot Noir
Decent Pinot but lacking expression, punch and weight for a Gevrey Vieilles Vignes. As others have noted, very light in color and rather subdued nose. Nothing wrong here and the balance was very fine - I simply had expected more oomph for the appellation and year.
  • ChâteauneufDuPfaff commented:

    4/23/23, 10:50 PM - I had hoped you were wrong on this but I was very underwhelmed, too. The 18 I had not too long ago was showing much much better.

Orange
2019 Bettina Schumann Grauer Burgunder Dit is der Clou von't Janze Baden
9/17/2022 - Xavier Auerbach wrote:
92 points
A private lunch (Restaurant De Kas *, Amsterdam, NL): Volcanic soils, old vines, low yield, three days of skin contact, spontaneous fermentation and ageing on the full lees in 500 litre oak barrels (1/3 new), 12.5% ABV. Beautifully clean and pure Pinot Gris, excellent varietal expression, glossy fruit with a hint of spice, medium body (12.5 % ABV), refreshing acidity, lovely shape in the mouth, borderline invisible oak, dancing bitters from the skin contact, convincing finale. An expert composition.
  • ChâteauneufDuPfaff commented:

    12/16/22, 2:27 PM - Just had a bottle tonight. I can only echo your description. Wonderful elegance, very well crafted indeed. A positively special Pinot Gris.

Red
2010 Castelgiocondo (Marchesi de' Frescobaldi) Brunello di Montalcino Sangiovese
11/20/2021 - RedBurgundyWine wrote:
88 points
A good tasting wine, but without dimensionality. James Suckling's rating of 97 is absurd. He consistantly over-rates wines to propel his ratings to be used by the trade. Never trust a James Suckling rating on any wine.
  • ChâteauneufDuPfaff commented:

    11/22/21, 1:25 AM - The 2010 Castelgiocondo was even his wine of the year! I have bought a couple as well and would probably score them a little higher than you have but it's certainly not a 97 point wine for me either.

White
2018 Azul Perdido Maresia Canary Islands Listan Blanco, Palomino Fino
9/27/2020 - MaJeKu Likes this wine:
91 points
In der Nase finde ich reife Birne, fast wie aus der Dose, dazu eine sehr kräutrig-florale Note wie von Waldmeister und Löwenzahn und ganz viel Graphit.
Am Gaumen sehr kernig, fast rosiniert, dazu durchaus warm aber keinesfalls breit und dann zieht sich die Graphit-Note durch. Der Wein hat eine hohe innere Spannung und eine ganz toll eingebundene feine Säure.
Fast kaubar im Abgang, da freu ich mich sehr auf die zweite Flasche. Unheimlich gelungener Holzeinsatz!
  • ChâteauneufDuPfaff commented:

    2/26/21, 11:56 AM - Ich habe grade die zweite Flasche aufgemacht (WaL Abo?! ;)) und finde ihn noch ein bisschen schöner als vor einem halben Jahr. Wirklich ein außergewöhnlicher Wein!

White - Off-dry
2007 Joh. Jos. Prüm Wehlener Sonnenuhr Riesling Spätlese Mosel Saar Ruwer
Excellent Spätlese from a prime vineyard from a terrific producer from a very good year. You can't go wrong with this combinaton and the 07 Wehlener Sonnenuhr did not let me down: Amazing (ripe) fruit, nicely dialed-in petrol notes, fabulous acidity and what a finish. Spectacular.
  • ChâteauneufDuPfaff commented:

    10/9/20, 3:58 AM - Unfortunately, I have never had the Auslese in 07 but I believe every word you say. ;)

Red
2016 Chiara Condello Romagna Predappio Riserva Le Lucciole Sangiovese
First time me trying the Tasting Note Assistant ;)

The wine looks ruby colored. The legs are medium. There is no sediment in the bottle. It smells like forest floor, mineral, red currant, cherry, sandalwood, nutmeg and violet. It tastes like cherry, raspberry, red currant, mineral, tobacco and thyme. The body is medium. The wine has smooth texture. The wine finishes medium. The wine has high acidity.

In short: This is an amazing and very elegant Sangiovese that is very much recommended and worth any search. Clear upside potential.
  • ChâteauneufDuPfaff commented:

    10/9/20, 3:04 AM - Thanks for the feedback, I think so too. :) The assistant is way too analytical.

1 - 6 of 6
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close