Lou's
Tasted Wednesday, September 25, 2013 by Loren Sonkin with 626 views
Last night my tasting group met. The rules for this group are $20 to $40 and purchased locally, but we had to spread our base to find enough wines for this theme. There used to be a lot more of these wines available locally than there are now. In addition, I threw in a horizontal of Terre Nere as I had been looking for an opportunity to try these wines blind against each other. The wines were consumed blind (initially) over the course of 3 hours. Breads and cheeses were served.
I was disappointed at first in these wines. I had popped the corks at 4 and we did the flight at 8. The wines showed older and not as powerful. By the end of the night, the three better ones had improved IMO. Some never felt so. Certainly, they behave more like a Barolo in that they are not monster fruit wines despite having tannins. It was a treat to try a Prephyloxera wine, but nothing seemed to stand out about that quality to me. It was the best wine, but not significantly better than the wine half its cost. I am not sure if I would buy any of these again to be honest, but the Guardiola is the most likely for me. Something I would not have said at the end of flight one. Luckily I went back 1.5 hours later. Still, it was a cool, geeky way to taste the wines, so that was fun.
Overall, I was a bit disappointed. I hadn't explored this area in a while, but there used to be good wines at this price range. It would seem that is still true but the better wine have crept (or leapt) past the $40 mark. There is still some value to be found under $20 though.
2010 Calabretta Carricante Sicilia 87 Points
Italy, Sicily, Sicilia
Light golden in color. The nose is vanilla lemon cream sickle. Odd as I doubt this seems any oak at all. Still, very strong flavor. Light to medium bodied. Slightly tinny on the attack. Turns to lemons with a good finish. I wouldn't mind a bit more acidity, but this is nice. My first time trying a Carricante IIRC.
Post a Comment / Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Report Issue