2006 Lillian Winery Syrah

Syrah

alanr wrote: 92 points

April 6, 2010 - Two 2006 Syrahs: Lillian and Relentless: Shows some ripeness on the nose, with a touch of vanilla. Palate is rich, bold, dark fruit, quite lush and forward, but fairly well balanced. More acidity than tannins in structure, with a bit of savory oak on the finish. Very well made and enjoyable for its style, though I don't find any Rhone-ness to the wine as some have described. At 15.6 ABV on the label (and the medium body suggests that it's been watered down by a percent or so as well), with its bright, focused, juicy, lush fruit, I would treat this as an enjoyable cocktail wine.

2 people found this helpful 7,247 views

MarkC commented:

4/8/10, 12:31 PM - Alan--I confess that I love these wines. So my comments are probably biased :-) Your points seem to be higher than I'd guess given your notes :-) I do agree that it doesn't come across as very Rhone-like--I checked all my old notes and the closest to Rhone-like was a reference to a similarity to a Copain wine (which can be somewhat Old World in style to me).
alanr commented:

4/8/10, 9:17 PM - Mark, It's not my personal favorite, but there are lots of folks who love this style, and they should really like this wine, so I try to balance the score with the category the wine falls into, then someone who is looking for that style will hopefully get something good :)
KristianT commented:

4/16/10, 1:32 PM - How do you think this wine will evolve? Does it have the structure to mature further?
alanr commented:

4/16/10, 5:21 PM - Kristian, my personal opinion is that wines made in this riper style don't evolve into anything much more interesting with time. They may soften, but not really improve. I don't think there is a rush to drink it, but I'd suggest opening with the next 2-3 years.