Community Tasting Note

• swade wrote: 73 points

  December 23, 2015 - Plum color. Funk and herbal tea aromas. This enters with a bit of flat filminess. Dark cherry, grip, acid and bone dry. I don't expect the fruit will outlive the structure. Unbalanced. This needs food. Pass.

  3,286 views

3 Comments

• marco_graz commented:

  1/2/16, 1:14 PM - Could be this a corked/overwarmend up bottle? I can't believe you give 73 to a good bottle of this wine/vintage

• swade commented:

  1/2/16, 1:30 PM - I didn't think so, else I have no problem marking it as such. I am a tough grader, but scored per the scale.

• marco_graz commented:

  1/2/16, 1:40 PM - You can be a tough grader, but this it too tough for this wine, not only considering general reviews.
  
  By the way, all other comments on similar grades you gave in the last year are generally worse than this, but you still give it 73.

Add a Comment