Community Tasting Note

• AllRed wrote: 75 points

  November 30, 2019 - Retailer tasting. 2016 base. Dirty. Clay, cotton and apple with a dominant dirty animal fur overtone. Small bead. Light on fruit; short finish.

  3,658 views

4 Comments

• billhike commented:

  12/1/19, 1:44 PM - Interesting - guessing you got a flawed one. We tried it at the Binny’s DG tasting last month and liked it enough to buy three.

• huevosconvino commented:

  12/1/19, 4:50 PM - I agree with the other commenter: I had a lovely bottle of this wine this week. Perhaps the score should be removed?

• AllRed commented:

  12/2/19, 2:24 AM - The bottle was not flawed- it was average at best. Three other tasters liked it better than I did. My opinion is my own. If you like the wine, that's terrific and you should be happy with it. My score is for my palate. The score stands.

• huevosconvino commented:

  12/2/19, 5:31 PM - I'm just suggesting that if you tasted dirty animal fur, perhaps the bottle wasn't representative? You have a terrific history of tasting notes, and I see there are plenty of other times when you decided not to include a score in seemingly similar situations, but it's certainly your choice.

Add a Comment