Year 3 - Super Tasting 1 of 5 - David does Birth Year Wines
Dave's House, Kitchener, ON
Tasted May 23, 2015 by Dave Canada with 444 views
Introduction
I had always liked the idea of doing a dinner where each participant would have the enjoyment of drinking a wine from the year in which they were born so when year three rolled around, I began looking for wines that fit the bill.
Flight 1 - Reception (1 note)
Paired with Brioche Crustini's, Creme Fraiche and Beluga Caviar
The palate is advanced as well with obvious bruised apple notes but augmented with minerals, nutmeg, clove, lemon and hazelnut.
Finish is medium and a somewhat singular. This was much more advanced that I would have expected and given that it came from a great cellar...I would say drink up as this is tiring.
Flight 2 - 1st Course (4 notes)
Paired with Roasted Quail Breast on Confited Quail Leg and Morel Mushrooms in a Madeira reduction
One the palate, you can tell that this is a bit of a leaner year as it is dominated by the ample acidity. The tannins are also a touch austere. The wine is very clean and shows shows tart red fruit, spice, minerals, orange peel and a dominant lactic note but definitely leans to the more rustic side of Burgundy.
The finish is medium with good complexity. Overall, this is a touch disappointing as the nose showed such promise...
Needless to say...the 1970 Palmer did not show up to the party. Nose showed some traces of fruit but this was really over the hill with a dominant metallic note. The palate was thin, metallic and boring....what a waste. DOA
I pulled this to fill in for the previous off bottle assuming that it would provide that classic Rayas profile....this was....interesting.
If you closed your eyes when smelling the wine...you would have assumed you were smelling an ontario Riesling Icewine.....notes of orange peel fresh cut strawberries, flowers, ripe citrus flavours...this was so aromatically intense.
The palate showed similar flavours of incense, saffron, orange peel, strawberry and minerals.
Finish was long and quite complex.
Flight 3 - 2nd Course (6 notes)
Paired with Beef Tenderloin in a red wine reduction
The palate showed a leaner blue fruit profile augmented by classic notes of olive, fat and earth.
Finish was medium with moderate complexity.
The palate was quite complex showing similar characteristic notes of brine, olives, smoked meat and campfire.
Finish was medium+ and quite complex. Pretty wine.
The palate gave the impression that there was still some residual sugar...but the fruit also showed some tart aspects...
Finish was simple
Palate was very lithe....very pure and so integrated. Black and red fruits mix with secondary and tertiary flavours of leather, cedar, earth and forrest floor.
Finish is medium+. Pretty wine.
Flight 4 - Cheese Course (1 note)
Paired with Stilton, St. Agur, Roquefort, apricots, figs, dates, honey, roasted nuts and sourdough.
This was gorgeous...and by far the best 1977 port I have ever had.
Nose was a kaleidoscope of flowers, spice, dark rich fruit, nuts, minerals, figs, spice cake.
Palate was viscous but at the same time very light and elegant....such precision, focus and integration. Myriads of different dark and red fruits mix with a bouquet of flowers and spicy nutty notes.
Finish is long, layered and lush. WOW. Pretty.
Flight 5 - Dessert (0 notes)
Homemade Dark Chocolate Ice Cream
Closing
Overall, not the best showing for birth year wines. Provenance, as always is a key and a few of these bottles illustrated this point in a poignant fashion. No great wines...only great bottles.