Important Update From the Founder
Read message >
Year 3 - Super Tasting 3 of 5 - Chris does Blind Pinot Noir
Dundas, Ontario
Tasted October 24, 2015 by Dave Canada with 400 views
Introduction
Chris came up with the idea of doing a blind tasting of Pinot Noir and sourced a great cross section of vintages, producers and quality levels for this event.
Flight 1 (16 notes)
White
2011 Tawse Chardonnay Quarry Road Vineyard
92 points
Nose is a touch muted on first pour but opens to reveal lemon blossom, lemon custard, minerals, and lime. Some oak notes evident but restrained.
Palate shows applesauce, lemon, minerals, custard and lime and is very mineral driven....acid is high.
Finish is long and quite complex. Great wine.
Palate shows applesauce, lemon, minerals, custard and lime and is very mineral driven....acid is high.
Finish is long and quite complex. Great wine.
White
2010 Louis Jadot Meursault 1er Cru Les Genevrières Domaine Louis Jadot
flawed
This is rich and quite powerful....aromatically intense...lemongrass, candied lemon, white flowers, sulphur and a lactic note...the sulphur really comes out with time.
Palate is rich....obviously from a ripe vintage. Shows tonnes of alcohol and not enough acid....also some oxidative bruised apple notes that really come out with time.....pre-mox in the house.
Palate is rich....obviously from a ripe vintage. Shows tonnes of alcohol and not enough acid....also some oxidative bruised apple notes that really come out with time.....pre-mox in the house.
White
2013 Calera Chardonnay Mount Harlan
92 points
Oak is quite prominent on the nose...ripe lemon, white flowers, lime....oak is there but not obtrusive....quite pretty.
Palate showcases som very ripe fruit bordering on tropical with some peppermint, butter, caramel and lemongrass.
Finish is lone and sweet....quite complex and layered.
Palate showcases som very ripe fruit bordering on tropical with some peppermint, butter, caramel and lemongrass.
Finish is lone and sweet....quite complex and layered.
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Red
1996 Calera Pinot Noir Reed Vineyard
93 points
Loaded with menthol, cherry nibs, red fruit, red flowers and stems.....so many stems!....tart red fruit, minerals, wet soil, leather and tobacco. Pretty
Palate shows cherry pit, stems, cigar undertones, cranberry, minerals, cherry nibs, menthol, red flowers, spice, circus and sour cherry.
Finish is long and layered! Almost 94 points
Palate shows cherry pit, stems, cigar undertones, cranberry, minerals, cherry nibs, menthol, red flowers, spice, circus and sour cherry.
Finish is long and layered! Almost 94 points
Red
1996 Dominique Laurent Morey St. Denis 1er Cru
flawed
This is dirty! Dirt....with some ginger....pickled ginger and tart red fruits. Brett bomb with noticeable VA.
Palate shows moss, earth, prunes and tones of acid.....Heat damage? Clearly not right.
Palate shows moss, earth, prunes and tones of acid.....Heat damage? Clearly not right.
Red
1993 Comte Armand Pommard 1er Cru Clos des Epeneaux
flawed
This was an utter disappointment! Dominated by acetone, sugar and balsamic notes......quite volatile.
Not a right bottle.
Not a right bottle.
Red
1990 Williams Selyem Pinot Noir Olivet Lane Vineyard
97 points
WOW! Such complexity.....this is singular and complex all at the same time. Red flowers, savoury herbs, red fruit, sandalwood, a touch of brett, blood orange, grapefruit and orange peel.
Palate is svelte......cashmere. Pure red fruit that is tart but also so pure and powerful....flowers, candied flowers, herbs, earth. Mouthful is unreal...such texture. Rosewater, sandalwood and spice dominate the transition to a long, long finish. Just awesome! Almost 98pts
Palate is svelte......cashmere. Pure red fruit that is tart but also so pure and powerful....flowers, candied flowers, herbs, earth. Mouthful is unreal...such texture. Rosewater, sandalwood and spice dominate the transition to a long, long finish. Just awesome! Almost 98pts
Red
1999 Chehalem Pinot Noir Rion Reserve
85 points
Peanut shells and quite ripe fruit. Would guess a rhone blend...very little pinot character.
Palate is astringent, course and stewed.
Simple and short
Palate is astringent, course and stewed.
Simple and short
Red
2001 Arcadian Pinot Noir Sleepy Hollow Vineyard
94 points
This is almost classic...
Nose just jumps out of the glass. Tonnes of stem notes augmented by spice, coriander, pickled ginger and soil.
Palate shows bright red fruit, red flowers, spice, clove, pickled ginger and grapefruit.
Finish is long and spicy with gorgeous red fruit.
Nose just jumps out of the glass. Tonnes of stem notes augmented by spice, coriander, pickled ginger and soil.
Palate shows bright red fruit, red flowers, spice, clove, pickled ginger and grapefruit.
Finish is long and spicy with gorgeous red fruit.
Red
2001 Bouchard Père et Fils Corton-Le Corton
89 points
Fruit was quite dark here but also quite simple....some glycerine.
Palate has some pure dense fruit but it is a bit viscous and ultimately forgettable.
Finish is simple and medium in length.
Palate has some pure dense fruit but it is a bit viscous and ultimately forgettable.
Finish is simple and medium in length.
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Red
2002 Domaine du Château de Chorey (Germain) Chorey-les-Beaune
88 points
Nose is quite subdued....with some aggressive swirls you get some mild fruit but overall simple and boring.
Plate shows some candied fruit but does not have sufficient acid and makes this out of balance.
Plate shows some candied fruit but does not have sufficient acid and makes this out of balance.
Red
2002 Mount Eden Vineyards Pinot Noir
92 points
Incense, spice, red fruit, flowers, caramel, resume, sap and stems.
Palate shows pure red fruit, spice, incense, flowers, caramel, leather and great balancing acid.
Finish is long.
Palate shows pure red fruit, spice, incense, flowers, caramel, leather and great balancing acid.
Finish is long.
Red
2002 Louis Jadot Beaune 1er Cru Grèves
87 points
Non descript nose.
Palate is ripe but a touch simple....chaulky and medicinal in nature with some cherry cough syrup.
Finish is simple.
Palate is ripe but a touch simple....chaulky and medicinal in nature with some cherry cough syrup.
Finish is simple.
Red
Red
2004 Rhys Alesia Pinot Noir Chileno Valley
91 points
Gorgeous nose of incense, liquid flowers and tart red fruit.
Palate shows menthol, stems, flowers, citrus and pure red fruit. It needs a bit more acid as it is quite ripe....just a touch out of balance.
Finish is medium
Palate shows menthol, stems, flowers, citrus and pure red fruit. It needs a bit more acid as it is quite ripe....just a touch out of balance.
Finish is medium
Closing
This was unreal....Burgundy was crushed but bottle variation and cork taint took a few burgs that could have really shined. A great night!