Important Update From the Founder
Read message >
Russian River Valley Pinot Noir
Jeffrey's Office - Corona Del Mar, CA
Tasted November 13, 2009 by Paul Lin with 568 views
Introduction
This was a small focused tasting to see how California Pinot Noir, in particular from the Russian River Valley, would present itself with a little bit of bottle age. Based upon this tasting, it seems 5-8 years is the sweet spot for these wines.
All the wines were tasted blind. The Holdredge was voted the winner of the tasting, and it was also my #1 wine. The August West and Siduri came in a close second, with the former being my #2 wine.
Flight 1 (7 notes)
Red
1999 Saxon-Brown Pinot Noir Russian River Valley
85 points
This wine seemed a little past peak to me with madeirized notes of autum leaves, fruit cake, and white cherries. Tart on the palate.
Red
2001 DuMOL Pinot Noir Russian River Valley
87 points
Muscular notes of black cherries, crushed strawberries, red clay, earth, and cola nut. Full-bodied and meaty on the palate with a touch of heat on the finish. 87-88 points.
Red
2001 Aubin Cellars Pinot Noir Verve Russian River Valley
90 points
Mature notes reduced cherries, cherry liqueur, mushrooms, and forest floor. Nice texture on the palate with a soft feathery finish. I cannot see this wine getting any better, so drink up.
Red
2003 Siduri Pinot Noir Keefer Ranch Vineyard
89 points
Rich aromas of black cherries, cinnamon, and clove. Opulent on the palate with sweet notes of plum, blueberries, and cherry liqueur. Still has a long life ahead of it. 89-90 points.
Red
2004 August West Pinot Noir Graham Family Vineyard
91 points
The aromas leap out of the glass with notes of ripe cherries, black raspberries, crushed strawberries, and candied orange peel. Robust and persistent on the palate with layers of fruit and finishing a hint of cola. My #2 wine of the tasting.
Red
2004 Holdredge Pinot Noir Wren Hop
91 points
Initially tight and funky, but with time and air this wine really opened up like a flower in bloom. Slightly sherried notes of dried flowers, dried orange peel, and cranberries followed an elegant, balanced palate and mineral-laced finished. Quite a contrast from the August West, which I enjoyed very much, but in the end its subtle and feminine expression edged out the aforementioned as my #1 wine of the tasting. 91-92 points.