Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(7 comments on 7 notes)

1 - 7 of 7 Sort order
Red
2015 Sottimano Langhe Nebbiolo Langhe DOC
6/22/2020 - Derek Darth Taster wrote:
89 points
At home. Late night after blackout. Drank in Gabriel Standart.
Appearance is clear, pale intensity, ruby colour. Legs.
Nose is clean medium+ intensity, initial reduction stink blew off, showing aromas of violets, sweet tar, sour red cherries, fresh red plum. Youthful.
On the palate, dry, high acidity, medium+ alcohol (14%), sticky high tannins, medium+ body. Medium+ flavour intensity, with flavours of sour red cherries, raspberries, sweet red plum, herbal thyme and mint, licorice, bitter-sweet tar earth towards the finish. Medium finish.
Good quality. Nothing really profound here. Balance not quite achieved in these young vines yet. Tannins stick out, fruits present but not enough depth of substance, and that bitterness going to the finish. Then with air, this actually improves up. Tannins still prominent, but the rest of the palate seems to integrate into a more wholesome picture. May be this wine could actually surprise a little over the next 3+ years of age.
15 year old young vines from the Basarin cru in the commune of Neive.
  • fhayek commented:

    9/17/22, 11:30 AM - great wine description

Red
2017 Friedrich Becker Becker Family Pinot Noir Pfalz Spätburgunder, Pinot Noir
9/18/2021 - Vera Wind Likes this wine:
80 points
Lovely Pinot noir, as usual.
  • fhayek commented:

    10/29/21, 8:31 AM - Why 80p, if lovely?
    80p means a poor wine.

Red
2015 Franco Molino Barbera d'Alba Superiore
3/20/2020 - fhayek wrote:
88 points
Diffcult one to rate for me. 21 EUR at German wine merchant.

Scent: like a good Bordeaux. Underwood, cigar box, chestnut even.

Taste: A lot of (quality) wood. It has depth, intensity, structure. So spicy it reminds me actually of a certain style of shiraz. The aftertaste is so polished it's almost lame a bit, very soft on the back.

Have been drinking quite a lot of it now but still don't know if I like it that much. On one hand, it ticks a lot of boxes and a certain quality is undeniable. On the other, it relies a bit too much on the oak and I'm not sure Barbera is supposed to taste like this.

I might be wrong here but it feels like this is an attempt - not a bad one - to produce a kind of generic prestige wine for those who are accustomed to new world wines.

All in all, I guess this will be very satisfying to non-nerds and new-world fans. The rest might feel 21 EUR is too much for it.
  • fhayek commented:

    4/4/20, 9:23 AM - Is is worth to wait with it?
    I'm not sure to be honest, I don't have much experience with the aging of barberas.
    If I had to provide an answer, I would probably say I would not wait with it, simply because it does not display any 'young' characteristic and because typically one needs acidity for a wine to improve with age, which this wine does not have a lot of. But it's just a guess.

White
2014 von Winning Deidesheimer Kalkofen Riesling Großes Gewächs Pfalz
10/13/2016 - fhayek Does not like this wine:
78 points
Tried this in a wine bar after 6 red wines, which might have blurred my palate.

Anyway, this stroke me as off-balance, unfocussed and also with pronounced volatile acid problems. So no thumbs up there.
  • fhayek commented:

    3/3/17, 7:17 AM - Doni Bertolami, you're right, of course von Winning is Pfalz and not Rheinhessen. Apologies.

    I have to say however that being a member of VDP and having long traditions is in no way a guarantee for quality. And obviously tasting a 2014 GG in 2016 is not the optimal timing but there are many other 2014 GGs that taste terrific already today.

    Thanks for the comment / correction anyway.

White
2011 Martin Müllen Trarbacher Hühnerberg Riesling Spätlese * trocken "Alt und Jung" Mosel Saar Ruwer
6/14/2015 - Vertigo wrote:
88 points
This bottle was nothing compared to my last bottle which was a great positive surprise. This time the wine was very powerful but more one-dimensional. Bottle variation???
  • fhayek commented:

    10/6/15, 8:25 AM - I have found bottle variation to be quite significant with Martin Müllen's wines in general.

White
2014 von Winning Sauvignon Blanc II Pfalz
Grassy nose
GRassy lean style, ripe fruit but light
Elegant, a wine which becomes more interesting with each sip
Good stuff, not cheap £16.95
  • fhayek commented:

    10/4/15, 6:41 AM - Sure you had the '2'? That costs 11 eur in Germany and '1' costs 17-18 eur.

Red
2001 Uccelliera Brunello di Montalcino Sangiovese
10/18/2012 - fhayek wrote:
82 points
40 euros (ouch!).
And... well past its prime. Nothing disturbing there but rather hollow.
  • fhayek commented:

    1/4/13, 7:57 AM - Hi, no it wasn't flawed, it was just a rusty empty shell. Possible of course that it wasn't stored properly although I bought it from a small, professional wine merchant. Certainly I won't spend another 40 EUR to find out!

1 - 7 of 7
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close