Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Tasting Notes for Paul from the Oblong Table

(1,260 notes on 541 wines)

1 - 50 of 1,260 Sort order
Red
Possibly the best bottle that I will ever have. Given to me by my daughter-in-law Carmela Westle (OBM) a number of years ago. The bottle on this Special Occasion brought back many wonderful memories.
3 people found this helpful Comment
Red
10/19/2023 - Paul from the Oblong Table wrote:
90 points
Love jt, love it, love it.
Red
It was a good drink, maybe past it"s time.
Red
The 2312 is still drinking GREAT.
I will share the first time that it deviates. PRW
Red
I'm not selling myself as the expert, but these bottles are the best of the best (for the money).
For what I'm willing to spend I can't imaging ever getting a better bottle.
PRW
Red
the minute that the bottle was opened the aroma filled the room.
Color, fruit and the lingering effect made the not-so-fancy meal great.
Red
The longer it sleeps (and is rested) the better the bottle when consumed.
Red
A winner, is a winner, is a winner. Color, texture, flavor, and lasting lingering effect makes an almost PERFECT bottle.
Red
Great bottle.
Everything that you would expect to find in an expensive bottle. wonderful bouquet, dark fruit, and a great linger on the tongue.
A better bottle won't be found for the price.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
My opinion...each bottle gets better with age.
Red
WE both love and appreciate this bottle for every day drinking.
2 people found this helpful Comment
Red
ABSOLUTELY DYN-O-MITE,
As these bottles are aging, they are getting better each month.
Red
2018 is just as good as ever. thank you CB.
Red
This bottle had an 'opening act', a thermos of Espresso Martinis followed by a wonderful dinner, and excellent conversation.
Red
Unbelievable, month after month it is getting better--and yet the drink date says different?????
Red
ABSOLUTELY, ABSOLUTELY one of the finest bottles I/we ever consumed. It was a simple Italian meal but the bottles made it so much better.
Thank goodness that I found more bottles.
Red
LOVED it with a plain Italian dinner.
Red
Always a satisfying bottle--and we keep on buying it.
Red
Almost on a level with GREAT. A bottle like this you can drink every night.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
GREAT every day bottle.
Red
Opps! The label must have fallen off the bottle.
This homemade vintage is always something special. We have many amateur's, professionals, almost professionals, and other who have an opinion that have a vested interest in making the best wine. This is my tasting of bottle No. 1----and it is outstanding.
Red
We had dinner w/Richard, preceded by Watermelon Martinis.
Both beverages were over the top--isn't life a blast!!!
Red
Never a doubt--drinking better than the Winemaker expected.
Red
ALWAYS GREAT! I just wanted a great bottle for my wife and I tonight. Life's too short to be leaving all of the good stuff for my Shiva.
Red
Why is the last bottle always the best?
Because there's no more left at the vineyard...
Red
the latest delivery was as good as ever; color, taste, fruit and bouquet. AND PLENTY OF LIFE.
Red
Dark, fruity, tasteful, and always a good drink.
Red
Great every night wine.
Red
4/28/2023 - Paul from the Oblong Table wrote:
91 points
You have heard of finger licking good--this bottle was tongue licking good.
From the first sip, the bottle was that enjoyable.
Rosé
Very good for its age. It came in handy just where it was needed.
Red
...always a great drink, and always consistent.
Red
First, it tasted like it cost a lot more. it was not the darkest color previously seen in an Amorone, but the aroma, blended fruits, and lingering taste made this bottle a RE-BUY.
Red
This was the last of the "Mohicans", and yes I'll see if there is more...
1 - 50 of 1,260
More results
  • Tasting Notes: 1,260 notes on 541 wines
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close