12/15/23, 5:29 AM - 3 day wine review: I think flawed best describes a single bad bottle, not 3. I was on the PAX mailing list in the mid 2000’s and know what good wine he can make and has made. My review was perhaps harsh but was driven by frustration and disappointment based on long experience and prior satisfaction. There are numerous other negative comments regarding this wine / vintage. So cool your jets, Junior Jeb Dunnuck and understand this not the wine spectator and you are not Robert Parker. I hope YOU enjoy your next bottle of the Prisoner.
12/19/23, 6:14 PM - Ok, 3daywinereview, I will try to take CellarTracker reviews more seriously. But reread my comment- I was expecting much more from a winemaker whose wines I’ve liked in the past. I literally poured out three bottles. And while 50 is low, your review at 95 points day 1 and, in your words 50 day 3, suggests I might not be far off. In general I think wine scoring is overinflated and is in reality maybe a 20 point scoring system. I used 50 to make a point, and it was done in the heat of disappointment. I apologize.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search