4/18/24, 6:37 PM - Thank you for this detailed review. You nailed it.
6/11/23, 5:31 PM - I tend to agree with you. The bottle I had last night seemed simply compared with previous bottles.
5/8/23, 7:31 PM - My recent experience was aligned with yours.
10/26/22, 6:26 PM - Green. Acidic. Ugh
10/28/22, 3:58 AM - Decanting Queen - I posted this shortly after opening the bottle on October 26.
6/19/22, 7:41 PM - Agree with your comment but I'm not sure that this is a storage condition issue. My 2011 has been stored at a consistent 58 degrees. FWIW it reminds me of a lightweight Amarone.
8/8/21, 11:42 AM - Sorry to hear that your experience across all 4 bottles so far has been awful. Back in February, I emailed Garagiste about this wine - highlighting all the notes and my own experience. I concluded my email as follows: "I've been a member of Garagiste for a long time and purchase a lot of wine from you all. I've never encountered a wine that deviated so much from what was stated in Jon's notes. Is this really the same wine that Jon tasted?"I plan on sending a summary of the 6 bottles after I open my last one.
7/19/21, 3:57 AM - I noticed that my tasting note had a 93 rating - not sure how this happened. Removed the rating. It's certainly not a 93 point wine but at least bottles 2 and 3 have been enjoyable.
2/19/21, 8:54 AM - Or some kind of classic French Chicken with Vinegar saute. This wine is so far off that I'm tempted to send Garagiste an email. I've ordered other natural wines from Garagiste before and sometimes they are quirky but never have I had one that deviated from the description so greatly.
8/12/20, 2:59 PM - Last Bottle - they were very accommodating when I sent them an email expressing my disappointment that both bottles were bad.
6/28/19, 6:42 PM - Thank you for posting such detailed notes on your vertical tasting.
1/13/18, 4:22 PM - I had the same issue with cork.
7/4/16, 12:11 PM - Just saw your review. I paid a little over $11 for this. Definitely good value at that price.
12/6/15, 6:32 PM - My notes are similar even down to the possibility of a corked bottle. I wonder if there's a bad batch of corks here. I have had other vintages of this wine and this vintage's profile is a bit different and not in a good way.
5/31/15, 5:58 AM - I was a member of the wine club for about a year and a half but discontinued. Not my style I guess.
4/29/12, 5:47 PM - Placing a score on a wine after letting it sit 5 days in an open state is misleading. You should eliminate the score so that others are not deterred from purchasing this wine based upon an aggregate score.
10/18/11, 6:57 PM - My tasting notes would mirror Michael's. Don't think I would buy again though.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search