Saturday, January 16, 2016 - Popped corks, drank over 3 hours. Both very good, '08 insignia a little darker fruit profile w better cut, sharper & shorter (but better) finish, whereas '08 Seavey a little more sweet, w baking spices and a more mellow long finish. Both 94 pts. Slight edge to insignia to my palate for fruit profile. Drink or hold 5+ yrs
(Night two- phelps a little flat, Seaver tasted better)