samatoid

Member #259,891 signed up 10/5/2012

Fans(2)

  1. talbot61

    talbot61

    1,106 Tasting Notes

  2. photo

    BadaBingAgain

    7 Tasting Notes

Member since October 2012

This member's profile is not public.

View all 35 Tasting Notes

Message Board Post Public Message

  • samatoid says:

    7/9/2019 1:53:00 PM - Hi Vintage1949, I would be vintage1957. Though I agree with Jeff's description in its current state, I would not expect this wine to improve a great deal. I have tried it a few times on the second day and each time came away disappointed. Oxidized. It is a young flashy modern styled wine w/o alot of complexity at this point. I fear that once it looses its fruit it will suffer. It is a little bit of fun to drink, but not like I remember having some other similarly priced wine (like 1985 Lynch Bages) in its youth and loving it - that and 1984 Dunn Napa vineyard made me realize I love wine. Malescot 1985 isnt going to be that kind of experience for most people.

  • vintage1949 says:

    7/9/2019 12:44:00 PM - Greetings-Was reading your comments under 2016 Château Malescot St. Exupéry. Is this a wine that is-I hate to say it-good enough to enjoy? I love the aspects of tobacco and fruit. To be candid I buy wines in the $150 to $250 range. This is only done with a lot of research. However I have had wines given to me as gifts that were excellent in this price range. Looking forward to hearing from you. Note: I can only by a case of the 2016. Dave

×
×