Important Update From the Founder
Read message >
Maverick Wine Co.'s Grand Tour 2011
OneSixtyBlue, Chicago IL
Tasted September 12, 2011 by KeithAkers with 874 views
Flight 1 - Piedmont (5 notes)
Red
2005 Produttori del Barbaresco Barbaresco Riserva Ovello
92 points
nose: lovely and perfumed nose of roasted herbs, dark red cherries, tar, red fruits and a touch of floral tones. On the understated side and very elegant
taste: medium bodied with medium/high acidity and chewy tannins that show off the youth of the wine. Balanced and elegant tones of roasted herbs, dark red cherries, tar and some bits of red fruits blend together behind the acid and tannins
overall: clearly a young barbaresco. This is quite lovely though with a more feminine side that will certainly take some time to fully coax out
taste: medium bodied with medium/high acidity and chewy tannins that show off the youth of the wine. Balanced and elegant tones of roasted herbs, dark red cherries, tar and some bits of red fruits blend together behind the acid and tannins
overall: clearly a young barbaresco. This is quite lovely though with a more feminine side that will certainly take some time to fully coax out
Red
2004 Damilano Barolo Cannubi
91 points
nose: tight, but showing a lot of class with lovely tones of dark red fruits, herbs, dark red cherries and strawberry tones. Good depth showing through the tightness right now
taste: medium bodied with chewy tannins and medium/high acidity. The acidity is definitely overbearing right now and showing the youth along with pretty tones of dark red fruits, tar, herbs, and dark red cherries with a touch of roasted herbs
overall: Certainly in need of time. While it wasn't shut down, it wasn't completely giving either. There's a real lovely barolo waiting to come out
taste: medium bodied with chewy tannins and medium/high acidity. The acidity is definitely overbearing right now and showing the youth along with pretty tones of dark red fruits, tar, herbs, and dark red cherries with a touch of roasted herbs
overall: Certainly in need of time. While it wasn't shut down, it wasn't completely giving either. There's a real lovely barolo waiting to come out
Red
2005 Damilano Barolo Lecinquevigne
88 points
nose: pretty and aromatic with lovely tones of red fruits, berries, strawberries and roasted herb tones. Good tones, but lacking depth
taste: elegant and feminine medium body with medium+ acidity with nice tones of red fruits, strawberries, and roasted herbs. The tannins are there, but aren't that rough for a young barolo
overall: this is nice, but lacking the depth that you want from a barolo. Good complexity on both the nose and palate, but it's hard seeing this add more depth with time
taste: elegant and feminine medium body with medium+ acidity with nice tones of red fruits, strawberries, and roasted herbs. The tannins are there, but aren't that rough for a young barolo
overall: this is nice, but lacking the depth that you want from a barolo. Good complexity on both the nose and palate, but it's hard seeing this add more depth with time
Red
2006 Elvio Cogno Barolo Cascina Nuova
91 points
nose: very tight and taking a bit to get tones of dark red fruits, perfumes, stawberries and some roasted herbs. Very good depth and tones when they poke out
taste: medium bodied with medium/high acidity and very taught tannins. The tannins are a bit oppressive but with very good tones of tar, roasted herbs, strawberries and dark red fruits. Good depth as well
overall: this was on the tough side. Extremely young, but with something very good being there. What tones did come through were really good on both the nose and palate. This will certainly need time
taste: medium bodied with medium/high acidity and very taught tannins. The tannins are a bit oppressive but with very good tones of tar, roasted herbs, strawberries and dark red fruits. Good depth as well
overall: this was on the tough side. Extremely young, but with something very good being there. What tones did come through were really good on both the nose and palate. This will certainly need time
Red
2006 Poderi Aldo Conterno Barolo
91 points
nose: well balanced but restrained nose of roasted herbs, dark red cherries, black licorice, and tar
taste: very young with the tannins being very coarse right now. Medium/full bodied with medium/high acidity that is fairly piercing along with tones of roasted herbs, dark red cherries, and tar
overall: This is a very young barolo. The tannins are big and chewy with big acidity as well. While not the most complex barolo, this should develop nicely
taste: very young with the tannins being very coarse right now. Medium/full bodied with medium/high acidity that is fairly piercing along with tones of roasted herbs, dark red cherries, and tar
overall: This is a very young barolo. The tannins are big and chewy with big acidity as well. While not the most complex barolo, this should develop nicely
Flight 2 - Tuscany (10 notes)
Red
2006 Argiano Brunello di Montalcino
89 points
nose: on the more extracted side with tones of licorice, black fruits, herbs, and black cherries. Decent depth, but lacking a bit
taste: medium bodied with medium+ acidity and chewy tannins. A bit rough with richer tones of licorice, herbs, dark red fruits and black cherries
overall: A solid brunello. Lacks the savory quality I really want from a brunello. Could use a little time, but this isn't a long haul wine
taste: medium bodied with medium+ acidity and chewy tannins. A bit rough with richer tones of licorice, herbs, dark red fruits and black cherries
overall: A solid brunello. Lacks the savory quality I really want from a brunello. Could use a little time, but this isn't a long haul wine
Red
2006 Argiano Solengo Toscana IGT
88 points
nose: very oak driven nose with rich and extracted tones of anise, black cherries, black fruits, oak, and roasted herbs. Decent depth, but blunted by the oak on the nose
taste: medium/full bodied with very chewy tannins and medium+ acidity. Rich with tones of anise, oak, roasted herbs and black cherries
overall: too much oak and tasted too extracted. It wasn't totally overdone, but it was far from subtle. This could use some time to come together, but I really doubt the oak will pull back enough
taste: medium/full bodied with very chewy tannins and medium+ acidity. Rich with tones of anise, oak, roasted herbs and black cherries
overall: too much oak and tasted too extracted. It wasn't totally overdone, but it was far from subtle. This could use some time to come together, but I really doubt the oak will pull back enough
Red
2006 La Poderina Brunello di Montalcino
91 points
nose: while tight, this was a very savory nose with tones of dark red fruits, berries, red cherries, wild spices and roasted herbs
taste: medium bodied with medium/high acidity and very chewy tannins. Extremely young but with excellent tones of dark red fruits, berries, red cherries and roasted herbs
overall: this is very young, but with some real class behind it. There is an elegant and savory quality to it that is very attractive, but this will certainly need time to really show
taste: medium bodied with medium/high acidity and very chewy tannins. Extremely young but with excellent tones of dark red fruits, berries, red cherries and roasted herbs
overall: this is very young, but with some real class behind it. There is an elegant and savory quality to it that is very attractive, but this will certainly need time to really show
Red
2004 Castello dei Rampolla Sammarco Toscana IGT
92 points
nose: While the nose is on the tight side, it's very savory and quintessentially tuscan with tones of dark red cherries, dark red fruits, spice tones and currants
taste: medium/full bodied with medium+ acidity with big and chewy tannins and savory tones of dark red cherries, dark red fruits, currants and roasted herbs
overall: this is obviously young and in need of serious time. There is a great savory quality to the wine right now and it should really have something to show in a few years
taste: medium/full bodied with medium+ acidity with big and chewy tannins and savory tones of dark red cherries, dark red fruits, currants and roasted herbs
overall: this is obviously young and in need of serious time. There is a great savory quality to the wine right now and it should really have something to show in a few years
Red
2007 Fattoria di Fèlsina Berardenga Chianti Classico Riserva
89 points
nose: nicely balanced an aromatic and savory nose with tones of roasted herbs, dark red cherries, florals, and red fruits.
taste: very good medium body with medium acidity and balanced tones of roasted herbs, dark red cherries, red fruits and spice tones
overall: A really nice felsina ccr. The acidity isn't there as much as in previous vintages and its slightly lacking right now for it. Nice and perfumed, but not as good on the palate
taste: very good medium body with medium acidity and balanced tones of roasted herbs, dark red cherries, red fruits and spice tones
overall: A really nice felsina ccr. The acidity isn't there as much as in previous vintages and its slightly lacking right now for it. Nice and perfumed, but not as good on the palate
Red
2007 Fattoria di Fèlsina Berardenga Fontalloro
92 points
nose: very aromatic with plump tones of dark red cherries, licorice, roasted herbs and dark red fruits. Showing a ripeness on the tones with good depth as well
taste: medium/full bodied with forward and plush tones of dark red cherries, spices, licorice and roasted herbs. Medium+ acidity as well with some chewy tannins as well
overall: Shows off the forward quality to the vintage. There is good balance to it but with a plump and plush quality as well. This could use a few years to smooth out
taste: medium/full bodied with forward and plush tones of dark red cherries, spices, licorice and roasted herbs. Medium+ acidity as well with some chewy tannins as well
overall: Shows off the forward quality to the vintage. There is good balance to it but with a plump and plush quality as well. This could use a few years to smooth out
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Red
2007 Fattoria di Fèlsina Berardenga Chianti Classico Riserva Rancia
92 points
nose: tight, but with good intensity on the savory tones of dark red cherries, roasted herbs, fresh picked roses, spice tones and some red fruits
taste: plush medium body with medium+ acidity and sneaky tannins. Behind the tannins are plush tones of red fruits, dark red cherries, herbs and some fresh picked roses
overall: This could use a few years, but it seems to be an earlier drinking rancia. Well balanced with good acidity+tannins
taste: plush medium body with medium+ acidity and sneaky tannins. Behind the tannins are plush tones of red fruits, dark red cherries, herbs and some fresh picked roses
overall: This could use a few years, but it seems to be an earlier drinking rancia. Well balanced with good acidity+tannins
Red
2008 Tenuta Corte Pavone Rosso di Montalcino
86 points
nose: richer nose with tones of oak, black licorice, dark red fruits and spice tones. On the riper side with the oak certainly showing
taste: fuller bodied with some chewy tannins and medium+ acidity. The tones have a rich quality to them with tones of oak, black licorice and dark red fruits
overall: the oak is a bit too much on both the nose and palate. Not a bashful rosso and fairly full throttled in a sense.
taste: fuller bodied with some chewy tannins and medium+ acidity. The tones have a rich quality to them with tones of oak, black licorice and dark red fruits
overall: the oak is a bit too much on both the nose and palate. Not a bashful rosso and fairly full throttled in a sense.
Red
2004 Tenuta Corte Pavone Brunello di Montalcino Riserva
93 points
nose: deep and powerful nose filled with tones of dark red cherries, spice tones, dark red fruits, violets, herbs and loads of berry flavors. There is a real big intensity on this without being over the top
taste: medium/full bodied with medium/high acidity and chewy tannins. The tannins are very noticeable and behind them are powerful tones of dark red cherries, dark red fruits, violets, herbs and berry tones. There is good layering already behind the tannins
overall: This does need some time to fully round into form, but it should turn into a stunner. The class is there already and it just needs some time to fully speak. Great depth on both the nose and palate right now
taste: medium/full bodied with medium/high acidity and chewy tannins. The tannins are very noticeable and behind them are powerful tones of dark red cherries, dark red fruits, violets, herbs and berry tones. There is good layering already behind the tannins
overall: This does need some time to fully round into form, but it should turn into a stunner. The class is there already and it just needs some time to fully speak. Great depth on both the nose and palate right now
Red
2007 Fattoria Viticcio Chianti Classico Riserva
90 points
nose: fairly plush on the nose with red fruits, berries, herbs and spice tones. Very good depth, but slightly ripe
taste: medium bodied with medium acidity. Plump feel with forward tones of red fruits, berries, and spice tones
overall: An excellent CCR. Is more forward and slightly ripe, but with good balance and depth on both the nose and palate
taste: medium bodied with medium acidity. Plump feel with forward tones of red fruits, berries, and spice tones
overall: An excellent CCR. Is more forward and slightly ripe, but with good balance and depth on both the nose and palate
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Flight 3 - Rest of France (8 notes)
Red
2008 Domaine de la Janasse Châteauneuf-du-Pape Vieilles Vignes
92 points
nose: very good depth and savory nose of licorice, black fruits, black cherries, spice tones and liquer
taste: plush medium/full body with good supporting tannins. Balanced with dark tones of licorice, black fruits, black cherries and liqueur tones
overall: This could use some age, but is pretty open right now. More plump than expected from the vintage with good dark tones on both the nose and palate
taste: plush medium/full body with good supporting tannins. Balanced with dark tones of licorice, black fruits, black cherries and liqueur tones
overall: This could use some age, but is pretty open right now. More plump than expected from the vintage with good dark tones on both the nose and palate
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Red
2008 Château Saint-Roch (Languedoc) Côtes du Roussillon Villages Chimères
89 points
nose: nice and brambly nose of underbrush, licorice, black fruits, spice tones and black currants
taste: silky medium body with nice supporting tannins and tones of licorice, black fruits, black currants and a touch of underbrush
overall: This is a very good wine. Well balanced with more rustic grenache tones.
taste: silky medium body with nice supporting tannins and tones of licorice, black fruits, black currants and a touch of underbrush
overall: This is a very good wine. Well balanced with more rustic grenache tones.
1 person found this helpful
Comment
White - Sparkling
N.V. Diebolt-Vallois Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut
89 points
nose: rich and fragrant nose of citrus, roasted nuts, pears, and warm dough tones. Well balanced, but lacking some depth
taste: balanced medium feel with nice supporting medium+ acidity. There is a nice roundness to the palate with tones of citrus, roasted nuts, some leesy tones, warm dough and some pears
overall: a very good NV. Well balanced and with a fatter take on the nose and palate.
taste: balanced medium feel with nice supporting medium+ acidity. There is a nice roundness to the palate with tones of citrus, roasted nuts, some leesy tones, warm dough and some pears
overall: a very good NV. Well balanced and with a fatter take on the nose and palate.
White - Sparkling
N.V. Gonet-Médeville Champagne Premier Cru Brut Blanc de Noirs
91 points
nose: pretty and balanced nose filled with tones of berries, white fruits, pears and crackers. Good depth with real defined tones as well
taste: excellent and crisp medium feel with noticeable medium+ acidity. Well balanced with good tones of berries crackers and pears
overall: a real winner at the price. Very intriguing on the nose and the acidity is very mouth watering.
taste: excellent and crisp medium feel with noticeable medium+ acidity. Well balanced with good tones of berries crackers and pears
overall: a real winner at the price. Very intriguing on the nose and the acidity is very mouth watering.
White - Sparkling
N.V. Larmandier-Bernier Champagne Premier Cru Blanc de Blancs
91 points
nose: very crisp and precise nose of hazelnuts, almonds, citrus tones, white fruits and mineral tones. Nice depth while being a bit tight on the nose as well
taste: very classy medium feel with medium+ acidity and crisp tones of almonds, hazelnuts, white fruits and mineral tones
overall: this is a really good NV. Well balanced with a real precision to it but with a classy side
taste: very classy medium feel with medium+ acidity and crisp tones of almonds, hazelnuts, white fruits and mineral tones
overall: this is a really good NV. Well balanced with a real precision to it but with a classy side
White - Sparkling
N.V. Larmandier-Bernier Champagne Premier Cru Terre de Vertus
91 points
nose: very complex, but tight, nose of biscuits, dough, white fruits, and green apples. Good depth as well
taste: excellent depth with a very good medium feel and medium/high acidity that is very noticeable. Balanced with real good tones of minerals, biscuits, white fruits, and green apples
overall: This certainly needs a slight bit of age to it to fully settle down. There are some real good tones on both the nose and palate with the class being there for something good
taste: excellent depth with a very good medium feel and medium/high acidity that is very noticeable. Balanced with real good tones of minerals, biscuits, white fruits, and green apples
overall: This certainly needs a slight bit of age to it to fully settle down. There are some real good tones on both the nose and palate with the class being there for something good
White - Sparkling
2005 Larmandier-Bernier Champagne Grand Cru Vieille Vigne de Cramant
92 points
nose: very complex but tight nose with leesy tones, baked bread, almonds, white fruits, wet stones and loads of mineral tones
taste: there is some power behind this with a real good medium feel and very noticeable medium/high acidity. Balanced with real good tones of almonds, white fruits, wet stones, minerals and leesy tones
overall: this does need some time, but there is a lot to like about it. Well balanced with real good depth on both the nose and palate
taste: there is some power behind this with a real good medium feel and very noticeable medium/high acidity. Balanced with real good tones of almonds, white fruits, wet stones, minerals and leesy tones
overall: this does need some time, but there is a lot to like about it. Well balanced with real good depth on both the nose and palate
Rosé - Sparkling
N.V. Larmandier-Bernier Champagne Premier Cru Rosé de Saignée Extra Brut
89 points
nose: nice and balanced nose of red cherries, berries, citrus tones, white fruits, and minerals
taste: well balanced medium/full feel with medium acidity. Good, but straightforward tones of red cherries, minerals, and berry tones
overall: a very good rose, but there is something just missing from this. Well balanced but fairly straightforward and not too complex
taste: well balanced medium/full feel with medium acidity. Good, but straightforward tones of red cherries, minerals, and berry tones
overall: a very good rose, but there is something just missing from this. Well balanced but fairly straightforward and not too complex
Flight 4 - Beaujolais and Burgundy (13 notes)
Red
2010 Marcel Lapierre Morgon
90 points
nose: very fragrant and perfumed nose of fresh picked berries, red fruits, and red floral tones. Nice depth with a very airy quality
taste: pretty and elegant medium feel with medium+ acidity. Balanced with silky tones of berries cherries, red fruits, and some roses
overall: There is a good amount of elegance to this wine. Pretty and perfumed, this needs a little bit of time but shouldn't take too long
taste: pretty and elegant medium feel with medium+ acidity. Balanced with silky tones of berries cherries, red fruits, and some roses
overall: There is a good amount of elegance to this wine. Pretty and perfumed, this needs a little bit of time but shouldn't take too long
Red
2009 Jacky Janodet Moulin-à-Vent Domaine les Fines Graves
89 points
nose: polished nose with tones of dark red fruits, dark red cherries, berries and spice tones
taste: medium bodied with medium acidity and balanced tones of dark red fruits, spice tones and dark red cherries
overall: a nice and silky beaujolais. Very good nose and palate with the nose being better.
taste: medium bodied with medium acidity and balanced tones of dark red fruits, spice tones and dark red cherries
overall: a nice and silky beaujolais. Very good nose and palate with the nose being better.
Red
2008 Domaine Parent Pinot Noir Bourgogne
88 points
nose: very nice and straightforward nose of red fruits spice tones and bits of earth. Good depth for a bourgogne
taste: medium bodied with medium acidity. Balanced with nice depth and tones of red fruits, earth and bits of cherries
overall: a very good bourgogne. Well balanced and drinking perfectly right away. This is really good for the level and very good on the whole
taste: medium bodied with medium acidity. Balanced with nice depth and tones of red fruits, earth and bits of cherries
overall: a very good bourgogne. Well balanced and drinking perfectly right away. This is really good for the level and very good on the whole
Red
2009 Jacques Girardin Bourgogne Cuvée Vieilles Vignes
87 points
nose: forward and easy nose of red fruits, cherries, and bits of berries. Nice and balanced but lacking some depth
taste: very good medium feel with medium acidity and forward tones of red fruits and cherries
overall: a very good bourgogne. Balanced with a more forward take on both the nose and palate
taste: very good medium feel with medium acidity and forward tones of red fruits and cherries
overall: a very good bourgogne. Balanced with a more forward take on both the nose and palate
Red
2009 Jacques Girardin Santenay 1er Cru Clos Rousseau
88 points
nose: riper and upfront nose of red licorice, red fruits, dark red cherries and spice tones
taste: good medium feel with medium+ acidity and tones of spices, red licorice and dark red cherries
overall: a very good pinot, but lacking some typicity. On the riper side both on the nose and palate and lacking some depth as well
taste: good medium feel with medium+ acidity and tones of spices, red licorice and dark red cherries
overall: a very good pinot, but lacking some typicity. On the riper side both on the nose and palate and lacking some depth as well
Red
2007 Domaine du Château de Chorey (Germain) Chorey-les-Beaune
87 points
nose: pretty tones of earth, spices, red fruits and some berry tones. Very good tones, but lacking a bit of depth
taste: very good medium feel with medium acidity and elegant tones of red fruits, spices, and earth tones
overall: If this had a bit more depth on the nose and palate it would be a wonderful wine. But, it's still very nice and a pretty beaune village wine
taste: very good medium feel with medium acidity and elegant tones of red fruits, spices, and earth tones
overall: If this had a bit more depth on the nose and palate it would be a wonderful wine. But, it's still very nice and a pretty beaune village wine
Red
2007 Domaine René Leclerc Bourgogne
87 points
nose: very good and straightforward nose of dark red fruits, spices, and dark red cherries
taste: medium bodied with very good medium acidity. Balanced with nice depth for a bourgogne and good tones of dark red fruits and spice tones
overall: a quality bourgogne. Shows nice depth for the level though it is a bit simple on the palate.
taste: medium bodied with very good medium acidity. Balanced with nice depth for a bourgogne and good tones of dark red fruits and spice tones
overall: a quality bourgogne. Shows nice depth for the level though it is a bit simple on the palate.
Red
2007 Domaine René Leclerc Gevrey-Chambertin
89 points
nose: very good and aromatic nose of dark red cherries, spice tones and earth tones. Textbook on the nose with nice village depth
taste: medium bodied with medium+ acidity. Well balanced with nice depth and excellent tones of dark red cherries, dark berries, spice and earth tones
overall: an excellent gevrey. Well balanced and very open to drink right now. Exactly what you'd want from a gevrey and it can certainly develop further
taste: medium bodied with medium+ acidity. Well balanced with nice depth and excellent tones of dark red cherries, dark berries, spice and earth tones
overall: an excellent gevrey. Well balanced and very open to drink right now. Exactly what you'd want from a gevrey and it can certainly develop further
White
2008 Domaine du Château de Chorey (Germain) Meursault Les Pellans
89 points
nose: well balanced with fat nose with tones of oranges, white fruits, and some white florals. Rather fresh with nice depth, but holding back a bit
taste: rich and full bodied with medium+ acidity that is very noticeable. Balanced with tones of oranges, white fruits, citrus tones, and some bits of white florals
overall: This is quite young and in need of some time. It could use another 3 years to fully unwind and show what it has.
taste: rich and full bodied with medium+ acidity that is very noticeable. Balanced with tones of oranges, white fruits, citrus tones, and some bits of white florals
overall: This is quite young and in need of some time. It could use another 3 years to fully unwind and show what it has.
White
2008 Domaine du Château de Chorey (Germain) Pernand-Vergelesses Les Combottes Blanc
88 points
nose: tightly wound with good tones of lemons, various citrus tones and a touch of white fruits. Very nice nose, but lacking some depth and complexity
taste: excellent and balanced medium feel with medium+ acidity. A bit shy on the palate with tones of citrus, fresh picked lemons and white fruits
overall: This is a nice white burg, but lacking some depth and complexity on both the nose and palate. Seems a bit shy right now, so a couple of years could do it well
taste: excellent and balanced medium feel with medium+ acidity. A bit shy on the palate with tones of citrus, fresh picked lemons and white fruits
overall: This is a nice white burg, but lacking some depth and complexity on both the nose and palate. Seems a bit shy right now, so a couple of years could do it well
White
2008 Domaine Amiot Guy et Fils Chassagne-Montrachet Vieilles Vignes
90 points
nose: very well balanced nose with very good tones of pears, peaches, citrus tones, minerals, and a touch of florals
taste: medium/full bodied with medium+ acidity and well balanced tones of peaches, citrus tones, and minerals. Nice depth, but a little restrained right now with very noticeable acidity
overall: this does need a couple of years. The nose is more open than the palate and the acidity is very sharp right now.
taste: medium/full bodied with medium+ acidity and well balanced tones of peaches, citrus tones, and minerals. Nice depth, but a little restrained right now with very noticeable acidity
overall: this does need a couple of years. The nose is more open than the palate and the acidity is very sharp right now.
White
2007 Marc Colin et Fils Saint-Aubin La Fontenotte Blanc
89 points
nose: upfront and fatter nose of oils, white fruits, oranges, and some marmalade. Nice balance, but lacking some depth
taste: full bodied with medium acidity and tones of oils, white fruits, and marmalade. Well balanced, but a bit lacking on the mid-palate
overall: this is drinking perfectly right now. Good balance on both the nose and palate, but it is slightly lacking in the depth department
taste: full bodied with medium acidity and tones of oils, white fruits, and marmalade. Well balanced, but a bit lacking on the mid-palate
overall: this is drinking perfectly right now. Good balance on both the nose and palate, but it is slightly lacking in the depth department
White
2008 Marc Colin et Fils Puligny-Montrachet Le Trézin
91 points
nose: very good depth, but wound fairly tight with very good tones of white fruits, pears, citrus tones and bits of florals as well
taste: medium/full bodied with very noticeable medium+ acidity. Balanced with good depth and tones of white fruits, pears, and citrus tones
overall: Considering this producer, decanting is the best option. It does need some years, so hopefully it can do that before it meets a premox fate
taste: medium/full bodied with very noticeable medium+ acidity. Balanced with good depth and tones of white fruits, pears, and citrus tones
overall: Considering this producer, decanting is the best option. It does need some years, so hopefully it can do that before it meets a premox fate
Flight 5 - Rieslings (7 notes)
White - Off-dry
2009 Gunderloch Nackenheim Rothenberg Riesling Spätlese
90 points
nose: nice and fresh nose of citrus, mineral tones, white fruits and some pears. Well balanced with nice depth
taste: medium bodied with medium+ acidity. Nice tones of citrus, minerals and pears but lacking a bit on the mid-palate
overall: if this could flesh out a bit more it could be very nice. Well balanced and aromatic but it lacks a mid-palate right now
taste: medium bodied with medium+ acidity. Nice tones of citrus, minerals and pears but lacking a bit on the mid-palate
overall: if this could flesh out a bit more it could be very nice. Well balanced and aromatic but it lacks a mid-palate right now
White - Off-dry
2009 Mönchhof Robert Eymael Ürziger Würzgarten Riesling Spätlese
91 points
nose: nice fresh and tart nose of green apples, pears, fig tones and nectarines. There is a fat quality on the nose that is very nice with some good depth as well
taste: very tasty lighter feel with medium+ acidity. Very well balanced with lighter (but not hollow) tones of green apples, pears, figs and a touch of white fruits
overall: This can be very nice with some age. A little bit of extra weight would be nice, but it isn't too light on either the nose or palate
taste: very tasty lighter feel with medium+ acidity. Very well balanced with lighter (but not hollow) tones of green apples, pears, figs and a touch of white fruits
overall: This can be very nice with some age. A little bit of extra weight would be nice, but it isn't too light on either the nose or palate
White
2009 Dr. F. Weins-Prüm Wehlener Sonnenuhr Riesling Kabinett
88 points
nose: lighter nose of pears, apples, white fruits and apricots. Lacking a slight bit of depth
taste: light body with medium acidity and tones of pears, apples and white fruits. Not really fleshed out on the palate
overall: This is a nice riesling, but without much depth on the nose and palate
taste: light body with medium acidity and tones of pears, apples and white fruits. Not really fleshed out on the palate
overall: This is a nice riesling, but without much depth on the nose and palate
White
2009 Schloss Lieser Riesling
83 points
nose: a good dose of sulfur is noticeable right away along with tones of green apples, pears and a touch of minerals
taste: very light feel with tones of green apples, pears and mineral tones. No real depth though on the palate
overall: a decent wine. There is too much sulfur on the nose with decent tones on the palate
taste: very light feel with tones of green apples, pears and mineral tones. No real depth though on the palate
overall: a decent wine. There is too much sulfur on the nose with decent tones on the palate
White - Off-dry
2008 Zilliken (Forstmeister Geltz) Riesling Butterfly
87 points
nose: nice and crisp nose of pears, white fruits, minerals, and citrus tones. Fragrant, but not that deep
taste: light feel with medium acidity and nice tones of white fruits, minerals and citrus tones
overall: a very good riesling. Nice and balanced with good tones and a good value
taste: light feel with medium acidity and nice tones of white fruits, minerals and citrus tones
overall: a very good riesling. Nice and balanced with good tones and a good value
White
2009 Koehler-Ruprecht Kallstadter Saumagen Riesling Spätlese trocken
91 points
nose: crisp and pristine nose of white fruits, green apples minerals and guava tones. Good balance with nice depth as well
taste: medium body with a real great feel and medium/high acidity and tones of white fruits, white florals, green apples and mineral tones
overall: an extremely interesting riesling. Very good depth and showing it's youth right now. This could be extremely interesting with some age on it
taste: medium body with a real great feel and medium/high acidity and tones of white fruits, white florals, green apples and mineral tones
overall: an extremely interesting riesling. Very good depth and showing it's youth right now. This could be extremely interesting with some age on it
2 people found this helpful
Comment
White - Off-dry
2008 Koehler-Ruprecht Kallstadter Saumagen Riesling Spätlese halbtrocken
91 points
nose: very mineral driven with tones of crushed rocks, pears, bits of wax, oils and a touch of apples. Very complex nose, but lacking some depth
taste: medium bodied with medium+ acidity. Well balanced with a real precision on the palate along with tones of crushed rocks, pears, wax, and apples
overall: this was an extremely interesting riesling. I liked the dry quality to it, but it was lacking some depth on both the nose and palate
taste: medium bodied with medium+ acidity. Well balanced with a real precision on the palate along with tones of crushed rocks, pears, wax, and apples
overall: this was an extremely interesting riesling. I liked the dry quality to it, but it was lacking some depth on both the nose and palate