Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(18 comments on 13 notes)

1 - 13 of 13 Sort order
White - Sparkling
2011 Taittinger Champagne Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut Chardonnay
11/12/2023 - GuanYu Likes this wine:
94 points
Uncorked another bottle last evening at a good friend's birthday dinner party. Drank it with Tiramisu birthday cake at the end of dinner. The Taittinger CdC BdB 2011 was fresh, smooth and well-balanced. It held up very well despite consuming 9 mix bottles of chardonnay, pinot noir and syrah among 7 people prior to the Taittinger.
  • GuanYu commented:

    12/7/23, 7:57 AM - If in doubt, open both: They taste so good and would disappear fast. DP 2008 is definitely better than CdC BdB 2011.

  • GuanYu commented:

    12/8/23, 9:02 AM - Agreed. DP2008 is for very special occasion as it would age very well for decades. Whereas for me, the CdC BdB 2011 is for any special occasion, including a fabricated one, because I got them at steep discounts, thanks to all the negative reviews out there. That is why I commented that if one is willing to open the DP2008, then the occasion must be very special and should not hold back to open the lesser CdC BdB 2011.

White
2020 Armand Heitz Bourgogne Blanc Chardonnay
9/28/2021 - ramtu Does not like this wine:
70 points
I've enjoyed many bottles of Domaine Heitz-Lochardet (emphasis on domaine) Bourgogne Blanc from 2014 to 2018 (Durots was the lieu-dit at that point). This is the first négoce Armand Heitz wine I have tried and despite my opening two bottles (after first showed some oxidation) the singeing alcohol and almost total lack of fruit of the second bottle force me to conclude that I've bought my first and last Armand Heitz (négoce) Bourgogne Blanc. (It also moved me to write my first cellar tracker tasting note). Hopefully the domaine wines are as good as they have always been.
  • GuanYu commented:

    11/15/23, 12:03 AM - Yes, starting with 2019 vintage, all Domaine Heitz-Lochardet wines are labeled as Armand Heitz. Thanks to Armand Rousseau and Comte Armand, "Armand Heitz" is much more marketable to an international audience than Heitz-Lochardet.

White - Sparkling
2011 Taittinger Champagne Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut Chardonnay
10/14/2023 - GuanYu Likes this wine:
94 points
Shiny pale yellow gold with lush bubbles. Lemon oil, green apple, hazelnut, honey-glazed almond, pastry, and oyster shell. Delicate and complex, medium-long finish.

This 2011 didn't have as much depth and length as some better vintages like 2008, but nevertheless a Blanc de Blancs with good finesse. It reminded me of the 2007 vintage, especially in the back palate.

Some of the negative reviews did not do this 2011 justice. I wonder if Taittinger may have had some cork quality issues or other unusual circumstances which led to larger than normal number of flawed bottles.
  • GuanYu commented:

    10/16/23, 9:26 AM - Thanks. Ironically, I am able to get steep discounts on the 2011 CdC BdB due to the bad reviews. 2011 has become a bargain vintage. LOL

White - Sparkling
2011 Taittinger Champagne Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut Chardonnay
7/21/2023 - ubercuvee wrote:
Taittingers Comtes blanc night (Noize, London): Absolutely appalling Comtes. We opened 99/00/02/04/06/07/08/11/12 and not only was the 2011 dead last, it was dead last by a mile. It doesn't deserve to be spoken about in the same sentence as all the others.
On the palate this is atypically thin, herbaceous and astringent with a short finnish.
A total waste of money: buy any other Comtes but this. I hate to agree with Galloni, but this should never should have been released under the Comtes label - it does a disservice to the incredible wines they usually make.
  • GuanYu commented:

    10/9/23, 12:56 PM - Do you think you have a flawed bottle on the 2011?

    I had a 2008 CdC BdB previously with the exact tasting notes as your 2011. I knew it was flawed because I had drunken many bottles of 2008 around same time period.

  • GuanYu commented:

    10/9/23, 1:10 PM - I see. Maybe that explained why the 2011 vintage is selling much cheaper than the other vintages. I will get a bottle of 2011 in the near future, and report back, in case the Sommelier's entire lot of 2011 was flawed or spoiled.

  • GuanYu commented:

    10/15/23, 11:02 AM - I bought a bottle of 2011 from local wine shop, and tried it last night. It was actually pretty good. Not as much depth and length as 2008, but would hold up to be a Comtes de Champagne IMHO. Nothing green, herbaceous, or astringent at all.

Red
2015 Tenuta Caparzo Brunello di Montalcino Vigna La Casa Sangiovese
10/13/2023 - GuanYu wrote:
A year since I provided my last tasting notes on this bottle. I had a few bottles since then, with the last one drank in February 2023. They were all fabulous.

Suddenly, this bottle seemed to be in retreat. Perhaps an odd bottle variation, but it seemed the wine had withdrawn into a sleeping phase. Wine was closed and muted despite long breathing and left in fridge for tasting until next day. There were definitely the usual notes of red fruits, tobacco, fig and tar; and the tannin was quite overwhelming due to the subdued fruits.

ADDENDUM (Oct 15, 2023): I left the remaining half bottle in the fridge for the 2nd day (2 nights). I took it out of the fridge in the morning and let it warm up to room temperature. When I tasted it in the evening, about 48 hours after uncorking, the wine finally blossomed!! However, due to the extended aeration, wine had gone slightly sour and off-balance.
  • GuanYu commented:

    10/15/23, 9:35 AM - Thank you for your confirmation. I shall do the same, not touching my remaining 15s for at least 1 year.

White
2012 Hugel Riesling Schoelhammer Alsace
6/22/2023 - GuanYu Likes this wine:
96 points
Tasted at winery. Single vineyard version of Riesling Grossi Laüe. Shiny pale yellow with green tint. Fresh, crystalline. Citrus, green apple, white flowers, honeysuckle, Meyer lemon. High acidity. Long clean, lime finish. Viscous palate, very appetizing and lively. More youthful than the cuvee version of 2012 Riesling Grossi Laüe.

My favorite dry wine, red or white, of the winery.
  • GuanYu commented:

    8/28/23, 1:23 PM - Hi Lord of the Bottles, Hugel's Schoelhammer and Trimbach's Clos St. Hune are very different wine. Both Riesling, but different style. Different vintages would also taste differently. Since I have not done direct comparison, I would not be able to be specific. For example, I just drank a 2000 Clos St. Hune last Thursday. I wrote down some tasting notes. That was quite powerful and complex. My recollection of Schoelhammer was sharper and racier, but that was due to younger vintage of Schoelhammer that I drank. If you are interested, I would recommend you to find a few friends and get a bottle of each from the same vintage and do a comparison.

White
2020 Weingut Keller Riesling von der Fels Rheinhessen
7/27/2023 - GuanYu Likes this wine:
92 points
Shiny pale yellow with green tint. Citrus, green apple, honeysuckle, and minerality. Fresh and vibrant. Clean finish.

While this bottle tasted very good, Keller's Grosses Gewachs are 10x better.
  • GuanYu commented:

    7/27/23, 9:57 PM - You are very welcome. Yes, Keller is a world class winery, and their wines are made to keep. Specifically this bottle was fresh and youthful, and had a lot of fruits and acidity. It would easily last another 15 years, so long as cellar conditions are good. I would probably drink this young, and cellar their GGs for the longer term.

  • GuanYu commented:

    7/29/23, 12:32 AM - Hi IlliniWine, very lucky that you have so many bottles. Keller's bottles, GG or not, are usually by allocations.

    I just opened another 2020 von der Fels for breakfast. This time, the wine was even better, probably because I had a fresh palate myself. As a result, I have upgraded the scores I provided earlier in order to be fair to the wine.

    I have separately wrote a tasting story here on a range of Keller GGs last April 2023. It was an unforgettable experience.

  • GuanYu commented:

    8/3/23, 1:57 AM - Hi IlliniWine, I wrote it in the "Tasting Story" section. I will get in touch with CT to find out more. Maybe I need to publish it, which I haven't done it yet.

White
2019 Domaine Ostertag Riesling Muenchberg Alsace Grand Cru
6/17/2023 - GuanYu Likes this wine:
95 points
Pale yellow gold with green tint. Red apple, apricot, smoked pear and honey. Slight viscosity on the palate, round, long and clean finish.

We paired it with charcoal grilled tandoori chicken and curry. All my Burgundies were demolished by the curry spices, but this Ostertag held up above and beyond the call of culinary duty.

I saved some for next morning, Father's Day crepe breakfast. It held up well and the honey became more pronounced.
  • GuanYu commented:

    7/20/23, 2:37 AM - Thank you for your kind words. This Alsatian Riesling has residual sugar, but the high acidity balanced the sweetness perfectly. It didn't feel sticky at all.

White
2021 Weingut Hajszan-Neumann Grüner Veltliner Natural Wien
12/15/2022 - DerBismarck Likes this wine:
78 points
Cloudy, medium goldyellow

Clear, medium intensity, apple+ brioche +camomile

Dry, low acidity, no tannines, medium body, medium intensity, apple + brioche, short aftertaste

Conclusion: I love the nose on this wine it has a lot of different aspects however the taste is less complex and the aftertaste a little short I would rate this wine 78/100 I would definitely drink this again.
  • GuanYu commented:

    5/26/23, 7:20 PM - I wondered if you had a flawed bottle. Some of your comments (apple, brioche, camomile) were spot on, but some of them (low acidity, short aftertaste) suggested to me that you might have had an off bottle.

Red
2012 Domaine Drouhin-Laroze Chapelle-Chambertin Chapelle-Chambertin Grand Cru Pinot Noir
Medium intensity, nose is more complex and focused than the Au Closeaux 2012. Palate is deeper but not extremely complex: spices, notes of cherry...nothing special, would not waste 130$ on that wine.
  • GuanYu commented:

    5/10/23, 12:17 PM - 2015 might have been too early for this bottle (or any Grand Cru's in 2012) to show its promise.

Rosé - Sparkling
2008 Billecart-Salmon Champagne Cuvée Elisabeth Salmon Champagne Blend
9/5/2022 - GuanYu Likes this wine:
97 points
One of the finest rose champagne bottles I have tasted. Full-bodied, intense, balanced, and complex. Each sip revealed a different taste: apricot, candied orange, petals, berries, and even Coca-Cola. Fine bubbles, excellent mid-palate and long dry finish.
  • GuanYu commented:

    2/15/23, 9:46 PM - Hi Sheriff,

    Yes, I do think so. 2008 is a superlative vintage in Champagne. Just check here the recent tasting notes of earlier notable vintages. They would give you a peek review of how 2008 would become in the future.

White
2014 Olivier Leflaive Puligny-Montrachet Les Enseignères Chardonnay
11/1/2022 - GuanYu Likes this wine:
93 points
Citrus, mild butter, pear, white flowers, and minerality. Excellent mid-palate and long finish. Very well-balanced and delightful. We paired this with a bottle of 2014 Vincent Dauvissat Chablis 1er Cru Vaillons, and this Olivier Leflaive super village wine performed better.
  • GuanYu commented:

    12/31/22, 11:03 PM - Hi Palisades57,

    Thank you for your comment. Yes, we did decant the 2014 Dauvissat for hours. We drank it during lunch at a restaurant and so couldn't save any for next day. I still have another bottle which I will cellar for some time before trying it again.

Red
2017 Gros Frère et Sœur Bourgogne Hautes-Côtes de Nuits Pinot Noir
1/30/2021 - carstenf wrote:
82 points
Nose with cooked fruit and some sauer notes. Taste is not pleasent with heavy green notes.
I am not happy...Very seldom I don’t enjoy Bourgogne, but this was one. Something wrong with the bottle ?
  • GuanYu commented:

    10/28/21, 9:34 PM - I share your sentiment.

1 - 13 of 13
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close