1997 Joseph Phelps Insignia

Community Tasting Note

wrote:

94 Points

Saturday, September 27, 2008 - Even though we only paid $80 for this wine, it still is perhaps the most "valuable" wine we have drunk ever (and we drink a lot of wine) so rating it is a challenge. You know, objectivity? Anyhow, my first impressions. stll at cellar temps and decanted for 5 minutes were that it had that "explosive" nose I read others talking about. Sometimes I think that is BS, but in this case, the wine did jump out of the glass with a hint of skunk, earth, anise/licorice and berry. On warming, the skunk, thankfully, blew off quite quickly (reduction?) to reveal a more even nose, not actually quite as nice or complex but still good. That nose was more minty/licorice with a slighty musty, earthy odor that was not unpleasant, despite my description. Very well integrated, mature but still bright flavors of blue fruit, mint, oak, scotch (barrel?) with quite refined and pleasant, easy finishing tannin and just enough acidity to make it zing. Really quite nice, although I would not spend $200 retail on it, maybe in a restaurant if someone else was paying.

Post a Comment / View guitarguy's profile
Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Report Issue (8,285 views)
×
×