Saturday, May 27, 2023 - Napa evening with one bottle of Bordeaux (semiblind):
2016 Dunn Howell Mountain: A bit thin, lacking power. I have only had the 2013 before, but it was better. Wait 5 years or so: 92 pts.
2017 Beringer Private Reserve: A really good wine with depth and seductive fruit, without being over the top. 95 pts
2018 Gallica - I really liked the 2008 but the 2018 was just so-so: 91 pts
2019 Chateau Issan: Not convincing. Loved the 2018 but the 2019 did not deliver. 90 pts.
All bottles were opened 5 days in advance and then decanted before dinner. They all improved during our dinner.
Comment posted by Sdr69:
6/1/2023 5:26:00 AM - 5 days in advance?
Comment posted by Sundbyberg:
6/1/2023 7:02:00 AM - See the same question and my corresponding comment on 2019 chateau Issan.