Community Tasting Note
-
Cailles wrote: 91 points
November 23, 2022 - Ten Vintages Haut Bailly vs Mission HB: Preamble: All wines tasted blind in 10 vintage flights (1994-2015). To every flight one random third wine from Pessac Leognan added (2x Haut Brion, 2x Smith, 2x Pape Clement, 1x Branon, 1x Luchy Halde, 1x Carmes, 1x Chevalier). All wines opened a few hours before consumption but no decanting.
Some findings:
1) Haut Bailly outperformed Mission (5 vs 4 wins, 92.5 vs 90.5 average). 2) Haut Bailly is a rather structured wine which seems to shine bright in ripe and warm vintages, without any form of excess ripeness or extraction. 3) When done right (05/15), Mission eclipses Haut Bailly with its depth and delineation , but several vintages showed a bit too ripe but especially with the alcohol not well masked (09/10). 4) Pessac wines usually need quite some air to open up. In this setting (no decanting), most wines needed a lot of swirling to fully open up and will need more cellar time. 5) The best wines today were Haut Bailly 09 (96pts) & 10 (95pts) and Mission 05 & 15 (95pts).
TN: Fairly discree nose with a bit of dark fruit and herbs. On the palate this is a bit astringent, not enough fruit to be truly balanced. But with time this opens up a bit showing fresh fruit and some minerality. Overall medium balance, not much substance. 2008 doesn’t seem to be a winning vintage for Pessac wines.
Decanting: 1-2 hours should be enough.3,375 views
1 Comment
-
Eclectic Palate commented:
8/17/23, 11:21 AM - I very much appreciate how you all structured these tastings and reporting your findings. HB readily appears to be a "value buy" in comparison to LMHB. I will certainly consider this info when buying back vintages at auction!